Osprey isn't really being held back by the bad starting rating of later teams, I'm pretty sure. Ladder matches are starting to be more fair and so on. This was a problem in S1 for sure and S2 almost certainly, but by around the middle of S3 I think that concern is gone. Taking about 2 full seasons is probably about right for cleaning away a bad starting rating.
"Best League" and "toughest league" and so on is always an argument because it always means different things to different people, as Gart's tongue in cheek reply so very well points out. Osprey is quite competitive, and Tampa I think has proven they can hang with the top 10 with 4 wins over current top 10 teams and a #9 ranking. Alpine was top 10 material in seasons past but has clearly slipped this season. It has 5 teams in the top 50 and 3 more ranked in the 50-60 range, and has come very close to putting all 8 of those teams in the top 50 at the same time. As we get fewer leagues and fewer teams in the oldest age group this means less and less.
I think the Osprey teams are getting rated about where they belong now, but to be considered a runaway powerhouse league would need the top teams to be ranked higher than 9-17-25-28-50. Osprey gets my vote for "My favorite league" though. Sorry, other leagues i'm in.
"Best League" and "toughest league" and so on is always an argument because it always means different things to different people, as Gart's tongue in cheek reply so very well points out. Osprey is quite competitive, and Tampa I think has proven they can hang with the top 10 with 4 wins over current top 10 teams and a #9 ranking. Alpine was top 10 material in seasons past but has clearly slipped this season. It has 5 teams in the top 50 and 3 more ranked in the 50-60 range, and has come very close to putting all 8 of those teams in the top 50 at the same time. As we get fewer leagues and fewer teams in the oldest age group this means less and less.
I think the Osprey teams are getting rated about where they belong now, but to be considered a runaway powerhouse league would need the top teams to be ranked higher than 9-17-25-28-50. Osprey gets my vote for "My favorite league" though. Sorry, other leagues i'm in.






























