Marino and Elway both had their moments of "I can't believe he just did that" Elway's sucess proved that more than an insanely talented QB was needed to win a Superbowl.
Montana was a smooth progression, the main gear in a machine that chewed up defenses. Manning does what he did but with more talent.
Tarkington (who almost nobody has mentioned) was another freak - he was almost a quarterbacking Barry Sanders - always moving to stay out of trouble. Farve is very much in the Elway catagory, but with less disipline.
I wold say that even now Unitas deserves consideration. He pioneered the specific elements of a great QB, and did so at a level that is comparable to today's QBs.
Montana was a smooth progression, the main gear in a machine that chewed up defenses. Manning does what he did but with more talent.
Tarkington (who almost nobody has mentioned) was another freak - he was almost a quarterbacking Barry Sanders - always moving to stay out of trouble. Farve is very much in the Elway catagory, but with less disipline.
I wold say that even now Unitas deserves consideration. He pioneered the specific elements of a great QB, and did so at a level that is comparable to today's QBs.






























