Originally posted by LT56
Tay
I've never seen it stated anywhere, what is the criteria for a bug (here at GLB)?For something to be a bug it must meet certain criteria and be "coded" by Bort to work in a different way.
Regardless of any of our thoughts, some things are not or have not yet been, "coded" to work a certain way.... thus posters get the "working as intended" reply because it IS working as Bort coded it.
Another problem with this thread in particular is that the agent is trying to tell us that this is a bug, which directly goes against the forum rules and undermines the entire process.
None of us claims to be perfect. The system is now set up to have multiple mods trained to review these to all put in "votes" on if they think a certain issue meets the criteria to be a bug (i.e. not working as intended). Catch22 sees a lot more in this forum than most think and even discusses in private how certain things should and should not be handled.
A few things that need to be understood here though are what Catch22 posted in this forums rules:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3684419Originally posted by
Rule #3 of the Bugs Forum - we have a Bugs Moderation Team for a reason. It is fine to post examples of issues you believe are bugs or to help identify a bug. It is, however, not your place to state whether an issue is a bug or not.
Originally posted by
Rule #4 of the Bugs Forum - you will not always agree with the final resolution of a bug. That is completely understandable. If you have a problem with anything in the Bugs Forums, please contact one of the Leads or Bugs Coordinators. If they do not address your issue to your satisfaction, then contact Catch22 via private message. If you are unhappy with how a bug was classified or what my final determination was, please contact me via private message and we will discuss it. It's possible that the process is wrong and if that is the case, I'll be more than happy to revisit our determination. Please, however, do not create a new thread about the issue - it will be locked without any further consideration.