User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Depth Chart Bug - LBs - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
slughead42
Don't panic!
offline
Link
 
This will probably be a very long post, I'll try to include tons of examples, so bear with me. I can give GM rights to whomever needs them.

Here's the game in question - http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1842691 .

I put the selected DAI and Def depth chart into the tactics calendar, so I'm sure that the ones I thought were selected were in fact selected, and I haven't changed them any since the game simmed.

Basically, I have 2 LBs that are ONLY on the depth chart used for the game at RILB, LILB, and the ROLB1, MLB1 and LOLB1 slots. Yet, throughout the game, they show up where the DAI says it should be pulling from the MLB and/or LOLB slots, not the MLB1 and LOLB1 slots. I'm at a loss.

I hope someone can look at these and go, "Oh, yeah, dumbass, the problem is that...etc."

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1842691&pbp_id=5623777
LOLB is set to "LOLB" on play output, but pulls from LOLB1.
Custom defensive play name is "35", the output in the DAI is "35".

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1842691&pbp_id=5624812
MLB is set to "MLB", LOLB is set to "LOLB". MLB pulls from MLB1, LOLB pulls from LOLB1.
Custom defensive play name is "Z2Big I 326 *HB *TE *TE2 *FB PQB", the output in the DAI is "Big I 434 *HB *TE *TE2 *FB PQB".

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1842691&pbp_id=5624844
LOLB is set to "LOLB" on play output, but pulls from LOLB1.
Custom defensive play name is "35", the output in the DAI is "35".

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1842691&pbp_id=5624897
MLB is set to "MLB", LOLB is set to "LOLB". MLB pulls from MLB1, LOLB pulls from LOLB1.
Custom defensive play name is "31", the output in the DAI is "31".

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1842691&pbp_id=5625030
MLB is set to "LOLB" on play output, but pulls from MLB1.
Custom defensive play name is "34", the output in the DAI is "34".

I can pull more than this, I'm pretty sure, if you need more, just let me know. Thanks in advance for any/all help, you guys.
Edited by Sirwin on Dec 2, 2011 12:33:33
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Send me a GM, I'll take a look at it for you.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Also this is a very good bugs post, lots of info, but need to check a few other obvious things.

Formation Overrides
Package Overrides
Are Plays/Packages being used via the Team / My / GM location

FWIW, the details you posted so far show the Sim is following the Formation Overrides precisely as they are right now.
 
slughead42
Don't panic!
offline
Link
 
Thanks Mike! If I'm reading your quote correctly, you were looking on info on whether I was using packages to make my DAI, to see if maybe an override in a package setting conflicted with the DAI setting...the answer is no, I don't use packages on defense, I just script the DAI and put in custom plays for each output, 1-1 matchup for the most part.

Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Also this is a very good bugs post, lots of info, but need to check a few other obvious things.

Formation Overrides
Package Overrides
Are Plays/Packages being used via the Team / My / GM location

FWIW, the details you posted so far show the Sim is following the Formation Overrides precisely as they are right now.


I'm a little confused about your last sentence...I would expect that, if that meant the MLB1 spot was ALWAYS going to override the MLB spot (like the WR1-5 spots override the WR spot), then I would ALWAYS see some combination of the two LBs that are listed in the "LB1" slots on defense, but that's not what's happening; there are a lot of formations, apparently, where the depth chart seems to be working fine, and pulls from the regular MLB or LOLB slot when it's called for in the DAI, even though there are 2 LBs in the LB1 slots at that position.

The thing that is making me nuts is that some formations DON'T do that, as I listed above. In all of the examples I listed, the sim is pulling in a linebacker from the "1" slot for that position, instead of the regular slot, and I can't figure out why.

As a side note, I know there's probably a thread somewhere about the exact order that the sim uses when filling spots on the field, right? I mean as far as it pulls the NT and then the DT, or the MLB then the LOLB, that kind of thing. I looked in the Wiki for something about it, but couldn't find anything...could anyone point me to something on that score?

Thanks so much for the continued help.
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
Formation depth chart: http://goallineblitz.com/game/formation_depth_chart.pl?team_id=1317

I think the question is: on the plays where it's pulling MLB1 instead of MLB, is the MLB dropdown set to MLB or to the blank?
 
slughead42
Don't panic!
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CDZYO
Formation depth chart: http://goallineblitz.com/game/formation_depth_chart.pl?team_id=1317

I think the question is: on the plays where it's pulling MLB1 instead of MLB, is the MLB dropdown set to MLB or to the blank?


Ahhh...thanks. All the dropdown choices ARE set in the DAI currently, at one point in the offseason I re-set some of them to be blank instead of having a choice in there but I put it back once I started having troubles with the depth chart.

So, could what's happening be that, if you have a "1" slot chosen on the Formation Depth Chart tab, it will override even a regular slot chosen in the DAI in a specific output (i.e. if you have "MLB1" chosen on the Formation Depth Chart and "MLB" chosen in your DAI output, it will still take the MLB1 slot), but if you choose the regular slots on the Formation Depth Chart tab, you will still be able to override with the "1" slots in specific outputs in the DAI?

If that's, in fact, the way it works and the way it's INTENDED to work, then it's just a case of me not knowing that, and needing to update my choices on the Formation Depth Chart.
Edited by slughead42 on Nov 18, 2011 07:06:04
 
slughead42
Don't panic!
offline
Link
 
Based on the feedback, I'm going to assume that things work (and are intended to work) like my previous post right above this states. I'm going to link to a screen capture of the way my Depth Chart Formation tab WAS set up during the game in question, but I'm going to change it sometime tonight because I have a game tomorrow that I'd like it to be different for.

https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/-a2tFVtbJ0CU/TsbjonOIXEI/AAAAAAAAEbc/GuaY4bYmklQ/s800/Slackers%252520D%252520formation%252520depth%252520chart.png

Thanks to everyone who's helped me out so far with this, and thanks in advance for any Bugs Mod that can shed further light on it, if any.
 
bug03
offline
Link
 
yeah, just go through and fix the formation overrides.
 
Sirwin
offline
Link
 
Is this still an issue?

Sending a PM to the OP
 
Sirwin
offline
Link
 
Per PM from OP, closing this thread
 
Sirwin
offline
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.