Edited by IdRatherFlyFish on Apr 26, 2012 11:06:44
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > this has to be a kick block - NOT A BUG
fishdan
offline
offline
alindyl
offline
offline
Holder can't be tackled, that's why the DE ex plosif bounced off him. There was a bug post someplace where they were looking for replays where people did that (hit the holder and bounced off) but i don't know if it's still open someplace.
Blocking a FG/XP is more than position on the screen, the players in blocking position have to be able to make the block attempt roll, which does include jumping (among other things)
Blocking a FG/XP is more than position on the screen, the players in blocking position have to be able to make the block attempt roll, which does include jumping (among other things)
fishdan
offline
offline
Originally posted by alindyl
Blocking a FG/XP is more than position on the screen, the players in blocking position have to be able to make the block attempt roll, which does include jumping (among other things)
yeah, I get that, but I think if you tackle the place holder that should end the play, just like IRL
Otherwise I think it will incent teams to play weak blockers to save energy
Blocking a FG/XP is more than position on the screen, the players in blocking position have to be able to make the block attempt roll, which does include jumping (among other things)
yeah, I get that, but I think if you tackle the place holder that should end the play, just like IRL
Otherwise I think it will incent teams to play weak blockers to save energy
IdRatherFlyFish
offline
offline
Hey Fish,
Whoah .. feel like I'm talking to my self ....errr...
This is currently working as intended. I agree that it looks wonky, but remember that the graphics are a visual aid, we are told to trust the play by play text.
Blocking an extra point is very difficult to do, as alindyl mentioned. Lots of things come in to play, to deflect a pass .. kick .. err
Peace,
Fish
Whoah .. feel like I'm talking to my self ....errr...
This is currently working as intended. I agree that it looks wonky, but remember that the graphics are a visual aid, we are told to trust the play by play text.
Blocking an extra point is very difficult to do, as alindyl mentioned. Lots of things come in to play, to deflect a pass .. kick .. err

Peace,
Fish
fishdan
offline
offline
Certainly I understand getting a hand on a kick is as hard as deflecting a pass -- a defender is not guaranteed a deflection just because he's in the right place -- there's alot more. But for tackling?
In that context then, am I supposed to try to improve my kick blocking strategy? I had tried to make the best kickblocking lineup I could, including scouting the other teams FGblock team. We got through the line as planned.
Would you say I should give up trying to plan to block kicks? Or does the graphic at least indicate I have a better chance of blocking a kick then if I had no penetration.
If it's not worth planning for, I'm totally cool with that -- but if there IS some way to improve your kick blocking chances, I figure I'll give it the old college try...
In that context then, am I supposed to try to improve my kick blocking strategy? I had tried to make the best kickblocking lineup I could, including scouting the other teams FGblock team. We got through the line as planned.
Would you say I should give up trying to plan to block kicks? Or does the graphic at least indicate I have a better chance of blocking a kick then if I had no penetration.
If it's not worth planning for, I'm totally cool with that -- but if there IS some way to improve your kick blocking chances, I figure I'll give it the old college try...
Edited by fishdan on Apr 20, 2012 07:49:58
IdRatherFlyFish
offline
offline
I think you've done the best you can to improve your chances. Any more effort is probably going to see diminishing returns.
http://www.glbwiki.com/qa/search.php - Search for FG, and the top few replies have Borts answers to FG block attempts, and what goes into the roll.
Bort March 23, 2012
Question What goes into the FG/XP block skills?
Answer The block kick roll is INCREDIBLY hard to pass, even if you're in the right position. However, it is essentially the same roll as pass deflection, without any VA's and SA's other than swat ball.
Bort March 23, 2012
Question Would deflect ball AE/VAs/SAs affect/enhance the FG block roll (presuming the vision check is passed)?
Answer The only one that currently applies is swat ball. The others are specific to passing.
Bort March 23, 2012
Question What goes into the FG/XP block skills?
Answer The block kick roll is INCREDIBLY hard to pass, even if you're in the right position. However, it is essentially the same roll as pass deflection, without any VA's and SA's other than swat ball.
Bort March 23, 2012
Question Would deflect ball AE/VAs/SAs affect/enhance the FG block roll (presuming the vision check is passed)?
Answer The only one that currently applies is swat ball. The others are specific to passing.
aaasahi
offline
offline
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=2038561&pbp_id=42233
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=2001445&pbp_id=10573266
I have a player made FG block 2 time at S27 and S28.
Funny thing is he has 0 in swat ball
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=2001445&pbp_id=10573266
I have a player made FG block 2 time at S27 and S28.
Funny thing is he has 0 in swat ball

Tobysmith6922
offline
offline
Originally posted by fishdan
yeah, I get that, but I think if you tackle the place holder that should end the play, just like IRL
May 8, 2011
- Make sure placeholder cannot be tackled on field goal or extra point kicks
That rule was put into place before there were FG/XP blocks implemented in the game, due to weird bugs that would result if the placeholder was tackled.
Now that we have blocks, it should probably be removed, as if you get to the placeholder too early, you take yourself out of the play, as seen on the first replay, with the DE bouncing off to the side.
yeah, I get that, but I think if you tackle the place holder that should end the play, just like IRL
May 8, 2011
- Make sure placeholder cannot be tackled on field goal or extra point kicks
That rule was put into place before there were FG/XP blocks implemented in the game, due to weird bugs that would result if the placeholder was tackled.
Now that we have blocks, it should probably be removed, as if you get to the placeholder too early, you take yourself out of the play, as seen on the first replay, with the DE bouncing off to the side.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.




























