User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Canadian AA Leagues > Canada AA #2 > I hope they don't promote/demote with the A league this season
djfivenine
offline
Link
 
The level differences are ridiculous. Their undefeated teams won't even smell a win up here...and our bottom teams would have an easy time down there.

I hope Bort gives it one more season...because right now, it's not like an A team moving up to AA...it's more like a high school team trying to move up to play college teams.
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
That's going to be the consequence of level caps, if it is only going to apply to new leagues. But college teams that move to 1-A sometimes go winless, when they dominated in 1-AA, so who knows.

Plus you have to figure that the undefeated teams, with their "championship" trophy, are going to have an advantage in recruiting come the offseason...just like the Yokels and Kings did last year when they moved up to AAA. They'll have to build their team a lot, really quickly, but that's the consequence of playing in a higher league. We'll all have to deal with it if we move up to AAA next season...it's not like most of our teams are ready to beat the best AAA teams, and without improvement some of us might only get a few wins. But championship teams tend to work their asses off to improve, which is why they win to begin with, so I think it's doable.
Last edited Jul 8, 2008 13:17:50
 
djfivenine
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SpearSrai
just like the Yokels and Kings did last year when they moved up to AAA. They'll have to build their team a lot, really quickly, but that's the consequence of playing in a higher league.


Speaking of those 2...looks like they both are locked for the playoffs...don't think they'll do much there, but still, good work...gives us hope if we even make it up there.
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
No team should win a championship the first year they move up... that would be ridiculous if they did. The fact that they are making the playoffs proves that this is a great league, and there are a ton of great owners, teams, and GM's here.
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
There will be no teams dropping to Single A this season and the level cap is gone after this season.
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
In that case, I'm looking forward to holding the new owner of St Catharines to his trash talk.
 
Stan Gable
offline
Link
 
Personally, adding sub division to an already created league is the wrong approach. Low level teams will always stay low level unless they buy new high level players which then leads to low level players to not be able to advance to an upper league. The way I would do things is to add an entire new league with a cap level of say 10 and as all players are leveling then up the cap of such league, that way at least every team has an equal opportunity of advancing.
Last edited Jul 8, 2008 16:17:46
 
SpearSrai
offline
Link
 
That's a good idea; they're not necessarily thinking out the leveling as well as you'd hope. They have good ideas, like level caps, but they won't work unless they're applied across the board. Instead, it's just a big mess right now. Hopefully they'll figure it out eventually.
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
The only way they can get this shit to work right is to put in a cap level for entering a league. That basically means if you are a lvl 14 player you can not get on a team with a cap level of 13 nor can you be traded to a cap team if you are +14 even if you are in the cap league already. However if you are under contract you can still play in the league and renegotiate a new contract even if you are above the cap level. Eventually a team will be good enough to move up based on being a higher ranking team.

Now in addition to this they need to have more teams moving up and down to help balance the leagues out. I have suggested several times that the playoff conference winner, the regular season conference winner should move up. If the regular season winner is the playoff winner the regular season 2nd place winner moves up. This will have 4 teams moving up from each league and the 4 worst form each down. Having this many teams on the over will keep this game from getting stale and make a much better balanced league system.

Of course there is the factor of higher levels moving down into a league where the team is above the cap, but this will eventually balance out as the lower teams will eventually catch up and become competitive.


One of the biggest reason why the cap can not be based on an individuals level is the fact that a good number of teams are made up of RLFs and Bort and company do not want to force these guys to break up because of a level cap.
Last edited Jul 8, 2008 18:27:00
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.