User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Lv 4 Minor Leagues > Lv 4 Minor League #6 > East Playoff Scenarios - after 15 games
Novus
offline
Link
 
As we approach the playoffs, subjective analysis gives way to cold, hard facts and figures to decide who makes it into the playoffs. Here's the deal.

Four key games will decide who ends up where:
Appleton vs. Chicago Lightning
Chicago FC vs. Western
Palm Bay vs. K-Town
Vulgar Display vs. Bridgeport

I'm assuming Long Beach and Lone Star will win their games, since they have gimmes for Game 16.

Here's how it breaks down, team-by-team:

Long Beach Golden Hurricanes
#1 no matter what happens.

Palm Bay Palookas
#2 no matter what happens.

Appleton Cardinals - {CLINCHED PLAYOFF SPOT}
If Appleton beats the Lightning, Appleton is #3.
If Appleton loses to the Lightning and Western upsets Chicago FC, Appleton is #4.
If Appleton loses to the Lightning and Chicago FC beats Western, Appleton is #5.

Chicago Lightning - {CLINCHED PLAYOFF SPOT}
If the Lightning upset Appleton, the Lightning is #3.
If the Lightning lose to Appleton and Vulgar beats Bridgeport, the Lightning is #4.
If the Lightning lose to Appleton, Bridgeport beats Vulgar, AND Western upsets Chicago FC, the Lightning is #5.
If the Lightning lose to Appleton, Bridgeport beats Vulgar, AND Chicago FC beats Western, the Lightning is #6.

Chicago Football Club - {CLINCHED PLAYOFF SPOT}
If Chicago FC beats Western and the Lightning upset Appleton, Chicago FC is #4.
If Chicago FC beats Western and Appleton beats the Lightning, Chicago FC is #5.
If Chicago FC gets upset by Western, they can still finish #5 if Palm Bay beats K-Town AND Vulgar beats Bridgeport.
If Chicago FC gets upset by Western, Palm Bay beats K-Town, AND Bridgeport beats Vulgar, Chicago FC is #6.
If Chicago FC gets upset by Western, K-Town upsets Palm Bay, AND Vulgar beats Bridgeport, Chicago FC is #7.
If Chicago FC gets upset by Western, K-Town upsets Palm Bay, AND Bridgeport beats Vulgar, Chicago FC is #8.

K-Town Ratatatacklers - {CLINCHED PLAYOFF SPOT}
K-Town's scenarios are all ridiculously complicated. To save my sanity, I'll summarize thusly:
If K-Town upsets Palm Bay, they could finish #5, #6 or #7, depending on how the other games go.
If K-Town loses to Palm Bay, they can only finish #6 or #7.

Lone Star Leopards - {CLINCHED PLAYOFF SPOT}
Lone Star is guaranteed to win, so their seed will depend entirely on how the other games go.
If Western upsets Chicago FC and Vulgar beats Bridgeport, Lone Star is #6.
In all other scenarios, Lone Star finishes #7 or #8, depending on how the other games go. Again, it gets ridiculously complicated from here on out, so I'll stop.

Bridgeport Bulldogs
If Bridgeport loses to Vulgar and K-Town upsets Palm Bay, Bridgeport is #9 and out of the playoffs.
In any other scenario, they're in, and they can finish as #8, #6, #5, or even #4. Alas, those scenarios all get ridiculously complicated as well, so I'll spare myself from going into those details.
Two rules of thumb, though... if Bridgeport beats Vulgar, they'll finish either #4, #5 or #6. And if Bridgeport loses to Vulgar, they're at #8 if Palm Bay beats K-Town or #9 if K-Town beats Palm Bay.

Vulgar Display of Power
If Bridgeport beats Vulgar, Vulgar is #9 and out of the playoffs.
If Vulgar beats Bridgeport and Palm Bay beats K-Town, Vulgar is still #9 and out of the playoffs.
Vulgar's ONLY hope is to beat Bridgeport and for K-Town to upset Palm Bay. That would put Vulgar at #8. In any other scenario, Vulgar finishes #9.
Edited by Novus on Aug 27, 2010 12:17:53
 
punkass
offline
Link
 
Awesome Novus. Love the analysis.
 
Borsdt
offline
Link
 
Thanks for the analysis

This has been one crazy division. The middle of the pack is so close, and it's ridiculous how important this last week is for everyone.....except the Hurricanes...
 
Mattarchy
offline
Link
 
come on Novus, take one for the team!!

our team, lol.

GO SEX ROBOT.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mattarchy
come on Novus, take one for the team!!

our team, lol.

GO SEX ROBOT.


"Not gonna do it... wouldn't be prudent."

Worth asking, though.
 
Apold
offline
Link
 
Well sorry but the Bulldogs are just not going to roll over either.
 
Apold
offline
Link
 
And I do have to say I love your analysis also.
 
TrendKill21
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Apold
Well sorry but the Bulldogs are just not going to roll over either.


Maybe they need a Vulgar Display of Dog Training
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1335082
Palm Bay 59, K-Town 7

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1335132
Chicago FC 63, Western 30

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1335142
Vulgar Display 66, Bridgeport 58

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1335187
Appleton 63, Chicago Lightning 54
Edited by Novus on Aug 28, 2010 15:03:36
Edited by Novus on Aug 28, 2010 15:00:17
 
aMaizenBlue
offline
Link
 
So, if two teams have the same record at the end of the season, the H2H matchup means nothing? They go by points allowed?
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by procster62
So, if two teams have the same record at the end of the season, the H2H matchup means nothing? They go by points allowed?


Here's how it goes...

The tie-breaker order is this:
1.) Record among the teams that are tied
2.) Points allowed
3.) Points scored

In 2-team ties, the first tie-breaker is basically just head-to-head: the team that won that game wins the tie-breaker. Of course, ties are allowed in the regular season, so it's still possible for points-allowed or points-scored to be needed as a tie-breaker in a 2-way tie, but that's pretty rare.

In 3-team or 4-team ties, it gets complicated. To illustrate, I'll go ahead and use the 4-team tie we have in the Eastern Conference right now, with Lone Star, K-Town, Bridgeport and Vulgar Display all tied with 10-6 records.

TIE-BREAKER #1 - Record among the teams that are tied
Lone Star - 2-1 (defeated Vulgar and Bridgeport, lost to K-Town)
K-Town - 2-1 (defeated Lone Star and Vulgar, lost to Bridgeport)
Bridgeport - 1-2 (defeated K-Town, lost to Lone Star and Vulgar)
Vulgar Display - 1-2 (defeated Bridgeport, lost to Lone Star and K-Town)

As you can see, Lone Star and K-Town have better head-to-head records than Bridgeport and Vulgar, so they are guaranteed to finish in the top-two spots no matter what happens next, and Bridgeport and Vulgar are guaranteed to finish in the bottow-two spots. However, the tie still isn't entirely broken, since Lone Star and K-Town are tied with each other, as are Bridgeport and Vulgar Display. So, we have to go to points-allowed next.

But here's where it gets weird... if this were the NFL, since the first tie-breaker eliminated Bridgeport and Vulgar, the NFL would now consider this to be a 2-way tie between just Lone Star and K-Town instead of a 4-way tie. The NFL would START OVER with the tie-breaker process at this point, which means going back to head-to-head... and since K-Town defeated Lone Star, K-Town would finish at the top, followed by Lone Star. Then they'd look at Bridgeport and Vulgar as a separate 2-way tie and decide that one by head-to-head as well, and since Vulgar defeated Bridgeport, Vulgar would also win the head-to-head tie-breaker. So, your final standings here would be, K-Town, Lone Star, Vulgar, Bridgeport.

But this isn't the NFL. THIS! IS! GLB!!! And GLB does things a little differently...

TIE-BREAKER #2 - Points allowed
The head-to-head tie-breaker broke up the 4-way tie into 2 2-way ties, but GLB doesn't follow the NFL's practice of "starting over." Instead, they continue forward and use the next tie-breaker to split up both of the 2-way ties. So, GLB compares the points-allowed for Lone Star and K-Town, and then compares the points-allowed for Bridgeport and Vulgar.

Lone Star - 711 points allowed
K-Town - 745 points allowed
Lone Star wins the tie-breaker

Bridgeport - 522 points allowed
Vulgar Display - 945 points allowed
Bridgeport wins the tie-breaker

Interesting thing to note here... Bridgeport actually had the best points-allowed of all 4 teams. But the 4-way head-to-head record tie-breaker already guaranteed that both K-Town and Lone Star would finish ahead of them.

So, here's how it shapes up:
Lone Star (2-1 record, 711 points allowed)
K-Town (2-1 record, 745 points allowed)
Bridgeport (1-2 record, 522 points allowed)
Vulgar Display (1-2 record, 945 points allowed)

...

Bort has confirmed in the past that this is how the tie-breakers work, including the specific and important point that GLB's tie-breakers don't follow the NFL's "start over" model. I'm too lazy to look up the quote, but I've read it before, that's my understanding of how it works, and that's how it seems to have played out here.

There's been a lot of debate over whether or not this is the "right" way to break ties, with the #9 team usually being the one doing the most complaining for obvious reasons. But I can understand the thinking behind both tie-breaking methods, so rather than side with one or the other, I'll just say this. If you don't like how ties are broken, then don't let your team end up in a tie in the standings. If your playoff chances rely on winning a 4-way tie on a super-complicated formula, then guess what, skippy: your team isn't very good and you'll probably lose in the first round anyway.

Oh, and have a good defense. Since points-allowed comes ahead of points-scored, that should give you an extra incentive to make sure that your defense is good. Those 14 points you let that CPU team score because you got lazy that day could just come back to bite you later.
 
Mad LBer 41
offline
Link
 

but who you callin Skippy,Skippy?
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
I can call you Betty, and Betty when you call me, you can call me Al.
 
aMaizenBlue
offline
Link
 
Thanks for the clarification. Thats kinda what I thought, I just really didn't want to play you guys again
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.