User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America AAA Leagues > South America AAA #2 > So I'm building my own power ranking system for the league.....
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
...and had a question for the general populace.

What do you define as a blowout?

Yes, I know, the sim says 100+, I don't care about the sim. What do you consider to be a completely lopsided affair? 40 points? 50? Over 9000?
 
jlrock
offline
Link
 
say 63?
 
hee163
offline
Link
 
I think blowout is a bit general and pretty complicated- there's about 3 different levels

the 255-0 waste of time cpu type
the 100-130 type - where the team could never beat you even if their gameplan was great and yours was terrible.
the 50-100 type - where if the other team got their tactics right and you really messed up they'd run you close.

problem is, there'll be 2 teams you stuff 255-0, but one of those will beat the other 255-0.

Maybe a blowout should be a game you couldn't lose if you tried to? Loads of different ways of thinking about it tbh.
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hee163
I think blowout is a bit general and pretty complicated- there's about 3 different levels

the 255-0 waste of time cpu type
the 100-130 type - where the team could never beat you even if their gameplan was great and yours was terrible.
the 50-100 type - where if the other team got their tactics right and you really messed up they'd run you close.

problem is, there'll be 2 teams you stuff 255-0, but one of those will beat the other 255-0.

Maybe a blowout should be a game you couldn't lose if you tried to? Loads of different ways of thinking about it tbh.


While this is a great thought compilation, I'm dealing with an Excel script, and that's just too many IF statements.

That said, you seem to be saying that a base minimum on a blowout would be around 50?
Edited by griffin8r on Dec 20, 2009 06:45:02
 
Stu618
offline
Link
 
I like 63-70. That basically means if the winning team did everything within a normal game plan wrong, and the other team did everything in a normal game plan right, the winning team would still have the edge based on talent
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
I kinda like that number, because it makes it easier for me to minimize the benefit for beating up on a sorry opponent.

(edit)

I should say it makes for a smoother dropoff, because the way my formula is set up, you get squadoosh for beating a 0-win opponent.
Edited by griffin8r on Dec 20, 2009 11:07:25
Edited by griffin8r on Dec 20, 2009 10:44:54
 
Mynno
offline
Link
 
Just curious as to how you plan on figuring a teams power ranking when they lose. The above posters have given numbers for a blowout but what if your team is vastly overleveled yet you still manage to get a TD or two. Even though you lose in a blowout by the numbers you should not have even scored so that should play a big part in power rankings. I hope I expressed the idea properly.
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mynno
Just curious as to how you plan on figuring a teams power ranking when they lose. The above posters have given numbers for a blowout but what if your team is vastly overleveled yet you still manage to get a TD or two. Even though you lose in a blowout by the numbers you should not have even scored so that should play a big part in power rankings. I hope I expressed the idea properly.


The way the system is designed, the better your opponent's record is, the less damage the loss does to your rank, in an exponential fashion.
 
hee163
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by griffin8r
The way the system is designed, the better your opponent's record is, the less damage the loss does to your rank, in an exponential fashion.


Are you putting some kind of scale on blowouts, so that say +63 is where you start to lose a small amount of credit for the win and at +255, it barely makes any difference to your ranking at all?

Something like

Blowout adjustment = (Ranking points for win).Z

A linear Z would be like this
Blowout size... Z = (Score difference - 63)/(255-63)
 
griffin8r
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hee163
Are you putting some kind of scale on blowouts, so that say +63 is where you start to lose a small amount of credit for the win and at +255, it barely makes any difference to your ranking at all?

Something like

Blowout adjustment = (Ranking points for win).Z

A linear Z would be like this
Blowout size... Z = (Score difference - 63)/(255-63)


Actually, the scale is based on W/L record, with a hard cap (IF Score diff > 63, MoV = 63).

The actual points formula looks like this:

IF (W=True, SoV=MoV*(OppW^2)/(OppL^2), ELSE SoV=MoV/(OppW^2)*(OppL^2))

Why the squaring? Because beating a 15 win team by 1 should be worth significantly more than beating a 1 win team by 255.

And yes, with this formula, it is possible to lose no points by losing to an undefeated team and win no points by beating a winless team - however, your power score is adjusted downward by your total losses (Score=Raw/(L+1)), so a 4-1 will probably never outrank a 5-0, unless the 5-0 beat nothing but crappy teams.
Edited by griffin8r on Dec 21, 2009 07:54:50
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.