User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
joe87
offline
Link
 
Top 10:

1. Bandar Lampung Pigskin Pirates (12-0) Last Week: 1
2. Manila Warlords (11-1) Last Week: 2
3. Da Nang Tigers (10-2) Last Week: 3
4. Neo Armstrong Cyclone Jet Armstrong Cannon (9-3) Last Week: 6
5. Montana Mercenaries (10-2) Last Week: 5
6. South Austin Bats (11-1) Last Week: 4
7. Utopia Cobras (9-3) Last Week: 7
8. P-Funk Allstars (9-3) Last Week: 9
9. Awendaw ToadFish (9-3) Last Week: 9
10. Pa Dong Dragons (9-3) Last Week: 8



Outside Looking In:

11. Tongduchon Cowboys (9-3) Last Week: 11
12. Perrinton Panthers (8-4) Last Week: 12
13. Portland Dirty Penquins (7-5) Last Week: NR
 
Link
 
Hahaha! We're #6 now!? We're tied for the 2nd best record in the league, and have beaten Da Nang, NACJAC, and Awendaw, and barely lost to the Warlords. This is just asanine!
 
joe87
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Hahaha! We're #6 now!? We're tied for the 2nd best record in the league, and have beaten Da Nang, NACJAC, and Awendaw, and barely lost to the Warlords. This is just asanine!


And their seasons are still more impressive than yours. A few close losses doesn't mean they're not as good as you. NACJAC is the only team to beat the Warlords. Aside from their 3 losses, they've put ridiculous numbers.

This isn't how I'd rank the teams, but I've gotta keep it objective. The other teams are just scoring a lot more points than you, while most are giving up less on defense.

BTW. Teams 3-6 are all grade out very closely. It won't take much for those to change from game to game.
 
MorsDraconis
offline
Link
 
This is the most asinine thing I've ever seen. P-Funk beats Utopia and doesn't even skip over them? That's just retarded. This is worst then the BCS. At least in the BCS when you beat a team, in the top 10 and you were only 1 behind them the week before would jump over them.

Obviously, this "computer" you're using to rank these doesn't do any rankings that aren't based on points and that's the dumbest way you could possibly do it. South Austin doesn't blow out teams because we give all of our players a chance to play. Hell, we put up 90 on Ujung with our backups starting and the same goes for the 76 on Fukushima and the 48 against Okinawa.

Hell, we could have put up 150+ on all three of those teams, but what the hell is the point of that? Points scored doesn't mean crap.

To have 3 teams above us with worse records just because they happen to have put up more points against the dregs of the league doesn't mean squat, especially considering two of the 5 teams ahead of us we already beat and are about to beat another one.
 
Link
 
But computer rankings are just as errored as human rankings as well. The BCS is a prime example of both gone wrong. Human rankings are flawed because of "feelings" and other deterents.
Comps can only rank based off the formula.
Really the only rankings I see that matter a ton are the rankings on the league page but the true rankings don't start until the playoffs start. I do like PRJ's and Joes rankings though since they give a diffrent flavor to it and use diffrent formulas for each.

Meh, I like the fact you had your backups starting against those teams. We did that for our Def against HKGunslingers.
 
joe87
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MorsDraconis
This is the most asinine thing I've ever seen. P-Funk beats Utopia and doesn't even skip over them? That's just retarded. This is worst then the BCS. At least in the BCS when you beat a team, in the top 10 and you were only 1 behind them the week before would jump over them.

Obviously, this "computer" you're using to rank these doesn't do any rankings that aren't based on points and that's the dumbest way you could possibly do it. South Austin doesn't blow out teams because we give all of our players a chance to play. Hell, we put up 90 on Ujung with our backups starting and the same goes for the 76 on Fukushima and the 48 against Okinawa.

Hell, we could have put up 150+ on all three of those teams, but what the hell is the point of that? Points scored doesn't mean crap.

To have 3 teams above us with worse records just because they happen to have put up more points against the dregs of the league doesn't mean squat, especially considering two of the 5 teams ahead of us we already beat and are about to beat another one.


I could start my backups and my team would basically put up the same numbers it's been putting up all season..

Anyway. Have you ever looked at the computer rankings for college football? I'm sure you haven't. The BCS AREN'T the computer rankings. To get the BCS rankings, you're combining the Computer Rankings with the Coaches rankings (the AP poll isn't a factor anymore b/c the media had an agenda). If you ever look at the individual computer rankings, you'll notice they don't look much like the final rankings. They rank the teams based on margin of victory, strength of schedule, and record, just like I'm doing here. The only thing I might add to the formula is a bonus from "power wins" from beating teams with a winning percentage of 70% or higher.

I don't see why some of you get so up in arms about some stupid fucking rankings. I'm doing this so everyone can get an idea of what the top 10 would look like if you took all human bias out of consideration and went straight off of the major stats.

 
Outlaw Dogs
offline
Link
 
Chill a minute guys, it's not like this has any bearing whatsoever on anything.
 
Herdmaster
offline
Link
 
This should be our new bit....look at the effect already..LOL!!



Wait...maybe it is our new bit??


Warlords......their brains are computers.


SWEEP THE ARRRRRGGGGGGHHHHHHHHHH!!!!



Joe, when is my fucking trade going through?
 
JeffHCross
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by joe87
To get the BCS rankings, you're combining the Computer Rankings with the Coaches rankings (the AP poll isn't a factor anymore b/c the media had an agenda).
You forgot about the Harris Poll.

 
joe87
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JeffHCross
Originally posted by joe87

To get the BCS rankings, you're combining the Computer Rankings with the Coaches rankings (the AP poll isn't a factor anymore b/c the media had an agenda).
You forgot about the Harris Poll.



Isn't the Harris Poll the result from combining all the individual computer polls? There's like 8 or 9 computer polls, and they're all rolled into one before they're put into the BCS formula.
 
JeffHCross
offline
Link
 
Nope. Harris Poll is the replacement for the AP Poll. The Computer Rankings are rolled into one score, but not an actual poll. They're just computed together as part of the BCS formula.

Harris Poll is a collection of former players, coaches, admins, media, etc.
 
joe87
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by JeffHCross
Nope. Harris Poll is the replacement for the AP Poll. The Computer Rankings are rolled into one score, but not an actual poll. They're just computed together as part of the BCS formula.

Harris Poll is a collection of former players, coaches, admins, media, etc.


Oh alright. What we need is to get a vote between all the coaches after each game. Then we'd have the 3 Polls we can use to come up with the "BCS" rankings. Should make things a little more interesting.

BTW- Looks like the Computer poll had the Bats around where they should've been.
 
Outlaw Dogs
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by joe87
BTW- Looks like the Computer poll had the Bats around where they should've been.

Mean, just mean. I like it.
 
durakbane
offline
Link
 
<-- Logan Smith, RB, Tonduchon Cowboys

Originally posted by Outlaw Dogs
Originally posted by joe87

BTW- Looks like the Computer poll had the Bats around where they should've been.

Mean, just mean. I like it.


Shouldn't surprise you....he treats his own team worse!
Last edited Jul 6, 2008 14:26:38
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.