User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Divide Advance Equipment into Departments
Page:
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
When you get to the store let there be an option to let you choose what kind of equipment you want.

Tackling, Speed, Blocking, Catching, passing, etc

and once you click on that then you get the 3 random equipment choices.

Punters getting 1st step
QBs getting big hit
DT getting pancake SA

none of this makes sense.

DT should be able to choose strength OR tackling department and then pick what is available.
 
KellerFox
offline
Link
 
Well, sometimes is nice to get SA's outside of your current build selection... and Bort has said that they work. I agree with you that there are some that are just a waste of space but I also think they offer a great oppurtunity to improve your builds.

A DT with Pancake might not be so bad, would allow them to get to the QB quickly for a Sack by collapsing the pocket almost immidiately.
 
lrunkle911
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KellerFox
Well, sometimes is nice to get SA's outside of your current build selection... and Bort has said that they work. I agree with you that there are some that are just a waste of space but I also think they offer a great oppurtunity to improve your builds.

A DT with Pancake might not be so bad, would allow them to get to the QB quickly for a Sack by collapsing the pocket almost immidiately.


i think you missed the point. all you would have to do is choose to looks at blocking equipment if you where a DT wanting pancake.

it should be more refined on what you can get based on what you are looking for as if I am going shopping i don't blindy walk into random stores if I know what i am looking for.

my guard in 3 shopping trips got tackling gear 7 or the 9 times. that is just plain broke. having the option of going into a blocking store or a tackling store or a passing store would make things a lot easier for everyone.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KellerFox
Well, sometimes is nice to get SA's outside of your current build selection... and Bort has said that they work. I agree with you that there are some that are just a waste of space but I also think they offer a great oppurtunity to improve your builds.

A DT with Pancake might not be so bad, would allow them to get to the QB quickly for a Sack by collapsing the pocket almost immidiately.


but if a WR wants an SA in another ability he can chose that. If a WR wants something in a blocking SA he can also choose blocking.

the suggestion is have things divided up and you can go back and forth between sections but the equipment in each of those sections are randomly generated like they are now but focus on those specific areas.


 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
My punter has gotten nothing but tacling, big hit, or first step who wants that.

Oh another one of my punters got throwing????????????
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Good idea IMO.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
My punter has gotten nothing but tacling, big hit, or first step who wants that.

Oh another one of my punters got throwing????????????


First step should improve his punting motion
 
KellerFox
offline
Link
 
Well my experiance (out of about 10 total trips) hasnt been nearly as bad as you two... ive only gotton 3 or 4 pieces total that havent been related to my players respective positions and of those 3 or 4 pieces all of them were actually something that I would be interested in had my current equipment not been better.

I think part of Borts intentions was that it indeed is a blind shot, you dont know what your going to get. Frankly I think the general idea is that our current equipment will be better but if you cant afford it this is an escape from that finacial burden to still be competitive.

If your able to choose why not just specify that I was +5 strength with a +2 pancake SA? See that eliminates the whole purpouse of chance, even if your just limiting it to what type of gear you want. I can agree that perhaps Bort should limit it to stuff that would be of interest to each position, but I think its rediculous to want to be able to specify what you want before it even comes up. I love the fact that my FS is getting CB SA's and my CB FS SA's. My LB had some DE abilities come up, and my OG had the option to add Absord pain or Pancake.

As I said, it seems you two have had a different experiance than I have... but mine has been great and I dont see the need to change it.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by Robbnva

My punter has gotten nothing but tacling, big hit, or first step who wants that.

Oh another one of my punters got throwing????????????


First step should improve his punting motion


that is probably what bort would say but I don't believe it
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
I don't think bort even put in any punting equipment
 
KellerFox
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Robbnva
I don't think bort even put in any punting equipment


Might be the case, and I can understand your frustration but I think what your proposing takes all the randomness out of it.

This would be like eliminating the RNG from the game sims and just giving the win to the team who has the highest level average. I think the solution would be to limit the generated equipment to pieces that might be of some interest to the said position of the player.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by KellerFox
Originally posted by Robbnva

I don't think bort even put in any punting equipment


Might be the case, and I can understand your frustration but I think what your proposing takes all the randomness out of it.

This would be like eliminating the RNG from the game sims and just giving the win to the team who has the highest level average. I think the solution would be to limit the generated equipment to pieces that might be of some interest to the said position of the player.


there is still randomness, DTs shoudl not get blocking atributes unless they want to, since they are only limited to 3 right now, that is a choice that is wasted.
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
My FG kicker should also not get 3 pieces of equipment with tackling and no choice for kicking.

NOT A SINGLE PIECE OF KICKING EQUIPMENT
 
po
offline
Link
 
Damn I guess I wasted my idea since its nearly identical to yours...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1067561

I would like to see us being able to trade equipment between players as well.

Could add a little bit to the game.
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
I think this is a good idea.

Another idea would be to make sure at least one piece out of three is relevent to your class with the other two random.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.