User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Link
 
Give me one good reason why a CB would bite on a pump fake and move towards that part of the field and just leave the WR to keep streaking down the field?

CBs wouldnt do that, Ive never seen it once in my life.
Maybe we need a stupidity attribute??

If the WR is running a go-route, the CBs not even looking at the QB to begin with. The WR didnt even give a move he was runnign straight down the field lol

I dont understand it, for a lack of a better term its just stupid.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=187718&pbp_id=880386
Last edited Sep 20, 2008 13:38:02
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
I actually think the plays look a lot more realistic now. WR look like they are running stop n' go routes or the defender thinks the ball is going elsewhere and tries to jump it.
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
tbh, If you're thinking realistically, that's exactly where the pump fake would be useful - at the beginning of the route, before the route is tipped off, the corner bumps the fake and the WR flys by. Given the position of the dots, that seems a reasonable explanation.

I do agree that if it were a bit farther in the go, the corner would not bite a pump because his back would be turned - however, I don't believe our dots have "faces" or cone vision.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by superpunk
however, I don't believe our dots have "faces" or cone vision.


Like they should...???
 
feedy
offline
Link
 
maybe a cb wouldnt bite as hard if his backs turned but he'll know if he should be looking for the ball even on a go.
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
Of course they "should", but I'm not sure that they do. They're programmed to react certain way based on inputs from the other side, and then when the pivotal moment comes there is a sort of "roll" based on attributes that determines whether you catch/pass defend/ intercept/tackle/break a tackle/etc. But I don't believe what they can "see" ever plays into that.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
I think the OP is saying "If Pump Fakes ever work, that's unrealistic."

This one was extremely realistic. The CB would have been backpedaling, now knowing what route was being run. The QB pump fakes throwing to a hitch, so the CB pauses, and the receiver streaks through and is open.
 
T2
Killuh
offline
Link
 
With all the team playing man coverage and man coverage has the DB playing the man rather than the QB...the OP is right, pump fake should not be that great of a weapon. This should only work on players covering zones IMO.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TenTwo
With all the team playing man coverage and man coverage has the DB playing the man rather than the QB...the OP is right, pump fake should not be that great of a weapon. This should only work on players covering zones IMO.


HUH????

First, the fake in this case appeared to be a short pass to the CB's man, and then he threw later to him deep. The CB, if fooled, would definitely have stopped.

Secondly, man coverage still works too well compared to zones. Do you want to see no zone defense ever played? I still think zones need improvement and tight man coverage should, if anything, be nerfed even more (but balanced with better zone coverage), because most CB's can't get away in real life with tight man coverage often.
 
cosmoxl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by TenTwo

With all the team playing man coverage and man coverage has the DB playing the man rather than the QB...the OP is right, pump fake should not be that great of a weapon. This should only work on players covering zones IMO.


HUH????

First, the fake in this case appeared to be a short pass to the CB's man, and then he threw later to him deep. The CB, if fooled, would definitely have stopped.

Secondly, man coverage still works too well compared to zones. Do you want to see no zone defense ever played? I still think zones need improvement and tight man coverage should, if anything, be nerfed even more (but balanced with better zone coverage), because most CB's can't get away in real life with tight man coverage often.


zone defense does need to get a lot better.

the point that defenders in man won't bite on a pump fake as easily is that they usually will have their back to the QB as they are keeping up with the WR. In zone the defenders can keep their eye in the backfield more easily.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TenTwo
With all the team playing man coverage and man coverage has the DB playing the man rather than the QB...the OP is right, pump fake should not be that great of a weapon. This should only work on players covering zones IMO.


Quoted for truth.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Pump fake should only work against defenders playing on aggressive, for defenders who are playing on medium (backoff a bit more) it shouldn't work that much; against defenders playing loose, it should not work at all.
 
cosmoxl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Pump fake should only work against defenders playing on aggressive, for defenders who are playing on medium (backoff a bit more) it shouldn't work that much; against defenders playing loose, it should not work at all.


that's a good point too.
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Pump fake should only work against defenders playing on aggressive, for defenders who are playing on medium (backoff a bit more) it shouldn't work that much; against defenders playing loose, it should not work at all.


Well, Coverage Style should be a big part of the equation. But Vision should also.

And the idea that pump fakes don't work against M2M is ridiculous.
 
cosmoxl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shield.bearer
Originally posted by datongw

Pump fake should only work against defenders playing on aggressive, for defenders who are playing on medium (backoff a bit more) it shouldn't work that much; against defenders playing loose, it should not work at all.


Well, Coverage Style should be a big part of the equation. But Vision should also.

And the idea that pump fakes don't work against M2M is ridiculous.


why ridiculous? in M2M the defender should be focusing only on his man, not what the QB is doing. Good M2M in the NFL has the defender looking into the eyes of the receiver to know when the ball is coming.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.