User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Savitar
Ghost Recon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by eddryden
Interesting article on the draft:
http://www.nfl.com/draft/story?id=09000d5d817c513a&template=with-video-with-comments&confirm=true



 
eddryden
offline
Link
 
Since this season's forum is starting to grind to a halt (it happens), I thought I would introduce a random sports topic that could start some discussion.

Since we just finished the NFL draft and have had time to digest a bit, which rookie QB do you see making the greatest contribution to their team in their first year? Career?

The nominees are:

Sam Bradford - StL
Tim Tebow - Den
Jimmy Clausen - Car
Colt McCoy - Cle

 
eddryden
offline
Link
 
Or, if you rather, who was the greater draft day bust?
JaMarcus Russell or Ryan Leaf?
 
Spanky216
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by eddryden
Or, if you rather, who was the greater draft day bust?
JaMarcus Russell or Ryan Leaf?


any QB the Lions took!!
 
Spanky216
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by eddryden
Since this season's forum is starting to grind to a halt (it happens), I thought I would introduce a random sports topic that could start some discussion.

Since we just finished the NFL draft and have had time to digest a bit, which rookie QB do you see making the greatest contribution to their team in their first year? Career?

The nominees are:

Sam Bradford - StL
Tim Tebow - Den
Jimmy Clausen - Car
Colt McCoy - Cle



This really is an interesting question... I first can not believe Tim Tebow went so early... but to answer your poll... I think Jimmy is in a good spot... so career wise, I am going with Jimmy...
 
eddryden
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Spanky216

any QB the Lions took!!


Up until last year, Spanky. I LOVE Matthew Stafford's future.

 
Spanky216
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by eddryden
Up until last year, Spanky. I LOVE Matthew Stafford's future.



He needs to be able to survive the lack of an O-Line... but I do like his attitude and what I have seen... give this guy some time in the pocket, he can deliver a nice pass...
 
Savitar
Ghost Recon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by eddryden
Since this season's forum is starting to grind to a halt (it happens), I thought I would introduce a random sports topic that could start some discussion.

Since we just finished the NFL draft and have had time to digest a bit, which rookie QB do you see making the greatest contribution to their team in their first year? Career?

The nominees are:

Sam Bradford - StL
Tim Tebow - Den
Jimmy Clausen - Car
Colt McCoy - Cle



I too believe in Tebow.....like the Denver organization does. I think he'll outlast the others, and be a great QB when it's all said and done.
I think Clausen will be a bust. I think Bradford will be broken into a Ryan Lief. Marc Bulger was a very good QB, and the Rams neglected their offensive line....as a result Bulger couldn't handle the beatings he took. I think Bradford will be on the injured reserve list often.

McCoy has potential, but the Browns have a way of turning potential into failure. Under Holmgren tho, that might change.....therefore, I believe McCoy will have the second best career out of those 4.

With Tebow, the Broncos went with proven abilities to win. The kid has ungodly amounts of talent, and a willingness....even hard driven mentality to win.. He's the kind of QB I'd want my team to be lead by if I owned a team.
Edited by BadBuc99 on Apr 28, 2010 14:00:58
 
sarab
offline
Link
 
I think that Colt McCoy is going to have a great career at Cleveland...after the first season or two. Holmgren has a knack for making good QBs great. I hope that Tebow turns out to be better than Elway (I hated that guy...yea I said it) and makes everybody that said he would never make it look foolish.
 
eddryden
offline
Link
 
Bradford - Agree with Buc... but, more like David Carr, who got pummelled behind a HORRIBLE OL in Houston and now is a career back up.

Tebow - Sorry, I just don't see it. Good Cop - I like the guy. Gosh, what a great role model in today's times. Bad Cop - Gosh, what a goodie two shoes! Did this guy get pummelled growing up or what? Is that the reason why he is so thick right now... self protection? On the field, I will take the wait and see approach. I can't imagine the change in his mechanics are going to be 100% in year 1 or 2. Orton isn't great, but he is servicable. Quinn was HIGHER rated than Tebow coming out of college, but went to the wasteland Cleveland and was.... wasted. A lot of questions for me.

Clausen - He has GOT to be better than Delhomme. Right? If so, I think he has an OK career. He has a great OL, running game is awesome, Steve Smith is still one of the elite and the DEF is OK. Matt Moore isn't going to stand in his way if he is ready. He has the best opportunity to succeed right now and have a good career. The current offense they run holds back his GREAT potential.

McCoy - Agree with Sarab. Cleveland isn't the wasteland that it was a year ago. Holmgren is the MAN, when it comes to grooming QB. Montana, Young, Favre, Kitna, Hasselbeck... other than Favre, none of them have rocket arms, but ALL of them have had good seasons under Holmgren. Well, McCoy doesn't have a rocket arm either. McCoy is my pick.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.