User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America A Leagues > South America A #1 > **Monticello's Weekly Top 10 Coaches Poll**
Page:
 
Monticello
offline
Link
 
I figured someone needs to do something like this on a consistent basis so I will head it up.

I need voters who will commit to sending me their votes for a top 10 the night after EVERY regular season game. If you cannot make this commitment, then DO NOT sign up for the poll. Results will only be accurate if the same people vote each week.

**Only 1 designated voter is allowed per team**. That person must be either the owner or a GM on the team.

You don't have to use any kind of formula to vote. Just use simple observation just like an AP poll voter would do in college football. You must commit to being as objective as you possibly can. If I start receiving votes with 9 Alpha Teams in the top 10 I will remove voting abilities from that team. That does not mean that you have to give token votes either just for the sake of being "objective" either. Just be fair.

Only vote for 10 teams in your poll. I figure no one really cares who the #25 team in the league is so lets just make this a ranking of the heavy hitters. I might put an "also received votes" section or something.

You CAN vote for your own team, but don't put them at #1 if they have 4 losses, nor at #10 if they have 8 losses. That will be grounds for your removal from the poll.

I will start a new thread each game week with the results. That way we can comment on each week.

I would say we could add an offensive and defensive player of the week, but the game offers no way to look at weekly stats in mass and I'm afraid it would just be every owner voting for the best player out of his team and the team they played. So, lets just keep it simple.

We will however, use these same voters to configure a Pro Bowl/ All America team at the end of the season with players of the year, etc.

If you can make this commitment, respond in this thread with what team you will be representing.
 
StoutOne
offline
Link
 
What about Associated Press (me), can we vote since it will be unbiased?
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Hmmm...this sounds pretty good, but I am afraid that I could not do much justice to the Zeta teams. I just don't have time to scout them at all or really keep up with them beyond a cursory view of their records.

That being said, I will still give it a shot if you like...I do think the two game preseason schedule helps determine a bit about where the line is drawn between conferences, and that helps at least.



 
Monticello
offline
Link
 
yea, sure. Give it a shot.
 
jrogish
offline
Link
 
If we're still doing this pawpawynana will submit the Piranhas' vote.
 
Link
 
Hmm I might be up for this
 
Monticello
offline
Link
 
There is not a lot of interest so I don't plan on heading this up. If anyone else wants to then feel free.
 
Staz
offline
Link
 
It's tough to get activity lately. I've noticed a dwindling response on many forums. I attribute that to the less "active" players just not caring enough, and the more "active" players spreading themselves quite thin.
 
pawpawynana
offline
Link
 
i sent you my votes just in case you change your mind and others start voting. lack of interest may be due to it being early in the season.
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 12:15:35
 
MizzouDizzle
offline
Link
 
I am active and read the forum posts but generally dont post stuff on the forums... The coaches poll is an ok idea, but I dont know how much i or someone else wants to look at other teams and decide who is better
 
colest
offline
Link
 
I dunno if yoman has said he would do this or not, but I'll vote if he doesn't have the time.
 
pawpawynana
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MizzouDizzle
I am active and read the forum posts but generally dont post stuff on the forums... The coaches poll is an ok idea, but I dont know how much i or someone else wants to look at other teams and decide who is better


i see what your saying. though it didnt take me but 15 minutes or so to look at the W/L records, who they beat and who they lost too and by how much. its probably not the most accurate poll out there but you could say the same about early polls in college football today.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
I sent in my choices as well...I think this is a good idea if someone can take the time to run the show. These sorts of things add a lot to the game in my opinion.

I will likely do an "early analysis" of Alpha, perhaps after another 2 games (at the 4 game mark), but I do like the weekly tracking and potential for smack talk...
 
reneg2
offline
Link
 
I sent it in as well.
 
reneg2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
I sent in my choices as well...I think this is a good idea if someone can take the time to run the show. These sorts of things add a lot to the game in my opinion.

I will likely do an "early analysis" of Alpha, perhaps after another 2 games (at the 4 game mark), but I do like the weekly tracking and potential for smack talk...


Just put us in 16th, please. We'll gladly accept.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.