User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
shull
offline
Link
 
Why MUST you have at least one play saved in each section of the offensive playbook? The Sim is f'd up enough to randomly pick plays I never call for in my AI, so why can't I ensure a section of plays will never be called by the Sim?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715678&pbp_id=3519795

You cannot save the playbook without an inside QB run or outside QB run somewhere in the playbook. This is stupid.


 
Captain Kaos
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shull
Why MUST you have at least one play saved in each section of the offensive playbook? The Sim is f'd up enough to randomly pick plays I never call for in my AI, so why can't I ensure a section of plays will never be called by the Sim?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715678&pbp_id=3519795

You cannot save the playbook without an inside QB run or outside QB run somewhere in the playbook. This is stupid.




Just set your AI up so the QB has no chance of running with the ball.
 
Mr Sinister
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by cwisler
Originally posted by shull

Why MUST you have at least one play saved in each section of the offensive playbook? The Sim is f'd up enough to randomly pick plays I never call for in my AI, so why can't I ensure a section of plays will never be called by the Sim?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715678&pbp_id=3519795

You cannot save the playbook without an inside QB run or outside QB run somewhere in the playbook. This is stupid.




Just set your AI up so the QB has no chance of running with the ball.


Also don't put in run random, because if you do, you will have a good chance of a QB run being called.
 
shull
offline
Link
 
Neither of those are applicable, as I don't have a random run in there...everything is assigned, and the AI is set so the QB has no chance of running the ball.
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Switch to a purely packaged based offense, and don't put QB runs in your packages?

Beg Woods to stop them more often?
 
tragula
title
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shull
Why MUST you have at least one play saved in each section of the offensive playbook? The Sim is f'd up enough to randomly pick plays I never call for in my AI, so why can't I ensure a section of plays will never be called by the Sim?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=715678&pbp_id=3519795

You cannot save the playbook without an inside QB run or outside QB run somewhere in the playbook. This is stupid.




This is a "stupid proof" mechanism. When you call a non-existing play like "shotgun FB Inside run left" the sim need to run something. Instead of just running a random play, it will look for the most similar play if the book. Since you have to have a FB inside run, you are guaranteed that your in the worst case scenario you will still get a "inside FB run".
Good programmers always tries to anticipate what the user errors will be, and try to minimize damages.

You may also want to note, that this doesn't work with specific play choice/ packages. If you call a play which is not in the playbook the sim has no play definition to stick too and the result will be completely random.

And I usual 99% of "I never called that play" are user errors. If that call happened twice in a game it is 99.9999% user error. I think many OCs/DCs claim that at least once they got a play that "could not been called". But without repeating problem and some common features there is no much progress in finding the source of that (if it is actually a real bug)

by the way: no bug here
 
bigr925
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shull
Neither of those are applicable, as I don't have a random run in there...everything is assigned, and the AI is set so the QB has no chance of running the ball.


There is no bug...you are not assigning the runner in your AI. Put RB or FB and not random in...random will revert back to basic AI.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigr925
Originally posted by shull

Neither of those are applicable, as I don't have a random run in there...everything is assigned, and the AI is set so the QB has no chance of running the ball.


There is no bug...you are not assigning the runner in your AI. Put RB or FB and not random in...random will revert back to basic AI.


Random works just fine, if you have your basic tactics set properly. I use it sometimes myself, when I've got a rushing FB available.
 
shull
offline
Link
 
Basic Tactics = 0% QB run
AI - Second down scenarios - every play was assigned to some player that was not the QB.

I understand the "shotgun fullback inside" will revert to something similar, and see how it's beneficial for "stupid proofing".

However, I'm wondering why you cannot remove categories of plays entirely from the playbook. So in the case a user error occurs, I want the sim to pick an acceptable play from the playbook, and want it to never have the option of choosing a QB run. Whether it's user error or not, you should be able to fail proof against running categories of plays.
 
shull
offline
Link
 
My argument isn't that the AI is buggy, but I don't understand why you cannot save a playbook unless there is at least one play in each category. In my case, I want to never select a QB run. But you absolutely must have at least one QB inside and one QB outside run in the playbook.
 
InRomoWeTrust
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shull
My argument isn't that the AI is buggy, but I don't understand why you cannot save a playbook unless there is at least one play in each category. In my case, I want to never select a QB run. But you absolutely must have at least one QB inside and one QB outside run in the playbook.


So why is this in the Bugs section of the forums

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread_list.pl?forum_id=2 - Suggestions
 
shull
offline
Link
 
touche.

I still think the thing is buggy.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.