User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > How exactly is this a missed tackle on an incomplete pass?
Vigorous
offline
Link
 
That is impossible in football. If it was a catch and he dropped the ball then its a fumble. If its an incomplete pass then there was not attempt at a tackle because the player never had the ball.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=176988&pbp_id=2042254
 
JD Cuda
offline
Link
 
Haha, yeah I've seen that happen two other times too.

The best I can figure is that:
1. the player "caught" it
2. the first defender flew by and couldn't tackle him
3. the second defender knocked the ball loose
4. the ref/sim/whatever ruled it as incomplete instead of a fumble because it wasn't in possession long enough

Still, it's something that needs to eventually be fixed.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
the wr was bobbling the catch, guy tried to tackle and he dropped it. since he never had control it was called an incomplete eventhough the defender missed tackling him BEFORE he dropped it.
 
Vigorous
offline
Link
 
Again you can not be credited with a Tackle unless you are Tackling a guy with possession of the ball. If the guy had possession and then someone attempted to tackle him and then he dropped the ball then its a fumble.

I have tried to see this the other way ... and it does not make any sence.
 
jdbstealth
offline
Link
 
I had the exact same thing happen and posted it here this morning. Crazy stuff.
 
PS3
offline
Link
 
Wow I've just seen that happen too in one of my team's games and I was wondering what that was about.

I've seen what looks like "bobbling" pass from a WR and a CB or safety come in and deflect it away but I don't think I've seen the missed tackle and then a deflection before.

 
t3chn9ne
offline
Link
 
That's easy. The guy who missed the tackle tried to tackle the receiver who was bobbling the ball but some other defender finally knocked the ball away
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 22:10:35
 
PS3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Willie49419
That's easy. The guy who missed the tackle tried to tackle the receiver who was bobbling the ball but some other defender finally knocked the ball away



Except I thought you need to actually have possession of the ball for a player to be credited for a tackle so a "missed tackle" seems to apply the WR had possession before the CB could even attempt to make a tackle. So if the WR had possession enough for the defender to be credited with a "missed tackle", shouldn't it be a fumble and not a incomplete?



 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Its a cornucopia of fuckness!
 
Vigorous
offline
Link
 
LOL... PS3 that is what I was trying to say!!!!
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.