Originally posted by gameface25
if they faced each other I would be WVU 100%, easily. When you show me some unwritten man-law that states I cant like another programs basketball team, I will concede the point.
As a Cavalier I am sorry you are all about 1 team only, as it must not be very exciting to be a fan in your neck of the woods
Who gives a rats ass about lacrosse, soccer, swimming, etc.... seriously... or even baseball.
Big East > ACC past 3-5 years, you can quote your aggregate RPI all you want, its a worthless stat. Top to bottom there is no comparison, just look at the # of top 25 teams season in and season out in basketball and football. Therein lies the truth, along with bowl records
Shoot, I was willing to let bygones be bygones, but you've done stirred the pot again. Let me take the fallacies, in kind.
First, if you cheer for WVU with the same level of passion that you cheer for UNC, you're a bandwagon jumper of the worst order. Agree to disagree, if we must, but there it is. You say you would cheer for WVU 100% of the time if they played Carolina. That's acceptible in this "Man Rulebook" you mentioned. However, if you cheer for UNC just as hard, then you're no better than the bandwagon fan mocfam mentioned above.
Second, you missed the whole freaking point completely. As a Cavalier, I'm not constrained to cheer for my team solely during fall and winter. We were 9-4 and made the Gator Bowl last year, which is a successful season by an objective measure. Our basketball team, while not what it was in the 1980s, has had a .500 record in all but 2 seasons this decade (and one of those was 15-16). Our baseball team made the NCAA Regionals for the 5th straight year this season. Our tennis team made the NCAA semifinals and finished with a record of 31-1 with a repeat NCAA individual champion. Our soccer team made the NCAA tournament yet again, falling in the Round of 16. Our lacrosse team made the NCAA semifinals, losing a heartbreaker to the eventual national champions. Our women's basketball team made the 2nd round of the NCAA tournament, dropping a heartbreaker on a 23-foot shot by ODU as time expired. Our women's golf team triple-bogeyed the final hole of the NCAA championship to finish 2nd to Duke. Our men's and women's swimming both won the ACC title for the 5th straight year, each. Our men's cross country won the ACC this year.
And you say there's nothing to cheer about as a Cavalier. Please, dude. I think I just PWNED you.
Third, I think you're in the minority in your view that no one gives a "rat's ass" about the sports you mentioned. Tell JHU lacrosse fans that. Or tell FSU, Miami, or Texas baseball fans that. Tell Wake Forest fans that soccer doesn't matter, I'm sure they'd be glad to give you their national title. Tell FSU that swimming doesn't matter: they're still mad at us about our rise to dominance there. Anyone can spout off what you have. Back it up with more that: "well, I don't care about, so no one else does, either". Your arguments are hideously near-sighted, if anything.
And fourth, yes, I can and will quote all the aggregate RPI I want. It's only what the NCAA tournament selection committee relies most heavily on when deciding on teams for the NCAA tournament. The Big East's 10th-place team this year was Cincinnati, who was 13-19. The ACC's 10th-place team this year was Virginia, at 17-16. The ACC's worst team was Boston College, at 14-17. The Big East had FIVE teams worse than that: Cincinnati, DePaul, St. John's, South Florida, and Rutgers. The Big East had NO teams in the NCAA Final Four; the ACC had 1. I can go on, and on, and on, and on, and on. Logic doesn't seem to affect your arguments, because I keep bombarding you with it and still you can't acquiesce the point that the ACC is better than the Big East in basketball, at least currently. At the VERY least, you haven't proferred nearly as many arguments as I have to the contrary.
if they faced each other I would be WVU 100%, easily. When you show me some unwritten man-law that states I cant like another programs basketball team, I will concede the point.
As a Cavalier I am sorry you are all about 1 team only, as it must not be very exciting to be a fan in your neck of the woods
Who gives a rats ass about lacrosse, soccer, swimming, etc.... seriously... or even baseball.
Big East > ACC past 3-5 years, you can quote your aggregate RPI all you want, its a worthless stat. Top to bottom there is no comparison, just look at the # of top 25 teams season in and season out in basketball and football. Therein lies the truth, along with bowl records
Shoot, I was willing to let bygones be bygones, but you've done stirred the pot again. Let me take the fallacies, in kind.
First, if you cheer for WVU with the same level of passion that you cheer for UNC, you're a bandwagon jumper of the worst order. Agree to disagree, if we must, but there it is. You say you would cheer for WVU 100% of the time if they played Carolina. That's acceptible in this "Man Rulebook" you mentioned. However, if you cheer for UNC just as hard, then you're no better than the bandwagon fan mocfam mentioned above.
Second, you missed the whole freaking point completely. As a Cavalier, I'm not constrained to cheer for my team solely during fall and winter. We were 9-4 and made the Gator Bowl last year, which is a successful season by an objective measure. Our basketball team, while not what it was in the 1980s, has had a .500 record in all but 2 seasons this decade (and one of those was 15-16). Our baseball team made the NCAA Regionals for the 5th straight year this season. Our tennis team made the NCAA semifinals and finished with a record of 31-1 with a repeat NCAA individual champion. Our soccer team made the NCAA tournament yet again, falling in the Round of 16. Our lacrosse team made the NCAA semifinals, losing a heartbreaker to the eventual national champions. Our women's basketball team made the 2nd round of the NCAA tournament, dropping a heartbreaker on a 23-foot shot by ODU as time expired. Our women's golf team triple-bogeyed the final hole of the NCAA championship to finish 2nd to Duke. Our men's and women's swimming both won the ACC title for the 5th straight year, each. Our men's cross country won the ACC this year.
And you say there's nothing to cheer about as a Cavalier. Please, dude. I think I just PWNED you.
Third, I think you're in the minority in your view that no one gives a "rat's ass" about the sports you mentioned. Tell JHU lacrosse fans that. Or tell FSU, Miami, or Texas baseball fans that. Tell Wake Forest fans that soccer doesn't matter, I'm sure they'd be glad to give you their national title. Tell FSU that swimming doesn't matter: they're still mad at us about our rise to dominance there. Anyone can spout off what you have. Back it up with more that: "well, I don't care about, so no one else does, either". Your arguments are hideously near-sighted, if anything.
And fourth, yes, I can and will quote all the aggregate RPI I want. It's only what the NCAA tournament selection committee relies most heavily on when deciding on teams for the NCAA tournament. The Big East's 10th-place team this year was Cincinnati, who was 13-19. The ACC's 10th-place team this year was Virginia, at 17-16. The ACC's worst team was Boston College, at 14-17. The Big East had FIVE teams worse than that: Cincinnati, DePaul, St. John's, South Florida, and Rutgers. The Big East had NO teams in the NCAA Final Four; the ACC had 1. I can go on, and on, and on, and on, and on. Logic doesn't seem to affect your arguments, because I keep bombarding you with it and still you can't acquiesce the point that the ACC is better than the Big East in basketball, at least currently. At the VERY least, you haven't proferred nearly as many arguments as I have to the contrary.
Last edited Aug 28, 2008 16:25:47






























