User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
seawolf93
offline
Link
 
After today's Championship game I think some of you might want to change your votes to Brady Quinn (MVP), Super Sackman (Def POY) and Thunderbird Jenkins (Off POY)...

MVP
1 - Stuckey Adams
2 - Hermann
3 - Gabriel Graham (Taos Hum QB is a goody)

Off POY
1 - Adams
2 - Hermann

Def POY
1 - Reese
2 - Rebel Warren

 
Link
 
No one is gonna finish up on this?

I went ahead and tallied up the scores from the 5 teams we had participate.


MVP
1 - Hermann 10
2 - Stuckey Adams 8
3 - Reece 4
3 - Soapman 4
Honorable Mention - Gabriel Graham 1, Dunco 1, Kramia 1

OPOY
1 - Adams 5
1 - Hermann 5
Honorable Mention - Soapman 3, Madine 1, Quinn 1

Since no one else voted the only tie breaker I could think of was to delete the votes for that catagory from the 2 teams that Adams and Hermann come from to nullify the possible "competitive favoritism".

results:
1 - Hermann 5
2 - Adams 3
Honorable Mention - Quinn 1


DPOY
1 - Reese 8
2 - Sackman 2
Honorable Mention - Rebel Warren 1, Big Pussy 1, Rap 1
Last edited Sep 24, 2008 18:23:45
 
Tajson
offline
Link
 
Thank you.
 
Also Banned
offline
Link
 
my Punter "Thats What She Said" only level 14 and he is tearing it up
 
JBennett23
offline
Link
 
Kane wins hands down
Last edited Oct 5, 2008 08:08:13
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JBennett23
Kane wins hands down


Both Chile Dog QBs have a better claim over your QB.
 
JBennett23
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mat McBriar
Originally posted by JBennett23

Kane wins hands down


Both Chile Dog QBs have a better claim over your QB.


Really? And how would you even remotely get that idea? I lead the league by almost 1000 yards so far, 22 TDs 2 Ints, and I don't have a running game to open the skies up like Chile does.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Chile Dogs QBs
286-370, 77% completion percentage, 3719.5 yards, 45 TDs 0 INTs, 10.1 yards/attempt
9-1 record

Bolivian Berserkers QBs
328-530, 61.9% completion percentage, 3916.5 yards, 31 TDs 3 INTs, 7.4 yards/attempt
6-4 record


Oh and your comment on the Chile Dogs HBs opening the skies for the passing game is somewhat comical. Y'all say you don't have a running game but that's because you run the ball like 10 times a game. Chile's yards/rush is a mere 4.9 yards with us running the ball roughly 35 times (for almost a 50/50 run/pass split) a game. With less passing attempts the Chile Dog QBs still match your QB and then some.

And I just don't see your case for the E-MVP award when your team is just squeaking into the playoffs.
 
JBennett23
offline
Link
 
Exactly. Your team success is your primary justification as to your QBs superiority. You're banking off of the talent that surrounds the QB.

Fact of the matter is, is that my man leads your men by almost 1000 yards, and has less talent around him to do it with.

Nobody said LT was the best until the Chargers made the playoffs. When they went 1-15 he was just "good". Right.
 
Tareton
offline
Link
 
Age old debate again. Best player on the best or most valuable player to his team. What is the MVP award really for?

You can make a strong case for either side of the arguement.
 
jmorgalis
offline
Link
 
Well I will say this, there's never been a platoon that won an MVP. That's a choice made by the Chile Dogs that has worked out for them, but neither of their QBs will win the award as there is no Most Valuable Platoon award.

Sort of like a pitcher winning the baseball MVP. Got to play every day, or in this case, most of the plays.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jmorgalis
Well I will say this, there's never been a platoon that won an MVP. That's a choice made by the Chile Dogs that has worked out for them, but neither of their QBs will win the award as there is no Most Valuable Platoon award.

Sort of like a pitcher winning the baseball MVP. Got to play every day, or in this case, most of the plays.


so all we can win is a John Madden Horse Trailer award.

*shakes fist*

 
SAVAGE OPS
offline
Link
 
Screw'em, they can take that award and Shove it up their ass! It's meaningless, we know who the best QB in this league is. There should be more emphasis put into QB rating instead of yards. Anybody on a crappy team is gonna be passing alot more.
Allstar "shmallstar" who cares?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.