User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Greg B
offline
Link
 
Im just curious if Ure had the same exact numbers on a good team would people have voted for him?

I dont see how playing on a bad team is relevant if he only played 50 plays a game (less then a couple of the guys chosen). If he played 100 plays a game I could see it, but he has similar TFL, Sacks and more tackles. Not like he just got 100 tackles and thats it, he got pressure on guys higher then himself. Where as the guys chosen are higher value guys in this league and all considering played Lineman lower valued then them but didnt get the same numbers, but because hes on a bad team it's all for not.
 
Squicken
offline
Link
 
It is very relevant. Would you say that the Machu Pichu Apocalypse, Antarctic Eunuchs, or the other teams on the top of the list for tackles have the best defense in our league? No, not at all. The reason that these teams get so many tackles is because they let teams keep on moving against them, so they have to play defense 2/3 of the game. I'm not saying that you don't have a good player, I'm just saying that having such a high total tackles says zero about the talent level of him. And please don't use the excuse of low energy or the skill level of the O-linemen. That's like saying if I went and played DT for an NFL team (I weight 170), that I should deserve MVP because I don't have the same amount of strength or experience as those guys. It makes no sense at all to use the fact that you trained him so hard that he had no energy left to play as a reason for him being better.
 
taurran
offline
Link
 
What about dominant boosted teams beating up on weaker teams to pump up player/team stats? What about cornerbacks who are really damn good, who never get thrown too because of coverage, who get less int's and tackles?

It's all subjective and in the end doesn't matter, but people only seem to play those cards when they stand to favor from them. What matters is winning games.
 
StoutOne
offline
Link
 
I feel your pain Greg Butler, my LB didn't make our "Pro Bowl" team and he dominated people and still is at a lower level than most. Some people don't know a good player when they see one, but next time they face my LB, they'll know him...
 
yomanpopo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Derek4jc
Originally posted by yomanpopo

Wow, no love for my QB. 3600 yrds, 358/507 for 70% (highest in the league), 20 TDs. Led the squad to 14-2 record, oh well.

Surprising only 2 of my teams players made it and we are the #2 team in the conference.


He did get my vote, but it was his only vote.


At least he got 1!!!!
 
Greg B
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by StoutOne
I feel your pain Greg Butler, my LB didn't make our "Pro Bowl" team and he dominated people and still is at a lower level than most. Some people don't know a good player when they see one, but next time they face my LB, they'll know him...


Werd

People still arent getting the point though, just because Ure played on a currently bad team (that will change we got some great builds) should not take away from what he has done.

For example:

Detroit Lions have sucked for years, Shaun Rogers had a great season a couple years ago. Did he still manage to go to the Pro Bowl? Yes he did 2 straight years. Ure's stats are just as comparable as the other guys chosen, just because the defense he was on was bad doesnt mean his performance was. If his tackles were all 20 yards down field I could see your point, but he was comparable in sacks and TFL.

With the ideas you guys have that would mean not a single player from a bad team would ever be picked for a Pro Bowl.

Plays/game
Max- 56.9
Ripp-65.2
Old- 49.8
Ure- 52.2

Same competition, fewer plays per game, more tackles, similar sacks and similar TFL

That's all I have to say about it
Last edited Sep 9, 2008 08:53:24
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Greg Butler
Originally posted by StoutOne

I feel your pain Greg Butler, my LB didn't make our "Pro Bowl" team and he dominated people and still is at a lower level than most. Some people don't know a good player when they see one, but next time they face my LB, they'll know him...


Werd

People still arent getting the point though, just because Ure played on a currently bad team (that will change we got some great builds) should not take away from what he has done.

For example:

Detroit Lions have sucked for years, Shaun Rogers had a great season a couple years ago. Did he still manage to go to the Pro Bowl? Yes he did 2 straight years. Ure's stats are just as comparable as the other guys chosen, just because the defense he was on was bad doesnt mean his performance was. If his tackles were all 20 yards down field I could see your point, but he was comparable in sacks and TFL.

With the ideas you guys have that would mean not a single player from a bad team would ever be picked for a Pro Bowl. That's all I have to say about it


I'm jumping in this late but here's my thoughts. If a player is going to be a Pro Bowler from a team giving up 400+ points on defense, he has to be significantly better than the other players when it comes to stats, not just around the same level.

If I'm a linebacker on a defense that gave up 170 points, I have 90 tackles, 3 sacks and 2 interceptions, my guy should get the nod over your guy who is on a team that gave up 550 points, even if you have 120 tackles, 3 sacks and 2 interceptions. Why? Because the surrounding players on your side are not as good as the ones I play with. Because of that, the surrounding players on my team will get a higher percentage of tackles and big plays themselves leaving less stats for my guy even if we are on the field for the exact same number of plays.

If I had a vote, I would say a player on a terrible team must have elite stats...

ie defensive end with 15+ sacks
cornerback with 8+ interceptions
etc.

Interesting debate. I do find it interesting that the Warriors only have a couple of players mentioned. May have something to do with our balance on both sides of the ball.
 
Derek4jc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Greg Butler
Originally posted by StoutOne

I feel your pain Greg Butler, my LB didn't make our "Pro Bowl" team and he dominated people and still is at a lower level than most. Some people don't know a good player when they see one, but next time they face my LB, they'll know him...


Werd

People still arent getting the point though, just because Ure played on a currently bad team (that will change we got some great builds) should not take away from what he has done.

For example:

Detroit Lions have sucked for years, Shaun Rogers had a great season a couple years ago. Did he still manage to go to the Pro Bowl? Yes he did 2 straight years. Ure's stats are just as comparable as the other guys chosen, just because the defense he was on was bad doesnt mean his performance was. If his tackles were all 20 yards down field I could see your point, but he was comparable in sacks and TFL.

With the ideas you guys have that would mean not a single player from a bad team would ever be picked for a Pro Bowl.

Plays/game
Max- 56.9
Ripp-65.2
Old- 49.8
Ure- 52.2

Same competition, fewer plays per game, more tackles, similar sacks and similar TFL

That's all I have to say about it


I think you're stretching that statement a little bit. I'm just saying, for me, getting a lot of tackles on a team giving up 600 yards per game, and getting completely handled every game, isn't going to motivate me to put that guy on my pro bowl ballot over a guy who is putting up similar numbers on a team who's defense is actually successful.

Also, on the Lions/Rogers tip, two things, fan voting, and the Lions are getting raped defensively in the manner Ure's team is. I understand the attempted comparison, but when a team is as overmatched as that team was this year in this league, it's like comparing a juco team to a pro team, not two pro teams to each other. Sure there will be a couple guys on that Juco team that will get most of the tackles because their teammates are so bad, but it doesn't make them a top 3 player in the league at their position.
Last edited Sep 9, 2008 12:02:19
 
Derek4jc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Smith_FPS
Originally posted by Greg Butler

Originally posted by StoutOne


I feel your pain Greg Butler, my LB didn't make our "Pro Bowl" team and he dominated people and still is at a lower level than most. Some people don't know a good player when they see one, but next time they face my LB, they'll know him...


Werd

People still arent getting the point though, just because Ure played on a currently bad team (that will change we got some great builds) should not take away from what he has done.

For example:

Detroit Lions have sucked for years, Shaun Rogers had a great season a couple years ago. Did he still manage to go to the Pro Bowl? Yes he did 2 straight years. Ure's stats are just as comparable as the other guys chosen, just because the defense he was on was bad doesnt mean his performance was. If his tackles were all 20 yards down field I could see your point, but he was comparable in sacks and TFL.

With the ideas you guys have that would mean not a single player from a bad team would ever be picked for a Pro Bowl. That's all I have to say about it


I'm jumping in this late but here's my thoughts. If a player is going to be a Pro Bowler from a team giving up 400+ points on defense, he has to be significantly better than the other players when it comes to stats, not just around the same level.

If I'm a linebacker on a defense that gave up 170 points, I have 90 tackles, 3 sacks and 2 interceptions, my guy should get the nod over your guy who is on a team that gave up 550 points, even if you have 120 tackles, 3 sacks and 2 interceptions. Why? Because the surrounding players on your side are not as good as the ones I play with. Because of that, the surrounding players on my team will get a higher percentage of tackles and big plays themselves leaving less stats for my guy even if we are on the field for the exact same number of plays.

If I had a vote, I would say a player on a terrible team must have elite stats...

ie defensive end with 15+ sacks
cornerback with 8+ interceptions
etc.

Interesting debate. I do find it interesting that the Warriors only have a couple of players mentioned. May have something to do with our balance on both sides of the ball.


I think one thing to keep in mind is that only 4 ballots came in, and one of them was from your owner. You weren't allowed to vote for your own players, so that leaves only 3 ballots that your players could have shown up on. It does seem as tho some of the teams that received lower numbers of pro bowlers were either bad teams or voted.
 
Knob McDude
offline
Link
 
I want to thank Derek4jc for counting the votes, and posting the results.

I'm sure we all have players on our team, who we think should be on the list. It isn't Derek's fault they're not, so let's ease up on him.

If you want to blame somebody, blame me. I didn't have enough time to vote, and I would have voted for all those who were supposed to be on the team, but didn't make it.

Thanks Derek.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
There are several spots open on the Alpha Pro Bowl roster...Marisol, Zheng Yi Quan and Johnny Tso are all stripped of their awards after miserable performances in losing the conference championship.

Put someone worthy in their place!

 
HankTubbs
offline
Link
 
As owner of one of the four teams who submitted a ballot, I thought I'd share my two cents on some of the "controversy" mentioned here so far:

Originally posted by Greg Butler

Kind of suprised not to see Ure in there


While the quality of the team defense wasn't an intentional consideration in determining my votes, I'll admit it crossed my mind. I generally looked through our games to see if any players stood out in games against us, then looked across the conference leaders to see whose names appeared toward the top of multiple stat categories. One place where Ure doesn't come close to the top vote-getters is in Hurries. If I'd made a fourth pick at DT, it might've gone to Ure - who knows?

I was surprised to see your plays/game comparison, though. I didn't look that deeply into it, but wouldn't have guessed it'd be that close. Regardless of his "snub", I think you've got to be proud of Ure's season, especially considering he was regularly overmatched.

Originally posted by yomanpopo

Wow, no love for my QB. 3600 yrds, 358/507 for 70% (highest in the league), 20 TDs. Led the squad to 14-2 record, oh well.

Surprising only 2 of my teams players made it and we are the #2 team in the conference.


3rd in Yds.
1st in Comp %.
2nd in Yds/Att.
12th in Yds/Comp.
3rd in TDs.
7th in TD/INT ratio.

A very respectable stat line, and certainly warrants consideration for Pro Bowl votes. It might be hard to make a case against any of the Top 3, though, too.

Originally posted by CarpeDeezNuts

http://goallineblitz.com/game/full_player_stats.pl?player_id=769008&playoffs=0

Really?

138 tackles, and 128 MISSED tackles? I thought I was missing something and this was a parody of some sort, but the other FS, cookie buchanon, actually has good stats.


Neither were on my ballot.

Originally posted by keith_dude

the tomato got screwed!

a level 19 FB with 66 carries for 250.5 yards....

He blocked for a dominant running game! Not my fault my lousy OCs didn't call a FB run.

11 pancakes? Come on!


I found it really hard to compare FBs without a ton of manual effort. If you look at rushing stats, it's nearly all HBs, if you look at blocking stats, it's nearly all OL, if you look at receiving stats, it's nearly all WR/TE. So if someone had assembled a list of all the FBs in the league with all their stats, I might've voted for you. As it was, all I had to go on was FB performances in games against us. You rushed 4 times for 12 yard and fumbled. 0 pancakes. Didn't scream "Pro Bowl" to me.


I'm sure I offended everyone I responded to, so I apologize. Just trying to shed some light on the rationale behind one ballot.



-HT
Last edited Sep 9, 2008 21:51:21
 
yomanpopo
offline
Link
 
None the less, it was fun. Thanks for taking time to count the votes, thanks for contributing everyone.

Time to recruit and get my entire team on the Pro Bowl next season!!!!

Good season everyone, it was fun.
 
Link
 
Perhaps we should open up voting for everybody in the conference (not just owners). Would get more votes at least.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.