User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Player's energy gets lower while he's standing waiting on the ball - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Not here, in Bugs. But in a system where people can suggest things that they think are illogical results, but others may not, like this very case in point, it's a very gray area.

LOL... we will have to agree to disagree.
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Presuming that he didn't move at all prior to coming into the screen for the catch? In other words, he was standing in the same spot-ish the entire play from kick to catch? With that presumption, than no, I don't think they should use up that much energy by any means. A couple 2-3 points maybe depending on their stamina level, but not half the acceleration amount. We don't know what's happening off screen though. In my game today, my KR caught one at the backline of the endzone for a touchback. I didn't think to check his energy, but I'm sure he used some getting back there to make that catch..


I'm not talking about off the screen, even though this is data that bort could see. No, I'm referring to the 12 ticks can be counted, on both the punt AND the kickoff after he comes on the screen and is clearly not moving, and yet he seems to lose a point of energy while clearly standing still.

BTW, the suggestion is here: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4204461 i revived Plankton's old post.
Edited by TheGreatPuma on Aug 31, 2010 09:37:59
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Not here, in Bugs. But in a system where people can suggest things that they think are illogical results, but others may not, like this very case in point, it's a very gray area.


LOL@ very gray.... whatever. Apparently logic is something that is completely forgotten in GLB.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by toobad4u_00
LOL@ very gray.... whatever. Apparently logic is something that is completely forgotten in GLB.


This is not a gray area. We are both in agreement that it's not a bug. Bort has designed it this way and this is the way he intended it to work. The gray area is the value of how much energy should be lost in some people's opinion. Some people's opinion = Gray area.
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
It's not logic so much as it is GLB has defined bugs narrowly so as to avoid arguments like this one. Even though it makes no sense, it was coded by bort "intentionally" (regardless of how little thought he may have put into it) so it's not a bug. I get that. But it's not really a suggestion in the real sense either as it's not necessarily something that should warrant a suggestion. I mean why should I need to suggest the fact that players shouldn't lose energy for standing still? My guess is if you asked 100 people in this game if they thought their player should lose energy while standing still, 100 would say "no".

What further allows this to happen is the fact that no one knows how anything is supposed to work. THere's no documents or anything else that says "yes, if a player is on the field his energy will constantly drain regardless of his movement". Mainly because if they did something like this there would be thousands more bugs.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma
I'm not talking about off the screen, even though this is data that bort could see. No, I'm referring to the 12 ticks can be counted, on both the punt AND the kickoff after he comes on the screen and is clearly not moving, and yet he seems to lose a point of energy while clearly standing still.

BTW, the suggestion is here: http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=4204461 i revived Plankton's old post.


Are we talking about ONE point of energy now from standing still? Because the response I gave and you quoted was for a larger hit to the tune of 50% of the acceleration value. The hit should be that large as I stated presuming none of that energy is lost in the returner's movements to get in position.

One hit to energy whilst standing to catch is acceptable imo. 6-7-ish while the returner is standing waiting to catch is something that should be changed, again imo.
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
This is not a gray area. We are both in agreement that it's not a bug. Bort has designed it this way and this is the way he intended it to work. The gray area is the value of how much energy should be lost in some people's opinion. Some people's opinion = Gray area.


are you saying I am saying this is not a bug??????????????????????????????

This is a bug. This is not a matter of opinion or what I like or dislike. This is a matter of logic and what would be expected to occur. A bug is something that occurs outside the norm. It does not matter if it was intentionally coded to be as such. It could fall under the category as a known and unlikely to change issue.. but it is a bug.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by toobad4u_00
are you saying I am saying this is not a bug??????????????????????????????


No, I'm saying that the OP and I are in agreement that it's not a bug.
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
Are we talking about ONE point of energy now from standing still? Because the response I gave and you quoted was for a larger hit to the tune of 50% of the acceleration value. The hit should be that large as I stated presuming none of that energy is lost in the returner's movements to get in position.

One hit to energy whilst standing to catch is acceptable imo. 6-7-ish while the returner is standing waiting to catch is something that should be changed, again imo.


Ugh.

I'm talking about my player losing energy while standing still, and yes, based on the fact that I can see him standing still as describe in my OP. He loses 2 energy over the course of 24 ticks while standing still, waiting to catch the ball. Then when he accelerates, he begins to lose energy at about 1 per 8 ticks. That's how I came up with 50%.

Obviously, I can't know how long he was standing still before he came onto the screen. However, perhaps someone could figure out a way to determine this...?
Edited by TheGreatPuma on Aug 31, 2010 09:51:26
 
toobad4u_00
offline
Link
 
geesh the damn forums are screwing up so badly right now..... I wrote:



LOL... we will have to agree to disagree.


after I tried to post this and was redirected:

LOL@ very gray.... whatever. Apparently logic is something that is completely forgotten in GLB.

Then I thought better of it and came back to edit the post and noticed it did not post and thus determined I could post what I thought would be better:

LOL... we will have to agree to disagree.

turns out it later caught up and posted the:


LOL@ very gray.... whatever. Apparently logic is something that is completely forgotten in GLB.


then I thought you were responding to:


LOL... we will have to agree to disagree.

because I did not know it ever posted:


LOL@ very gray.... whatever. Apparently logic is something that is completely forgotten in GLB.

is anyone else confused.... Yeah things are great overall.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Edit: double post.
Edited by VolBrian on Aug 31, 2010 10:11:11
Edited by VolBrian on Aug 31, 2010 10:09:30
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma

I'm talking about my player losing energy while standing still, and yes, based on the fact that I can see him standing still as describe in my OP. He loses 2 energy over the course of 24 ticks while standing still, waiting to catch the ball. Then when he accelerates, he begins to lose energy at about 1 per 8 ticks. That's how I came up with 50%.


Ok, same page then, no presumptions. Tbh he should probably lose a little more on acceleration than less during the catch period, but that's just my opinion.

Bort may decide he doesn't like the way he set up the energy system and redo it like morale, but we'll just have to see I suppose.
 
blaslo
offline
Link
 
I agree that this is not a bug. First off, the replay has always been an approximation of what is happening. Everybody has always known that what you see the replay is not EXACTLY what might have happened in the simulation. This means that, in my mind, while it might appear on the simulation that a player was standing still before receiving a kickoff or punt, maybe he actually had to run a couple of yards. That, combined with the adrenaline of bracing yourself for the catch, knowing you might get blasted while you are in a vulnerable position, any number of things could add up to the loss of a couple of points of energy prior to getting the ball in this situation.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.