User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AA Leagues > South America AA #3 > All Star Team? -All Owners Read.
Page:
 
JoeCoolMan24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by reian
Its tough to pick all stars if you get down to it. If you really want the best players you would have to take level into consideration.... I mean which is better... say a lvl 14 playing week in and week out vs players 4+ levels higher and getting decent stats OR a level 20+ playing against lower level players and getting really good stats.


I think you need to go solely on stats and not levels. If this was a real committee, you would break down replays and games to see how good they are, but no one is going to do that. I just say take a look a the leadersboards in stats, but take gamesplayed into consideration.
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
go by stats, not levels.

If a level 14 is outperforming, then congrats on the great build. But the level 23 getting better stats now is the star. That being said, I don't know if many on my team are putting up crazy stats right now. Seems success is spread out
 
vzone
offline
Link
 
Stats are important but they don't show everything. For example an LOLB on a losing team quite often leads the league in tackles. Nothing against the OLB's of the world but that doesn't mean they are the best LOLB. If I were truly looking for an all star in this case, I would factor things like that in and also look at things like missed tackles, PD's, INT's. Sacks, etc.

And tackles for a CB, forget it. Missed tackles, yes, but tackles for a CB are not the whole picture unless you break everything down and see how many of them were running play tackles.

 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vzone
Stats are important but they don't show everything. For example an LOLB on a losing team quite often leads the league in tackles. Nothing against the OLB's of the world but that doesn't mean they are the best LOLB. If I were truly looking for an all star in this case, I would factor things like that in and also look at things like missed tackles, PD's, INT's. Sacks, etc.

And tackles for a CB, forget it. Missed tackles, yes, but tackles for a CB are not the whole picture unless you break everything down and see how many of them were running play tackles.



very true. Stats can be a great indicator, but their are alot of mitigating factors. Particularly for CB's...Tackles made verse a WR is a great stat supporting the CB should NOT be on the team.
 
JoeCoolMan24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vzone
Stats are important but they don't show everything. For example an LOLB on a losing team quite often leads the league in tackles. Nothing against the OLB's of the world but that doesn't mean they are the best LOLB. If I were truly looking for an all star in this case, I would factor things like that in and also look at things like missed tackles, PD's, INT's. Sacks, etc.

And tackles for a CB, forget it. Missed tackles, yes, but tackles for a CB are not the whole picture unless you break everything down and see how many of them were running play tackles.



While this is very true, its also very hard to go by the intangible things on a game where we cant really "see" these things. Also, if people wont take the time to look at the leaderboards, then they wont take the time to look up all the other factors as well.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.