User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Out of Position Penalty not occurring? - NOT A BUG - CLOSED
mac112004
offline
Link
 
In our last game - The Throwback Cowboy's vs. The Brains Trust -

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=1312811

Our K - Oops Wideright was r QB for the entire game - his stat line was 95 total plays - 22/34 for 247 yards and 2 TD -0/1 FGM/FGA - 9 XPM/9 XPA

This was not a planned event - Lol, what happened was i removed the QB/HB/TE from the basic dc to see if i could just run the offense off the custom slots n my AI/play package settings. However, i forgot to identify what QB was to be in on a certain play in my AI/play packages, so apparently what happened was the sim chose Oops!.

One of the agents on our team mentioned that the out of position penalty should've had killed us and suggested i post the event here. I have to questions/concerns about what happened.

(1) we have 2 QB's on the roster y would the sim still chose the K as QB regardless of the AI/Play package oversite.

(2) The out of position penalty should have applied but to me and gauging from his overall performance it apparently did not.
Edited by Asdlfef on Aug 4, 2010 13:58:08 (I believe this is working as intended.)
Edited by VolBrian on Aug 3, 2010 19:32:34 (Reason in thread)
Edited by dmfa41 on Aug 2, 2010 19:18:39 (change title from "I don't if this is a bug or not")
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
offer sent

X-factor imo

Editing title to include idea.
 
kb2120
offline
Link
 
Possible that K OOP for QB hasn't been defined ( because who would put a K at QB ? ).
 
TheBear
Roll Tide
offline
Link
 
The lower levels got a buff to the passing game a while back. Try a DT or something at QB and see if what the results are. You might be onto something big.

Your post would be easier to read if you used "are" instead of "r"...and "why" instead of "y".
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheBear
The lower levels got a buff to the passing game a while back. Try a DT or something at QB and see if what the results are. You might be onto something big.

Your post would be easier to read if you used "are" instead of "r"...and "why" instead of "y".


I saw a WR at QB cap4 who was very successful and assumed it was due to the passing buff.
 
Alky
offline
Link
 
DOnt WRs and Kickers have similar stats, VIS, STR, CONF, except throwing you got yourself a little bit of a QB.
 
VolBrian
Rocky Top
offline
Link
 
Gotta say not likely a bug here. I know it's weird to have a kicker do well like that, but the game was a relative blowout that probably would have been much worse had a real QB been in. Plus, the YAC seem to indicate that most of the throws were short ones which he has a better chance of completing. I think what's in play here is a combination of what Alky and TheBear posted above.
 
Asdlfef
offline
Link
 
There are a few things to look at here:

The effective level between the two teams is 16-12, a difference of 4 levels at such a low level is fairly significant.

There is only 1 example of a game that was very one sided. In all likelihood the game would have been much higher scoring had a real QB been playing.

With this evidence I believe that the out of position penalty cannot be fairly assessed, but if I had to take a guess I would say that it was there.

If more instances of this do arise where any out of position player is significantly better than anticipated this could be something that may be worth looking into, but at this time I do not see any reason to explore this further.

I am calling this not a bug and closing.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.