User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
kentrol72
offline
Link
 
This ball is knocked away from the WR and it comes back to him.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=110154&pbp_id=5774808

While I agree that some PD's in the NFL are still caught by the recievers, it happens way too often on GLB.
 
kentrol72
offline
Link
 
anybody else see this going on?
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
1) Wrong forum. This isn't a bug report.

2) This has been discussed ad nauseum, between this board and the Suggestions board (which would be the right board).

Bort has implemented changes to cut down on the frequency of this while keeping passing averages about the same. Most people are happy with them. If he prevented this from ever happening, passing averages would become horribly low compared to real life.
 
Sledge
offline
Link
 
Shrug passin yards per catch are 3.8 to 4 yards a catch over nfl now.
 
NWWarrior
offline
Link
 
I agree with the OP on this subject, rather this is the place to discuss it or not!!!

Pass deflections need to hit the ground the vast MAJORITY of the time...way to many long TDs givin up this way right now in the GLB
 
kentrol72
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
1) Wrong forum. This isn't a bug report.

2) This has been discussed ad nauseum, between this board and the Suggestions board (which would be the right board).

Bort has implemented changes to cut down on the frequency of this while keeping passing averages about the same. Most people are happy with them. If he prevented this from ever happening, passing averages would become horribly low compared to real life.


I know the differance. Do you? Did you even look at the clip? The ball is clearly overthrown and snaps back to the WR not keeping in motion with the overall gameplay. That clearly looks like a bug in the system along with all of what I've seen in plays from anyone of my teams and whats being said in the CB forum. The suggestion forum is something totally different.

I know what Bort was fixing. Last season CB's gave up too little to WR's. He gave a boost to WR catching, but the answer shouldnt be to make PD's 70/30 in favor of the WR.

 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kentrol72
... Did you even look at the clip? The ball is clearly overthrown and snaps back to the WR not keeping in motion with the overall gameplay. ...


Since I can't see the z-axis: how can you be sure?

And even if it was overthrown: how can you be sure the WR didn't jump much higher than the CB and got the ball this way?

And if none of the above: how about a stronger WR ripping the ball out of the CBs hands while the CB bobbled it?

So what exactly makes you sure this is a malfunction of the game? Should a WR in tight coverage never catch an overthrown pass? Should the named scenarios never happen?

ALL I can see is that the pass was completed and that the CB got a hand on it sometimes - maybe as the WR came down from his jump and/or the CB jumped up too. So what is your superior knowledge? I really like to improve - for that kind of catches happen all the time.



 
kentrol72
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by kentrol72

... Did you even look at the clip? The ball is clearly overthrown and snaps back to the WR not keeping in motion with the overall gameplay. ...


Since I can't see the z-axis: how can you be sure?

And even if it was overthrown: how can you be sure the WR didn't jump much higher than the CB and got the ball this way?

And if none of the above: how about a stronger WR ripping the ball out of the CBs hands while the CB bobbled it?

So what exactly makes you sure this is a malfunction of the game? Should a WR in tight coverage never catch an overthrown pass? Should the named scenarios never happen?

ALL I can see is that the pass was completed and that the CB got a hand on it sometimes - maybe as the WR came down from his jump and/or the CB jumped up too. So what is your superior knowledge? I really like to improve - for that kind of catches happen all the time.





Since you cant see the "z-axis" and since you speculating what may have happen with 3 dimensional characters, for all you know a bird might have flown by at the time and got hit with the ball sending it back to the WR.

I started this thread because like I said above, I know the changes Bort made because of the unfair advantage CB's had last season. I know there was a correction for the WR's and to make it more realistic. Also after observing the game play countless times, watching how the "blimp view" (for all you 1992 gameboy Madden folks) characters "run" and how the ball is thrown and caught. I've seen the ball deflected loads of times and caught by the WR or batted away by the CB. In my observations the ball doesnt snap backwards at that speed to the WR. In the fix that was made to WR's catching, it appears on the replay that the defending is getting cheated out of a missed pass or succesful deflection. Thats why I brought this here to the bug forum.

My superior knowledge tells me that you shouldt try to bash someone trying to sound cool especially if you had no hand in writing the program for this game because they belive there is a problem. If you've seen it before, just say so and move on. Too many wanna be Elitist on these boards.
Last edited Aug 23, 2008 22:23:41
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
Pass deflections should be no more than 50% completion and even that is a high rate for deflected passes.Any higher than this and it becomes unrealistic.Now if we are talking tipped balls then it becomes a different scenario but since the only word available to us is deflected we all assume deflected means deflected away from the players.The only way a deflected ball should ever be caught is if a player is out of position and happens to be in the wrong spot at the right time to catch the ball.
 
kentrol72
offline
Link
 
I agree Texans but what I'm trying to point out I guess is if the replay sim is accurately reflecting the plays (from a blimp view) than the programing is going out of its way to give the WR the catch.
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
We are both on the same page and I have also seen the ball in the blimp view do some strange things.We as a team have pondered the several thing on several plays.
 
kentrol72
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by King Of Life


Originally posted by Bort



- Deflections are more likely to get slammed to the ground or batted away from the receiver than they were before. Basically less Z axis and more X/Y axis. Should mean less caught tips.


Is this going to affect the amount of completion or just the amount of deflected passes?


Bort:
I doesn't affect the amount of deflected passes; just makes them less likely to be caught because they won't end up near the receiver. Completions should go up in general because of the QB's new ability to pass away from defenders, so tipped passes should be caught less to make up for it (makes more sense anyway).

Of course, it can still happen, but tips should be more likely to be more "away from the play" now.



maybe thats been fixed
Last edited Aug 24, 2008 12:20:35
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.