User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
sborats
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1699820&pbp_id=1106142
Called a passing play

Tested with the AI tester:
Matching Input
Input Named: 4th down, out of FG Range

Possible Outputs

Please investigate
100% Punt ()
Edited by TruthHammer on May 9, 2011 12:26:21 (Private Scrimmage)
 
Sirwin
offline
Link
 
Private scrimmage.

Rule #6 of the Bugs Forum - Bugs Mod or QA can not view private scrimmages. Do not post links to private scrimmages. If you do the thread will be locked and labeled as not a bug.


Can you find this in another game that is not private? If not, we will need to lock this as Not A Bug.
 
sborats
offline
Link
 
same scrimmage: this play as well

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1699820&pbp_id=1106953
called a running play

Tested with AI tester:
Matching Input
Input Named: 4th down, FG range

Possible Outputs
100% Field Goal ()
 
sborats
offline
Link
 
sorry, but this happened twice. Anybody want to serious investigate, I will give them GM powers.

It happened at least twice.
 
Sirwin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sborats
sorry, but this happened twice. Anybody want to serious investigate, I will give them GM powers.

It happened at least twice.


We would like to investigate but it can not be in a private scrimmage. We must have a non-private game replay to look at.
 
sborats
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sirwin
We would like to investigate but it can not be in a private scrimmage. We must have a non-private game replay to look at.


happened a 3rd time in same game. Since it is a private scrimmage, you brush under the rug? I can give somebody GM rights.

??
 
sborats
offline
Link
 
4th time for the Fail:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1699820&pbp_id=1112301
ran ball

Tested with AI tester:
Matching Input
Input Named: 4th down, FG range

Possible Outputs
100% Field Goal ()

fix sim please
Edited by sborats on May 9, 2011 11:05:36
 
Farlig
offline
Link
 
Not a bug mod but I'd be happy to take a look at it as typically these errors are AI based and not GLB's coding.
 
sborats
offline
Link
 
I ran the AI test for the playcalling AI and manually looked the AI as well.
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
The tester does not always give you the answer you need. Since we can't see the plays i will give you a random example.

Lets say you have an AI that says, between the goal and opp 30, you will kick a FG, and have another AI that says from opp 35 to your goal you will punt. This is on 4th downs of course. And you are on the 30.1 yard line (it will say, ball on the 30) you will run whatever just a basic non AI sim setting (similar to casual)

You can test it for what the PBP says (opp 30 yard line) but what you can't see if that it was beyond the range you set up for the FG range.

So have farlig take a look, or i can take a look and see if there is a reason for why this is happening. But posting more links from a private scrimmage, that they have told you they can't help you with and is in the rules of the bug forum that says they can't use it, won't really help. These are almost always some sort of error in the AI, or just something not accounted for that may not be obviously wrong.

Try to get a non private scrimmage with the same results you saw. The bug mods can't generally work with private scrimmages and will have to lock them up.
Edited by alindyl on May 9, 2011 11:25:22
 
Farlig
offline
Link
 
Well up to you, but I'll look if you want.
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
alindyl a and Farlig have volunteered to help you. I'll take a look too if you want, but considering a private scrim as part of a bug report is not an option.

In order to determine a repeatable, valid bug, we need to ask the userbase to provide us with additional examples of suspicious behavior. This can help us mods, the testers, and the developers to recognize patterns where the issue occur as well as verify that there is no other subtle but legitimate reason for the behavior.

Sure, the bugs mods could get a GM to see a private scrim, but there's no way to let the helpful people who monitor this forum see those plays. So we can't get additional examples.

Please re-submit the report if you see the same behavior in a publicly viewable game.
 
Pwned
offline
Link
 
The main issue with a Private scrimmage is you will have to give access to each of the 3-4 Bugs Mods who look into the issue, and then again, the Bugs Coordinators, who file the bug, on through the entire process.

It's a huge amount of extra time that has bogged down the Bug Forum in the past hence the rule being instated.

Granted this rule has been nullified on certain scenarios like the Blocked Extra point plays, but generally as always..

AI discrepancies are nearly 99% of the time due to user error.
 
Sirwin
offline
Link
 
I've sent a PM to sborats, since he sent me GM access, and let him know that we can look at the AI, plays, etc, but we can't file a report because of the issues you've listed above. I'll take a look at it and see what I can find, but it's possible that the wrong setting has been changed already.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.