User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Ts-Rock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by neoliminal
1. the MVP formula isn't perfect and probably never will be.
2. we don't know what it's based on, but maybe level/fame/other factor put Barry on top.
3. Barry won it, regardless of what the formula was.
4. give Bort something to work with if you think there's a better system. (you've clearly got the data to make something good.)
5. submit it to Cryptotich who is not a BUG MOD and who is also on our team ;-)


I don't know what it takes to come up with the MVP formula. I love the idea of having an MVP. I think it adds more depth to this game which I love. I just wish we knew what it takes into account. some else posted (in another thread) that maybe the MVP should only take the stats from the playoff teams. That way you have stats only from 7 games, but it is vs the top 7 teams in the league. IDK if that is any better, but I don't think it is fair to punish players (not counting stats in games over 60 pts) who play the same competition and put up better numbers. to me that is saying your team is to good to be considered MVP worthy. IF this is the way it is scored then it is flawed and It shouldn't be called the MVP.

Anyway, I apologize for starting a flame post, not my intentions. I was just upset at the way the MVP is calculated (which no one knows) and wanted to get some banter back and forth.
 
ecrana
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ts-Rock
some else posted (in another thread) that maybe the MVP should only take the stats from the playoff teams. That way you have stats only from 7 games, but it is vs the top 7 teams in the league.


This is almost a good idea if not for the fact that it is skewed towards the 2 teams that make it to the championship game and have more chances to rack up more stats. It's a little unfair if you have a back that leads the league in rushing by let's say 1,000 yards and 20 TDs (let's just say it was all against good teams and no CPUs) but his team only gets to the first round of playoffs before elimination. Then you end up punishing him for being the best player on a team that couldn't make it all the way.

MVP formula definitely sucks but I don't think the answer is to start picking and choosing what games should be in the formula. That just leads to more problems. What if you play a team in week 1 that was CPU and put up 1,000 yards. Then I play them in week 16 and they've got new ownership and have somehow put together a decent team and I rack up 300 yards still. Does that mean neither game would count towards MVP since it was CPU at the beginning of the season? Do I get credit for the 300 yards but you get no credit for the 1,000 yards? Some teams keep adding pieces throughout the season so it's easy to say in week 1 it was easier to rack up yardage against them then it was in week 15. I know we were still adding players as late as weeks 8-10.

Hopefully they figure something better out but until then all you can do is bitch about how it sucks and realize that we all agree it sucks.
 
djshutout
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ecrana
Originally posted by Ts-Rock

some else posted (in another thread) that maybe the MVP should only take the stats from the playoff teams. That way you have stats only from 7 games, but it is vs the top 7 teams in the league.


This is almost a good idea if not for the fact that it is skewed towards the 2 teams that make it to the championship game and have more chances to rack up more stats. It's a little unfair if you have a back that leads the league in rushing by let's say 1,000 yards and 20 TDs (let's just say it was all against good teams and no CPUs) but his team only gets to the first round of playoffs before elimination. Then you end up punishing him for being the best player on a team that couldn't make it all the way.

MVP formula definitely sucks but I don't think the answer is to start picking and choosing what games should be in the formula. That just leads to more problems. What if you play a team in week 1 that was CPU and put up 1,000 yards. Then I play them in week 16 and they've got new ownership and have somehow put together a decent team and I rack up 300 yards still. Does that mean neither game would count towards MVP since it was CPU at the beginning of the season? Do I get credit for the 300 yards but you get no credit for the 1,000 yards? Some teams keep adding pieces throughout the season so it's easy to say in week 1 it was easier to rack up yardage against them then it was in week 15. I know we were still adding players as late as weeks 8-10.

Hopefully they figure something better out but until then all you can do is bitch about how it sucks and realize that we all agree it sucks.


Well said! +1
 
neoliminal
offline
Link
 
I think what TS is saying is that if you only take that stats for games against the top 8 teams during the season, then the stats might mean more. That would eliminate the bias of playing a CPU team early or late in the season. So imagine that the final MVP score was based on how well a player did in 8 games instead of 16, with those 8 games being the top 8 teams (not including yours).

It's an interesting formula and would also change as the season went on as one team started to rise or fall... so would some players MVP chances.

You should definitely suggest it.
 
Cryptotich
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by neoliminal

5. submit it to Cryptotich who is not a BUG MOD and who is also on our team ;-)


Quit making my life harder!

But for what its worth, the topic is already under discussion for an off season change.

 
Ts-Rock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by neoliminal
I think what TS is saying is that if you only take that stats for games against the top 8 teams during the season, then the stats might mean more. That would eliminate the bias of playing a CPU team early or late in the season. So imagine that the final MVP score was based on how well a player did in 8 games instead of 16, with those 8 games being the top 8 teams (not including yours).

It's an interesting formula and would also change as the season went on as one team started to rise or fall... so would some players MVP chances.

You should definitely suggest it.


ecrana this is what I was talking about not stats in the playoffs.....sorry I worded it wrong or weird
 
ecrana
offline
Link
 
My fault. I only get on here at work mostly so I must have read it too quickly. I don't know what the hell I thought I read now but I got your point and it's definitely better than what we have going right now.

The flip side to the argument is if you're in a league where there are no CPU teams. Then it doesn't really matter if you use all 16 games. But that's rare nowadays and either way the top 8 teams idea seems more efficient.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.