User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > This player was dropped or traded from your team within the last 20 days. - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
SexyNinja
offline
Link
 
Just got this team, i haven't released anyone, and no one left since i got the team, which was today. I have been running into this error message, Should I be since it wasn't my team when these guys left?
Edited by doobas on Oct 30, 2010 10:31:27 (Working as intended)
Edited by VolBrian on Oct 29, 2010 07:18:48 (Not likely)
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
Seems like it's functioning correctly. The 20 day trading is linked to the team, not the owner.
 
SexyNinja
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
Seems like it's functioning correctly. The 20 day trading is linked to the team, not the owner.


that's not what i'm saying, since i'm the new owner, any players that were dropped previous are unavailable to me, maybe it should be re-set or something when the team is sold. which is going to suggested if it's deemed not a bug.0
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
No i understand what you're saying, and no that should not be reset. It could open the door to some abuse. So if players left a team under previous ownership, there is a 20 day re-signing restriction attached to the team.

A possible example could be a team pays it's players huge salaries in the beginning. They are going to miss the playoffs so the owner cuts everyone, sells the team. Co-owner buys the team, picks up all the players at min contracts and finishes out the season avoiding paying extra millions.

There are likely other ways people could find to cheat the system but hopefully you get the point. But the point is that preventing teams from picking up players it cut for 20 days is not a bug, it's the working as intended.

If you really want players that left/were cut from that team previously, find out when they left, figure out when the 20 days will be up and pick them up again at that point.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
This is not a bug at all. It's designed in part to prevent exactly situations like above. Changing this in any form would definitely be a suggestion.

Not likely a bug
 
gbororats
Bugs Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
No i understand what you're saying, and no that should not be reset. It could open the door to some abuse. So if players left a team under previous ownership, there is a 20 day re-signing restriction attached to the team.

A possible example could be a team pays it's players huge salaries in the beginning. They are going to miss the playoffs so the owner cuts everyone, sells the team. Co-owner buys the team, picks up all the players at min contracts and finishes out the season avoiding paying extra millions.

There are likely other ways people could find to cheat the system but hopefully you get the point. But the point is that preventing teams from picking up players it cut for 20 days is not a bug, it's the working as intended.

If you really want players that left/were cut from that team previously, find out when they left, figure out when the 20 days will be up and pick them up again at that point.


Just realized thats my former team, were you trying to sign my guys? I owned the team, someone bought it, i release a lot of my own players after the first purchase, and then i guess the team was sold again and repurchased by you.... i'm guessing you are trying to resign players that left within the last week when i sold it and it was rebought.

if you suck that bad early in the season what is the incentive to stay on the team? you cant cut players after the trade deadline, and you would have to sell the team, giving them the opportunity to release themselves. Why wouldnt you just send new contract offers out at lower money. You can always renegotiate new contracts mid season for less money. That theory is asinine. Why go through all the trouble selling a team to accomplish lower salaries. You will need a better answer than that...
Edited by gbororats on Oct 29, 2010 09:12:43
Edited by gbororats on Oct 29, 2010 09:03:23
 
alindyl
offline
Link
 
I'm not quite sure if i follow your post but i'll assume the first paragraph was for the OP, and the second was for me.

Unless something changed, according to what catch posted here http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3946717 you cannot negotiate contracts down during the season.

Specific quote:
"You can renegotiate the contracts of players that are currently on the team as often as you wish. If in renegotiating upwards you go over the Salary Cap, the amount you are over the Cap will go towards the Luxury Tax. You can only renegotiate upwards, not downwards. If you want to renegotiate a contract downwards, you can only do so in the off season. League Minimum Salary will equal .5% of the league Salary Cap. League Maximum Salary will equal 5% of the league Salary Cap." Bolded the specific point.

Considering i've seen complaints about people coming into teams where players are signed for salaries putting them over the cap and not being able to fix it, i'm guessing this is still the case.

Also this:
"That theory is asinine. Why go through all the trouble selling a team to accomplish lower salaries. You will need a better answer than that..." is not really called for. Plus you would be surprised what some people will do in order to try to get an advantage in this game. That was just something that i thought of as an example while typing my post.
 
Mightyhalo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
"That theory is asinine. Why go through all the trouble selling a team to accomplish lower salaries. You will need a better answer than that..." is not really called for. Plus you would be surprised what some people will do in order to try to get an advantage in this game. That was just something that i thought of as an example while typing my post.


Yeah if there is a way to game the system, someone will find it so that is why this is a good rule.
 
gbororats
Bugs Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by alindyl
I'm not quite sure if i follow your post but i'll assume the first paragraph was for the OP, and the second was for me.

Unless something changed, according to what catch posted here http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3946717 you cannot negotiate contracts down during the season.

Specific quote:
"You can renegotiate the contracts of players that are currently on the team as often as you wish. If in renegotiating upwards you go over the Salary Cap, the amount you are over the Cap will go towards the Luxury Tax. You can only renegotiate upwards, not downwards. If you want to renegotiate a contract downwards, you can only do so in the off season. League Minimum Salary will equal .5% of the league Salary Cap. League Maximum Salary will equal 5% of the league Salary Cap." Bolded the specific point.




I just sent myself a contract for a lower salary and it went through, so if this is the case then it is NOT working as intended and that in itself should be a bug. So what catch says, and what actually is possible contradict each other and is yet another case of poor QA in the GLB management.

Edit: They seem to type up a lot of crap and fluff on this site, but actually implimenting it is a different story. Just because they said they are going to do it, doesnt mean they actually follow through with it. Is this a loophole? maybe. You want me to prove to you the lower salary works? i will

Edited by gbororats on Oct 29, 2010 12:25:52
Edited by gbororats on Oct 29, 2010 12:22:28
 
SexyNinja
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gbororats
I just sent myself a contract for a lower salary and it went through, so if this is the case then it is NOT working as intended and that in itself should be a bug. So what catch says, and what actually is possible contradict each other and is yet another case of poor QA in the GLB management.

Edit: They seem to type up a lot of crap and fluff on this site, but actually implimenting it is a different story. Just because they said they are going to do it, doesnt mean they actually follow through with it. Is this a loophole? maybe. You want me to prove to you the lower salary works? i will





You sent yourself a contract for a lower amount then your initial contract?
 
doobas
™
offline
Link
 
It lets you negotiate lower after day 24, btw.

doobas™
 
gbororats
Bugs Moderator
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by doobas
It lets you negotiate lower after day 24, btw.

doobas™


Exactly, so there is no need to gut an entire team, so what legitimate hole is this stopping during a new team purchase. This prevents dropping entire teams, dropping down, then resigning. But doesn't hard level caps do the same?
 
doobas
™
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gbororats
Exactly, so there is no need to gut an entire team, so what legitimate hole is this stopping during a new team purchase. This prevents dropping entire teams, dropping down, then resigning. But doesn't hard level caps do the same?


This should be posted in suggestions, as it isn't a bug.

doobas™
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.