User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Training attribute above 100 hardcoding bug(?) with 5 enhancements - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
mandyross
offline
Link
 
I have a player with an attribute just above 100 (http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=2357422 ) which I was hoping to train on light 5* enhanced for a 2% gain.

Here is the screenshot showing that speed is 5* enhanced: http://oi41.tinypic.com/15i9ddu.jpg

The training gains above 100 are hardcoded to be 1%, 1%, 1%, for intense, normal and light (I can provide screenshots from another player to show this). With the 5* (50%) enhancement, they go to 1.5 which is rounded to 2%, (this post from Catch contains the information to show that the halves are rounded up http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4663065&page=1#42707693 ).

So, for this player, I would expect speed to show a 2%, 2%, 2% training percentage for intense, normal and light after the 5* enhancement is applied.

Intense is at 2% as expected: http://oi43.tinypic.com/16idteo.jpg
Normal is at 2% as expected: http://oi41.tinypic.com/28k3914.jpg
But Light is stuck at 1%: http://oi41.tinypic.com/2ueoem8.jpg

(Just to confirm, I trained on light and the bar only went up 1%, as shown by comparing this image with the one above http://oi40.tinypic.com/2dc5q9l.jpg)

I suggest that it is possible the hardcoding which fixes these training values above 100 on light is slightly in the wrong order, and should be done before the enhancement is applied. Maybe the hardcoding remains from this changelog update, and it should be checked over to put it into line with the accelerated player development changes?

Originally posted by Changelog

Feb 12, 2010
- Make minimum training amount be 1% (not zero)
Edited by TruthHammer on Dec 1, 2011 12:09:30 (Closed - not a bug)
Edited by mandyross on Nov 26, 2011 21:01:55
 
Time Trial
offline
Link
 
Maybe light is being rounded up to 1%, and whatever it is enhanced five times doesn't reach 1.5?
 
TaySC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Time Trial
Maybe light is being rounded up to 1%, and whatever it is enhanced five times doesn't reach 1.5?


^^^^ this ^^^^

I am sure that they are rounded up to 1% (without the enhancements), but maybe on light (as Time Trial mentioned) it doesn't push them to 1.5.

Bort would be the only one to know for sure, so I am speculating here, but light shouldn't give as much return as intense, so let's speculate for a second.

Intense - 1.1 (rounded down to 1%)
Normal - 1.0
Light - .9 (rounded to 1%)

So with the 50% increase you would be looking at something like this I think:

Intense - 1.1 + .55 = 1.65% rounded to 2%
Normal - 1.0 + .50 = 1.50% rounded to 2%
Light - .9 + .45 = 1.35% rounded down to 1%

Now this is pure speculation as I have no facts to back it up, but I sincerely do not think this is a bug.

You seem to be basing that it has to be a bug off of each of the 1% automatically getting .5 to get to 1.5 and rounded to 2%, but that is not the way that I understand it to work. The enhancement IMHO is done off the actual training before it is rounded.

Edited by TaySC on Nov 26, 2011 22:35:07
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Perhaps don't train above that number. I dunno...seems logical.
 
-Achanceb4-
offline
Link
 
I'll be selling your build to other teams. Thanks for the info.
Just kidding.Originally posted by Toriq
Perhaps don't train above that number. I dunno...seems logical.


that
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Nice natural 100, too bad he will always be gimped now.
 
mandyross
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TaySC
Originally posted by Time Trial

Maybe light is being rounded up to 1%, and whatever it is enhanced five times doesn't reach 1.5?


^^^^ this ^^^^

I am sure that they are rounded up to 1% (without the enhancements), but maybe on light (as Time Trial mentioned) it doesn't push them to 1.5.

Bort would be the only one to know for sure, so I am speculating here, but light shouldn't give as much return as intense, so let's speculate for a second.

Intense - 1.1 (rounded down to 1%)
Normal - 1.0
Light - .9 (rounded to 1%)

So with the 50% increase you would be looking at something like this I think:

Intense - 1.1 + .55 = 1.65% rounded to 2%
Normal - 1.0 + .50 = 1.50% rounded to 2%
Light - .9 + .45 = 1.35% rounded down to 1%

Now this is pure speculation as I have no facts to back it up, but I sincerely do not think this is a bug.

You seem to be basing that it has to be a bug off of each of the 1% automatically getting .5 to get to 1.5 and rounded to 2%, but that is not the way that I understand it to work. The enhancement IMHO is done off the actual training before it is rounded.



This is not the way it works. I mentioned the way it works in the OP - Check out the Catch post that I linked to in the original post: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4663065&page=1#42707693

Originally posted by Catch22


So at 78, intense training value is probably somewhere between 4.5 and 5 as the display value is 5%. When training you will always get 5% unless you get a breakthrough.

With 3 enhancements at 78, training value is 6.5 but it rounds up and the display value is 7%. When training you will always get 7% unless you get a breakthrough


Also, above 100 everything does not follow the exponential function that runs from 6 to 99.9 (I can provide math to show this if required). It is explicitly put in.

Please can you get them to check the hardcoding of the training values?

As for training above that number - it's an experiment, isn't build experimentation one of the fun parts of this game? I realise that it is a little crazy, but I would like the opportunity to at least have a go at it and not be foiled by some hardcoding applied in February 2010, way before the APD changes were made.
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by

Feb 12, 2010
- Make minimum training amount be 1% (not zero)


This doesn't say that the minimum base training amount will be 1%. It just says minimum training. Have we seen anything anywhere that would let us know where in the process the minimum is applied?

For example, what if the light training value at that level is .4?

You're saying .4 rounds down to 0, minimum check brings it up to 1, enhancements take it to 1.5, it gets rounded to 2.

How do you know it's not this: .4 rounds down to 0. Enhancements applied, still 0. minimum check brings it up to 1.

 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
I think that's the point of posting in Bugs: to find out if it's really a bug or not.
 
mandyross
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TruthHammer
Originally posted by


Feb 12, 2010
- Make minimum training amount be 1% (not zero)


This doesn't say that the minimum base training amount will be 1%. It just says minimum training. Have we seen anything anywhere that would let us know where in the process the minimum is applied?

For example, what if the light training value at that level is .4?

You're saying .4 rounds down to 0, minimum check brings it up to 1, enhancements take it to 1.5, it gets rounded to 2.

How do you know it's not this: .4 rounds down to 0. Enhancements applied, still 0. minimum check brings it up to 1.



I think that this is correct. Thank you! The original training gain from 2010 (before even light, normal, intense came into existence) will be hardcoded at 1%.

Light is 0.4 of this, rounded to 0%. Any enhancement doesn't matter, and then some more hardcoding bumps it up to 1%.
Normal/intense are 0.85 and 1.1 of this, so rounded to 1%. Here the 50% enhancement will push it up to 1.5, rounded to 2%.

If possible, if you could check that the coders are happy to keep to original training gain hardcoded from 2010, and don't think it needs any modification for the new Advanced Player Development system, that would be great. I'm not convinced that the hardcoding from 2010 should still be in there, but if it is determined that this isn't a bug then so be it

I'll only kick up a stink if it is changed later on when my player is older and ruined
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mandyross

If possible, if you could check that the coders are happy to keep to original training gain hardcoded from 2010, and don't think it needs any modification for the new Advanced Player Development system, that would be great.


Unfortunately, we don't have easy access to the coders in that way. You could always PM Catch22. You'll have to wait a little while, but I think you'd probably get a more direct response from Bort if you ask in a Q&A.

Closing this for now.
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.