User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > RESOLVED BUGS > DAI 42 (and 41) Defenses still use the 43 Linebacker positioning ranges - WILL NOT RESOLVE
fnordish
offline
Link
 
Basically even though I using a 42, my MLB can not get outside the weakside tackle. If I choose the 42 Weak base he is outside the invisible TE on the weakside, but as soon as I try to move him teleports to over the tackle and won't move outside the tackle. If I want to reposition him outside the invisible TE on the weakside I am forced to delete the play and start over and not move him at all at this point.

Edit - Fixing the worst lack of coffee grammer.
Edited by Catch22 on Feb 11, 2010 03:46:07
Edited by Catch22 on Feb 5, 2010 00:10:44
Edited by Catch22 on Feb 4, 2010 13:09:26
Edited by Catch22 on Feb 3, 2010 00:45:32
Edited by Guppy, Inc on Feb 2, 2010 03:38:47 (tagged for QA and moved)
 
Squab
offline
Link
 
Can you give us an example, like a play or screenshot?
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Confirmed.

In the Nickle Weak Defense the MLB is outside the RDE. If you try to move him, he teleports inside the RDE, and cannot be moved to the weak side.
 
fnordish
offline
Link
 
Cryptotich has it pretty much.

I picked the Nickle Defense and was trying to line the MB outside the Weak Side Offense Tackle off the line of scrimmage. I could not move the MB past the Weak Side Offense Tackle.

I then tried the Nickle Weak Defense for the base, the MB was about where I wanted him outside the Weak Side Offense Tackle, but too close to the line of scrimmage. When I tried to move him away from the line of scrimmage he teleported to directly over the Weak Side Offense Tackle and would not move outside him.
 
Thunder66
offline
Link
 
Same thing happening for me. Labeling as possible bug.
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
i dont mess with defenses, but enough people has voiced concerns that I moved this so that that QA will look at it.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
I'd like to see screenshots or examples before filing this as a bug - moving back to Bugs Forum with NEEDS MORE INFO
 
Thunder66
offline
Link
 
It's not doing it anymore (I tried it before and you could drag the MLB to a certain point past the LT and he'd teleport back inside), however its not doing that anymore, now you simply can't drag it past a set point [head up over the LT is the farthest it will let you go, but this time it stays at that point rather then resetting/jumping back like the OP mentioned].

So the teleporting bit has been resolved [not sure by who or why?].
Edited by Thunder66 on Feb 3, 2010 01:23:18
 
fnordish
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Catch22
I'd like to see screenshots or examples before filing this as a bug - moving back to Bugs Forum with NEEDS MORE INFO


This is an always happens, easy to recreate issue, this shouldn't require this level of investigation. This is being overkill what good do 2 screen shots of the MLB in 2 different positions do for this? The reproduction is easily repeatable(happens on both Firefox and IE - versions are available if you really can't repro this).
-Start a new DPC play
-Select the formation 'Nickle Weak'
- Select 'Custom drag and drop' for his position, and line him up anywhere the 3 predefined positions do(IE anywhere outside the weak side tackle)

I will go off the rails and make an assumption at this point, to deal with the overloading issue, positions got bounding boxes, there seems to only be one set of bound numbers for the positions though, and it breaks down when the defensive formation isn't a 4-3 one.

There are problems all over the place with how the DAI set the bounding boxes per position.
-In any defense with a middle linebacker he can not be positioned outside the LOT or ROT - this is understandable in the defenses where there is another linebacker on that side, the previous workaround for overloading shouldn't limit him when there is no other linebacker option though.

-In all the 3 down linemen defenses the nose tackle can't be moved to the weak side of the formation(He stops heads up on the center and will move no further) and the Right End can't move past the gap to the outside of the Weak side G. This means I can't position any down linemen in the weak side center gap yet I can stick the NT in the strong side gap. - This one is slightly more understandable but honestly if there is no DT on the play why can't I line the NT up in the gap to the weak side of the center but I can line him up on the strong side.

Edit1 - some grammer fixes.
Edit2- updated the repro case to be more streamlined.
Edited by fnordish on Feb 3, 2010 15:07:17
Edited by fnordish on Feb 3, 2010 15:04:07
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Take a look at the initial placement of the MLB in the Nickel Weak DPC

If you attempt to move the MLB, he teleports to this position:
http://i47.tinypic.com/fdtzs4.jpg

And can no longer be moved back to his origional starting point.

I r draw gud.
Edited by Cryptotich on Feb 4, 2010 05:05:56
Edited by Cryptotich on Feb 4, 2010 05:04:03
Edited by Cryptotich on Feb 4, 2010 05:03:47
Edited by Cryptotich on Feb 4, 2010 05:02:45
Edited by Cryptotich on Feb 4, 2010 05:02:16
 
Thunder66
offline
Link
 
Strange its back (was buggy first time I tried, fine the second now its back???).

http://i46.tinypic.com/xmsvo7.jpg Start/Base nickle (before you touch anything)

http://i49.tinypic.com/5vvvo8.jpg once you click on the MLB he teleports to this position

http://i50.tinypic.com/okwf4n.jpg then after the MLB teleports this is the furthest you can now move him to the weak side (left),

 
fnordish
offline
Link
 
Thank you for the screen posts.

This flipped all my flags for using process as a roadblock to QA/Dev instead of process as a streamliner for QA/Dev. So I apologize for going off a bit there.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
fwiw fnordish if you would have said the following in your first post it would have been much easier for me to replicate:

This is an always happens, easy to recreate issue, this shouldn't require this level of investigation. This is being overkill what good do 2 screen shots of the MLB in 2 different positions do for this? The reproduction is easily repeatable(happens on both Firefox and IE - versions are available if you really can't repro this).
-Start a new DPC play
-Select the formation 'Nickle Weak'
- Select 'Custom drag and drop' for his position, and line him up anywhere the 3 predefined positions do(IE anywhere outside the weak side tackle)

Your OP wasn't clear enough and none of the following posts contained enough information for me to be able to understand exactly what I was supposed to be looking for which is why I asked for screenshots.

I'll move this to NEEDS TO BE FILED.
 
Catch22
offline
Link
 
Per Bort:

This is somewhat intended behavior. The default alignment of players is ok, as
it's what is used in the basic playbook. However, custom alignment has
stricter boundaries. If the user wants have the MLB back on the outside, he
just needs to deselect "Custom position."

Allowing special case alignment bounds per formation would be possible, but
would require quite a bit of deciding what all those bounds should be.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.