User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > HUGE PROBLEM FOR QB's WITH THSI BUILD!@!@!@!@!@!@!@!@!@!@!@!@!@!@!@
sabourin1
offline
Link
 
K for all the scrambling qb's out their this forum is for you. The issue is for where qb's scramble, The problem with qb's scrambling is that they never scramble into open space. Second of all Qb's also never scramble outside the pocket witch is a HUGE PROBLEM for scrambling qb's. By the way my qb's vision is (51.27).

PLZ address this problem!

Examples: These plays are not draws...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=188281&pbp_id=748761 (If he were to have scrambles to his left he would have gained alot more yards.)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=188281&pbp_id=749550 (If he were to have scrambled to his left he would have had a huge gain compared to a 1 yard gain.)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=188281&pbp_id=746834 (If he bounces out side to his left he is gone!)
 
Bigmo6967
offline
Link
 
Everytime you say scramble left I see a defensive end there with outside position on your OT. Congratulate him for not scrambling left because all 3 times he would have been sacked.
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
I think that QB needs to work on his patience stat. Second and 3rd plays he had guys wide open at the first down marker but he chose to run it. First play it's freakin' 3rd and 13.5, his only chance at a first down was to roll out (not implemented properly) and hope someone popped open, even running left and assuming the Oline holds the Dline, the FS was going to be all over him and tackle him for about 4th and 6.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
It was a designed run, not a pass.
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist
It was a designed run, not a pass.


Well, that's somewhat true, but in the sim, all the QB runs are based from pass plays. All that happens is the QB run % kicks in, everyone else on the play starts out running one of the pass play options for that formation, but after the QB drops back, he runs a draw. The rest of the team doesn't start run blocking until the QB takes a step forward. Having these plays as a frequent option for 3rd and long is just a bad idea.

The OP has a definite point though as QB judgement on when and where to scramble is very poor... I've seen my team push the D-line all the way around behind the QB, and have the QB move forward towards the line of scrimmage with 15+ yards of open field in front of him, only to throw the ball at a well-covered guy, and they've done this multiple times even on 1st and 2nd downs. However all 3 replays the OP showed were plays called based on the QB run % in the AI, not the QB's judgement to scramble.
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
The only problem here is that the Original Post is talking about QB Running plays, those things that're CALLED runs in the playbook. QB Scrambling is something that occurs when basically all else fails - the pocket breaks down or there's a beefcake DE charging like a rhinoceros at his face, and he's got to make a split-second decision to launch a bad pass, or turn and try to get separation and launch a better pass a couple seconds later by scrambling out of the pocket.

Now, QB Scrambling DOES include rushing, but it's not the same thing. A QB rush and a QB scramble can be distinguished very easily: A Rush is a play that's designed for the QB to run with the ball and try to freak the defense out because they weren't expecting it - QB Sneak comes to mind. Conversely, a scramble is when a pass play is called, and things go horribly wrong, forcing the QB to exit the pocket and either tuck and run on the ground, or stay behind the line of scrimmage until someone's open and then launch the pass.

I'm an advocate for fixing the scrambling aspect of this game - not just fixing, but simply putting it into the game, period, since fixing something means it's not working properly...well, scrambling doesn't ever happen, so we have no idea if it works or not. (Obviously, it doesn't since it's not in the game, but I'm just saying...)
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 07:35:57
 
Motiak
offline
Link
 
Based on what I was seeing with your OL, I doubt bouncing it outside would've done anything as the DEs were getting off their blocks and were definitely faster than your QB.
 
tonylieu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnerhero
The only problem here is that the Original Post is talking about QB Running plays, those things that're CALLED runs in the playbook. QB Scrambling is something that occurs when basically all else fails - the pocket breaks down or there's a beefcake DE charging like a rhinoceros at his face, and he's got to make a split-second decision to launch a bad pass, or turn and try to get separation and launch a better pass a couple seconds later by scrambling out of the pocket.

Now, QB Scrambling DOES include rushing, but it's not the same thing. A QB rush and a QB scramble can be distinguished very easily: A Rush is a play that's designed for the QB to run with the ball and try to freak the defense out because they weren't expecting it - QB Sneak comes to mind. Conversely, a scramble is when a pass play is called, and things go horribly wrong, forcing the QB to exit the pocket and either tuck and run on the ground, or stay behind the line of scrimmage until someone's open and then launch the pass.

I'm an advocate for fixing the scrambling aspect of this game - not just fixing, but simply putting it into the game, period, since fixing something means it's not working properly...well, scrambling doesn't ever happen, so we have no idea if it works or not. (Obviously, it doesn't since it's not in the game, but I'm just saying...)


Scrambling does happen The secondary just needs to cover receivers well enough for it to happen.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=162662&pbp_id=2001195
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=162662&pbp_id=1999988
 
Juan Fiddy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Motiak
Based on what I was seeing with your OL, I doubt bouncing it outside would've done anything as the DEs were getting off their blocks and were definitely faster than your QB.


+1

The only play which would have likely made more yards based on moving outside the pocket was the first one, each other play has the end to the outside of the tackle which generally gives him plenty of time to break the block and run the ball carrier down.
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bigmo6967
Everytime you say scramble left I see a defensive end there with outside position on your OT. Congratulate him for not scrambling left because all 3 times he would have been sacked.


you fail to see the DE that would have jacked you up all 3 times you tried to run left. you forget that on alot of teams some of the fastes players on Def are the RDE there is no way you get around the corner with out that guy jacking you up. the LT will keep him from coming in to get you but once you get left of the LT he is no help to you unless he holds the guy. All 3 plays you go left your QB is toast.
 
sabourin1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bigmo6967
Everytime you say scramble left I see a defensive end there with outside position on your OT. Congratulate him for not scrambling left because all 3 times he would have been sacked.


k my qb's got 80+ speed i bet he can out run these's d ends there is a tone of space for him to go around them....
 
BigDaddyTim
offline
Link
 
you are wrong he would get jacked up. If your QB has 80 speed and 80 agility and 80 carry then maybe he gets around the DE but if not your a setting duck and your going to get jacked up.
 
HydrOshocK
offline
Link
 
I'd load the box and bring all out blitzes against that QB because if you have 80 speed then he obviously can't throw worth a damn.
 
Blowcaine
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HydrOshocK
I'd load the box and bring all out blitzes against that QB because if you have 80 speed then he obviously can't throw worth a damn.


example, mike vick
Last edited Sep 26, 2008 13:44:40
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.