User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > First step broken at low levels? - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
Page:
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Don't read too much into that response, it was a theory why your dot may have done that.

Not all players have 115 speed, 8 in FS, but only 20 Vision. In other words, your current build may have enabled your dot to do this, but it doesn't mean every dot with 20 or less vision is gonna run straight out of bounds. Most of those dots won't be going nearly as fast as your guy is or is capable of.

The bottom line question is, what is the bug here?

It's not First Step because that's obviously firing so is it a bug that players are able to run out of bounds period? Should a player with only 20 Vision act in the same fashion as one with 50 Vision and the same other attributes? If the player does make the cut to keep from running out of bounds regardless of vision or agility level, what should the "penalty" be? Should he hesitate and get tackled or caught? Would we then be talking about whether or not his hesitation is a bug or why he can get caught from behind with that speed?

I don't think this is a bug or a flaw in the system whatsoever tbh. I simply think it's a combination of build attributes that has allowed this to happen. Once your other attributes catch up, I'm sure he'll be a stud and would never do this. If it is happening all the time with players of any and all levels running straight out of bounds then it's an issue, but I have no other replays here showing this to be the case.

EDIT:

I have and do see this with PeeWee players from time to time and it's usually an issue with too much speed and not enough agility or vision to make or see the cut. Not every PeeWee player or lower-leveled dot is just going to run straight out of bounds, but when it occasionally happens it's usually because of that.
Edited by VolBrian on Aug 30, 2010 15:45:02
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
I'm leaving this as Needs More Info to give people opportunity to post examples/replays of simply.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Well right. I think we can posit certain suggestions for WHY it happens, and whether it happens consistently.

The real question, imo, is SHOULD it happen. And I would contend that no "football" player at any level would run out of bounds for no reason. So if these little dots are supposed to represent football players, on any level, then they shouldn't do THAT, which means it needs to be fixed. If a person IRL has too much speed to make the turn what does he do? He slows down. How is it possible that speed can be a bad thing because our dots don't have the ability to slow down like real football players?

In real life, just because a player can run a 4.3 40 doesn't mean he HAS to hit that speed even if it sends him careening out of bounds. But in GLB high attributes can be a negative, because Bort hasn't figured out how to make the dots assess how much of their abilities it is appropriate to use to succeed.
Edited by tjking82 on Aug 30, 2010 15:52:14
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
I think we need to remember the separation here. No real-life football players may do that, but no real life football players have the ability to add First Step. I don't mean to be glib either. I think it's a valid distinction that we're not talking about real life here. There have to be some penalties for having attributes at such a low level and one in this case is that he likely will miss some cuts like here or may run straight into a defender other times or something.

Also, who's to say he wasn't afraid of a possible hit by the chasing defender and ran out to avoid it? That happens at all levels of football as well.

I've got to head out, but y'all feel free to discuss the issue. If examples come up where WR's are doing this regularly and it can't be pinned to something like this then obviously we'll kick it up, but until then I simply think this is a one- (or very few) time occurrence where his low vision and extreme speed screwed him.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tjking82

In real life, just because a player can run a 4.3 40 doesn't mean he HAS to hit that speed even if it sends him careening out of bounds. But in GLB high attributes can be a negative, because Bort hasn't figured out how to make the dots assess how much of their abilities it is appropriate to use to succeed.


This may very well be true, but it doesn't make it a bug, more of the dreaded suggestion. And again, if this was a regular occurence even with your build and 8 FS's, it could likely be called a bug, but I don't think you'll see this that often and none at all once his Vision comes up to even 35-40.
 
tjsexkitten82
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
I think we need to remember the separation here. No real-life football players may do that, but no real life football players have the ability to add First Step. I don't mean to be glib either. I think it's a valid distinction that we're not talking about real life here. There have to be some penalties for having attributes at such a low level and one in this case is that he likely will miss some cuts like here or may run straight into a defender other times or something.


That's interesting. I always thought that the SAs were modeled after real football attributes. For example, First Step is supposed to give you great reaction times on the snap or high acceleration, just like some of the fastest guys in the NFL have. Superior Vision is supposed to give you great instincts like an Ed Reed. Monster Hit is supposed to help you hit like Polamalu. Not that these attributes are entirely outside of football, and First Step makes you faster than any NFL football player could ever be, etc. In fact, I'm almost certain Bort intended them to be as I described them.

I have no problem with low vision players missing cuts, or running into defenders instead of around them, cause that's what football players with low vision do IRL. I have a problem once they start doing ridiculous, non-football things like running in a straight line out of bounds. It's similar to the vision problem kick returners used to have (and still do? not sure) where they'd go out of bounds when a defender got within 10 yards just because they had "too much vision." It's not football-realistic and shouldn't be in GLB.
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
My personal opinion here - in GLB we can build dots that have attribute combinations that no actual human would have. This causes behavior that can't be mapped fairly onto human behavior. I think this is one of those cases.
I think "knowing your own turning limits when you're running at full speed" is something that would have to be tied to vision. A real kid in pee-wee isn't that fast, so he can turn to stay in bounds. But kids on ice skates go flying into the boards all the time even though they meant to make the turn...they just couldn't.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Ok, but what's the alternative? Your supremely fast player stops because the sideline is there but he can't make the cut? Then you've got a situation where the highest attribute is punished in favor of the lowest.

Also, the more I think about it, players irl at all levels of football get carried out of bounds by their momentum all the time. Think about a receiver running a deep out or flag at full speed, catching the ball and taking 3 steps before going out. Or even trying to tiptoe before going out. The idea that real life players are always able to make a cut and stay in bounds is disingenuous at best.
 
blaslo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by NiborRis
My personal opinion here - in GLB we can build dots that have attribute combinations that no actual human would have. This causes behavior that can't be mapped fairly onto human behavior. I think this is one of those cases.
I think "knowing your own turning limits when you're running at full speed" is something that would have to be tied to vision. A real kid in pee-wee isn't that fast, so he can turn to stay in bounds. But kids on ice skates go flying into the boards all the time even though they meant to make the turn...they just couldn't.


I think this sums it up great. We are in effect able to build "super human" players by pumping up attributes well beyond what any real athlete in the NFL would be able to achieve. And we're able to build up great disparities in attributes, effectively giving the same player superhuman speed but below average human vision/instincts..like, did anybody ever see the movie the adventures of Baron von Munchausen? There's the guy who can run superfast, but it takes him a great distance when he tries to stop.

It's either that we need to understand that the builds that go out towards the extreme, with extraordinarily high levels in one attribute, and below average levels in another are going to occasionally experience unusual behavior, or there is some kind of limit put on attributes to keep them within "human norms", which I don't imagine anybody would be happy with :-)
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by VolBrian
I think we need to remember the separation here. No real-life football players may do that, but no real life football players have the ability to add First Step. I don't mean to be glib either. I think it's a valid distinction that we're not talking about real life here. There have to be some penalties for having attributes at such a low level and one in this case is that he likely will miss some cuts like here or may run straight into a defender other times or something.

Also, who's to say he wasn't afraid of a possible hit by the chasing defender and ran out to avoid it? That happens at all levels of football as well.

I've got to head out, but y'all feel free to discuss the issue. If examples come up where WR's are doing this regularly and it can't be pinned to something like this then obviously we'll kick it up, but until then I simply think this is a one- (or very few) time occurrence where his low vision and extreme speed screwed him.


I saw a real life football player do just that yesterday on the NFL channel. He was rounding the corner and was trying to cut in to stay in bounds, but instead fell.

That Dot is real short on agility, especially for that speed. See it at all levels in the minors before Dots are rounded out.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dr. E
I saw a real life football player do just that yesterday on the NFL channel. He was rounding the corner and was trying to cut in to stay in bounds, but instead fell.


Yeah, I started thinking about it too and it's not all that an uncommon thing to see imo.

Originally posted by VolBrian

Also, the more I think about it, players irl at all levels of football get carried out of bounds by their momentum all the time. Think about a receiver running a deep out or flag at full speed, catching the ball and taking 3 steps before going out. Or even trying to tiptoe before going out. The idea that real life players are always able to make a cut and stay in bounds is disingenuous at best.


I'm gonna go ahead and change this to not likely a bug in light of all this discussion and only one replay thus far. If another mod sees it different, it will obviously move on to QA.
 
blaslo
offline
Link
 
going to agree at this point and say it's not a bug
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.