User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > kick off problem - NOT A BUG - CLOSED - #486
lellosnow
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1541104&pbp_id=5154505

please don't say working as intended.. i'll punch you in the face
Edited by TruthHammer on Jan 29, 2011 00:32:08 (Was directed by Catch22 to close this one.)
Edited by VolBrian on Jan 28, 2011 07:56:37 (Not likely a bug)
 
Rikkhen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lellosnow
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1541104&pbp_id=5154505

please don't say working as intended.. i'll punch you in the face


Whats the PROBLEM you are referring to if i may ask?
 
avwjase
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lellosnow
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=1541104&pbp_id=5154505

please don't say working as intended.. i'll punch you in the face


Well, it is working as intended. In the world of GLB there are: A) no 2 point conversions and B) no kickoff team recoveries on kickoffs.

I do think the coverage team should stop and not run past the ball laying on the ground (so they can prevent the TD) but that is a personal opinion of mine. Catch has spoken on this issue several times and to my knowledge has clearly said that this is working as intended as per Bort.
 
NickyNapoleon
offline
Link
 
HAHA The coverage team runs 8 yards past the ball, one player runs through the ball. If you arent going to let them recover it then treat it like a punt and when they touch the ball teh play is dead. But that is insane and if working as intended then this game is more broken than I realized and as someone who has been here since season 2 thats saying something.
 
ateam1026
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NickyNapoleon
HAHA The coverage team runs 8 yards past the ball, one player runs through the ball. If you arent going to let them recover it then treat it like a punt and when they touch the ball teh play is dead. But that is insane and if working as intended then this game is more broken than I realized and as someone who has been here since season 2 thats saying something.


100% agree
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
1) The kick returner shouldn't run so far in front of the kick that it sails over his head.
2) If it does happen, the kickoff team should be allowed to down the ball instead of waiting for the official returner to touch it.
3) If the kickoff team is going to wait for the kick returner to touch the ball, they should still converge on the ball so that when the returner *does* touch it, he doesn't have open field in front of him.

Grant that these are sophomore-level players -- low vision, whatever. Why isn't the kickoff team playing the ball?
 
NickyNapoleon
offline
Link
 
There are so many problems with this play its not funny. CDZYO just pointed out teh return team, but why is teh coverage team not converging either. You have a kickoff that goes right yet teh guys on the left run straight down teh field unblocked and past teh ball more than half a field away. I understand lane discipline but thats ridiculous. Lets not forget teh three players covering the kick closest to the ball who run unblocked until seconds after teh ball is picked up. They run straight up teh field to the area teh ball is kicked but never go to the ball
Edited by NickyNapoleon on Jan 28, 2011 07:47:16
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Here's the thing with these issues as I've stated quite a few times:

Originally posted by CDZYO
1) The kick returner shouldn't run so far in front of the kick that it sails over his head.
2) If it does happen, the kickoff team should be allowed to down the ball instead of waiting for the official returner to touch it.
3) If the kickoff team is going to wait for the kick returner to touch the ball, they should still converge on the ball so that when the returner *does* touch it, he doesn't have open field in front of him.

Grant that these are sophomore-level players -- low vision, whatever. Why isn't the kickoff team playing the ball?


These are all suggestions. I keep saying that, but if all of the vitriol that is put into these various threads regarding kickoff coverage were consolidated into a suggestion and get the thing on the ballot, maybe some results can be had.

Originally posted by NickyNapoleon
There are so many problems with this play its not funny. CDZYO just pointed out teh return team, but why is teh coverage team not converging either. You have a kickoff that goes right yet teh guys on the left run straight down teh field unblocked and past teh ball more than half a field away. I understand lane discipline but thats ridiculous. Lets not forget teh three players covering the kick closest to the ball who run unblocked until seconds after teh ball is picked up. They run straight up teh field to the area teh ball is kicked but never go to the ball


I agree that there are multiple ways that this could be changed, but as it is, it is not a bug.

I can't call something that Bort has intentionally coded a Bug in the software. If you think there is a "Bug" in his thinking or planning of the coverage design so be it, but until Bort says otherwise, this is how he set it up and he did so with purpose.

Not likely a bug - #486
 
DTRAIN
offline
Link
 
i feel for u Mods. you guys are put in a position to have to defend lolcodes that everyone knows is horrific. the kick return team gains a coded advantage because their KR guy cant get to the ball. so the Kick off team is now out of position and gets punished. and thats working as intended....?? really.


maybe it should be coded to randomly position the KR and his 3 blockers, and code the K to kick it more in the direction of the KR. it doesnt need to be directly at him, but just in his general direction. this would solve the problem.
Edited by DTRAIN on Jan 28, 2011 09:10:29
Edited by DTRAIN on Jan 28, 2011 09:09:19
 
amace
offline
Link
 
Not a bug, it's just not coded into the game.

would be more of a lacking feature than a bug.
 
CDZYO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
I can't call something that Bort has intentionally coded a Bug in the software. If you think there is a "Bug" in his thinking or planning of the coverage design so be it, but until Bort says otherwise, this is how he set it up and he did so with purpose.


I agree with you on all points. The confusion comes from not knowing if it's an intentional coding or an inadvertent coding. By directing us elsewhere, I think the system is working as intended. I'll put something in the Suggestions forum (unless someone beats me to it).
 
TruthHammer
Lead Bugs Mod
offline
Link
 
Closing - not a bug.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.