User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Game engine -casual - last minutes - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Dregget
offline
Link
 
Hi,
not used to this part of the official forum so don't flame me, at least not to hard.

I lost a game today, and it was a scrim so the result is not any big deal. Looking closer at the play-by-play it really gives a few questions.

This is the game.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1713434&mode=pbp

The "bugs" start after 2 min left in game.

Gotland Gladiators 2:00
2:00 4th & 4 OWN 16.5 Punt by iPunt , 39 yd, fielded by Fenrir Gladiator™ (21.5 yd return) [tackle: Brother Samuel]
1:50 1st & 10 OPP 34 Balder Gladiator rush to the left (7 yd gain) [tackle: Deunta Culliver]
1:07 2nd & 3 OPP 27 MicahelVickAmus Maximus rush to the right (1 yd gain) [diving tackle: Jason Loolen]
1:02 3rd & 2 OPP 26 Offensive Timeout Called: Gotland Gladiators
1:02 3rd & 2 OPP 26 Option QB Verser rush to the left (3 yd gain) [diving tackle: Deunta Culliver]
0:55 1st & 10 OPP 23 Offensive Timeout Called: Gotland Gladiators
0:55 1st & 10 OPP 23 Balder Gladiator rush to the left (5.5 yd gain) [tackle: Wal CB]
0:36 2nd & 4.5 OPP 17 34 yd field goal attempted by Hymir Gladiator™, made [FG]

El Mano Negro 0:32
0:32 Kickoff by Hymir Gladiator™, 48 yd, fielded by Lightning in a Bottle! (15.5 yd return) [tackle: Judur Gladiator™]
0:29 1st & 10 OWN 37.5 Peyton "Madden" Hillis rush to the left (1 yd loss) [diving tackle: Hermod Gladiator]
0:26 2nd & 11 OWN 36.5 Offensive Timeout Called: El Mano Negro
0:26 2nd & 11 OWN 36.5 I'm Batman rush to the left (2.5 yd gain) [tackle: Ull Gladiator]
0:21 3rd & 8.5 OWN 39 Offensive Timeout Called: El Mano Negro

0:21 3rd & 8.5 OWN 39 Ulti Dot pitch to Peyton "Madden" Hillis [TD] to the right (61 yd gain)
0:07 Extra point attempted by Giant Foot, made [XP]

Gotland Gladiators 0:07
0:07 Kickoff by Giant Foot, 55 yd, fielded by Fenrir Gladiator™ (19 yd return) [diving tackle: Wal CB]
0:03 1st & 10 OWN 33.5 MicahelVickAmus Maximus rush to the left (4 yd gain) [tackle: Monster Von]

Question 1:
Why does my team (Gladiators) call two offensive time outs with less than two minutes left, shouldn't they just run the clock down when they are in the lead. I guess the same applies for my opponent later on also calling an offensive time out being in front.

Question 2:
With 0:36 left on clock and a 2nd and 4,5 left and in the lead the team decried to go for a field goal. Why, must be better to keep the ball at least to a 4th down situation and then decide to kick or punt? At 2nd and 4,5 it should be pretty probable to get a new 1st down instead.

Don't know if it is a know issue or not. But I find it not to be a good siming at that important stage of the game. As it was, it was a scrim between the losers of the semis with a win more each it would have been for the championship. Casual is less than regular but it shouldn't act improbable.

/Dregget

Edited by Sirwin on Jun 21, 2011 15:39:52
Edited by Dregget on Jun 21, 2011 14:41:14
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
first one, you were tied during your drive. The score was 24-24 So you were trying to make sure that you would not run out of time while attempting to score, whether a TD or a FG.

Would it be better to run the clock down and kick a 1 second FG? Maybe but that would be more of a suggestion. I could see cases to do it either way. But in your drive, i would say the casual AI is trying it's best to score a TD with the time remaining.

The above pretty much answers question 2 as well. Since you were not in the lead at that point, and you were running out of time, kicking a FG seemed to be the best choice for you. You were running out of time and with complaints/suggestions in the past that the sim wasn't kicking FG's in these situations or wasting too much clock time and running out of time to kick FG's bort has had to be more cautious with how the basic AI works in these situations.

There really isn't a bug here, it's more of a suggestion that how the sim treats late game situations may not be optimal. Which many will agree.
 
Sirwin
offline
Link
 
In all actuality these are working as intended and are not bugs, but more of suggestions for Casual settings.
 
Dregget
offline
Link
 
Sorry, I made a miscalculation on the score. I guess that change it around quite bit.

Your reasoning is logical and make sense, thanks.
Sorry for blowing the horn before getting the facts right.

/Dregget
 
Sirwin
offline
Link
 
Marking as Not A Bug and Locking
 
Sirwin
offline
Link
 
Thread moved by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.