User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
fishdan
offline
Link
 
Hey -- guys please do NOT think I am offended at all -- you guys SHOULD take umbrage with what I said, and you did make me eat my hat. I'm TOTALLY cool with us disagreeing on this -- even disagreeing strongly.

My punt count:

4th & 12.5 OPP 20.5
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=594757&pbp_id=13824458


4th & 3.5 OPP 37
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=594757&pbp_id=13826993

Same drive
0:18 1st & 10 OPP 27 -- we don't kick the FG because of range, but I think most people would kick here with 18 seconds left

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=594757&pbp_id=13827109

10:58 4th & 11.5 OPP 30
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=594757&pbp_id=13827991

I can see counting the same drive ones as just one, so then it would indeed be 3.

I think SOME forced fumbles are luck -- and I say that as a DC with a defense that has forced 46 fumbles this year.

Prior to the Ujung game, you had forced 20 fumbles in 12 games. You might not think there is luck involved in getting 6 fumbles against us, but it certainly is a statistical anomlay.

Here's hoping for a playoff rematch!!
 
43Hitman
offline
Link
 
Sounds like sour grapes tbh...
 
Flintmode
offline
Link
 
The forced fumble thing can at least be explained better than recovered fumbles.. I mean, you have to agree, right?? I guess what i'm trying to say is this.. Good defensive players have some of these qualities..

With the VA's designed to force fumbles such as power tackler, helmet crash ect. and then you must factor in a players strength, tackling and if they have monster hit stacked out or not.. I think it's much more likely that a player is designed to make fumbles happen..

Now with all of these things combined wouldn't it make for a few fumbles waiting to be forced?? Say he hits the ball carrier a few times, lowering his morale (assuming he's using helmet crash) and then lays a monster hit or 2 on the same ball carrier (assuming he has monster hit stacked) and pow, i'd say that ups the chance of causing a fumble even with just a few of the above mentioned things mixed in.. I understand that it may be some luck but, i think that it's 100 times more planned and earned than a player recovering a fumble.. That's all about being in the right place at the right time, maybe speed and agility play into getting to the ball, perhaps vision..

I agree with you 100% that 6 fumbles is alot but, i can say that the players on our team who caused those fumbles are guys who are built to cause fumbles.. We're gonna have a couple games each season where we gain an edge by forcing alot of TO's.. Not to say that we're the fucking greatest or anything, just stating that we have the potential to take the ball away on defense (as do alot of teams) and every once in awhile it's gonna happen..
 
skinzfan08
offline
Link
 
Yeah, the sim itself is kind of a crap shoot to begin with. We're all building players who makes play based on percentages, rolls, and some factors that are controllable. 6 fumbles in a game is not out of the realm of possibility for any team. 20 fumbles forced is still a respectable number, but nowhere near what some other teams are forcing. But, to reiterate, 6 fumbles is not a huge stretch, based on our players' builds, etc...I'm sure, fishdan, it's just frustrating that it happens against you. We had the same thing happen in our playoff game last year. We fumbled less than 15 times on the whole season, and had 4 or 5 in the same game...and they cost us the game. It's frustrating, I understand that completely. It was a good game, and I look forward to our next match up.
 
mosesp33
offline
Link
 
Like I said, probably 6 but no more than 10 pts. But noone really knows because so many other subsequent variables would have changed. But it must suck to think that a game was lost that should have been won simply because of an AI screwup after all that time and gameplanning(and I write this sincerely not sarcastically-it's ahppenned to us before and it really does suck).

But the game would have been close either way.

"I think SOME forced fumbles are luck -- and I say that as a DC with a defense that has forced 46 fumbles this year. Prior to the Ujung game, you had forced 20 fumbles in 12 games. You might not think there is luck involved in getting 6 fumbles against us, but it certainly is a statistical anomlay."

Certainly you would agree that a change in defensive tactics could account for this statistical anomaly?

I'm not saying there isn't any luck involved, but as a DC you know very well that tackling tactics can be changed to create fumbles. And you also know there are around 1/2 dozen VA's that can influence them. And 3-4 SA's. And at least 4 build attributes on both sides of the ball.

And I say that as a GM for a team that has had couple of heartbreaking losses because of fumbles lost over the past couple of seasons.

On the flip side, let's look at factors that can be controlled with regard to recovering fumbles..............(cue the crickets, lol).

Looking at running plays exclusively, it looks like on average 50-60% of fumbles end up being lost.

When you guys beat Bali 28-6, was that a statistical anomaly? Because that was the only time they gave up that many points all season.

Dan, please don't be discouraged from calling the games as you see them because it's a tough job and I think you're generally very objective and honest and remarkably good at it. But more importantly your time and effort makes things a lot more fun for myself and a lot of others. And noone would be here if it wasn't fun.

But to suggest that this game should not have been close after it's already been played on the cyber field...well that's a different story.
 
43Hitman
offline
Link
 
Those last two posts were way better than mine tbh... Great stuff guys, I am only trying to keep it light.
 
Sahoj
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Flintmode
Yes it was a heck of a game but, even with the FG thing being set wrong i still can't understand how we were yet again predicted to lose by +3 TD's in a game where the outcome was less than a FG..


It's how predictions work! Believe it or not, predictions are not always accurate or fishdan would be a very
rich man and I would surely take him to Vegas.

Good game fellas!

Cheers,
Sahoj
 
fishdan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sahoj
[... predictions are not always accurate or fishdan would be a very
rich man and I would surely take him to Vegas.

Good game fellas!

Cheers,
Sahoj


Dude, I live in vegas and am a billionaire off of football wagering. I am actually Dan Snyder

That's a joke btw -- if I were Dan Snyder, I would have killed myself by now.

I second Sahoj's good game, and I have enjoyed our spirited discussion. NOW I feel like I'm carrying the forums if I can inspire positive chat like this. Let's keep it up.

The Bali game is a good question. I think we matched up well against running teams. Ever since the Mekong/Bacolod debacles I've been very actively trying to roll back our run defense and focus more on stopping the pass. I feel pretty confident I don't have the balance right yet

 
valakar
offline
Link
 
I predict 8 teams from the Naga conference will win tomorrow. Yes I know I am going out on a limb because we could have a tie but still going to stick to my predictions! That is all.
 
Flintmode
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fishdan
Originally posted by Sahoj

[... predictions are not always accurate or fishdan would be a very
rich man and I would surely take him to Vegas.

Good game fellas!

Cheers,
Sahoj


Dude, I live in vegas and am a billionaire off of football wagering. I am actually Dan Snyder

That's a joke btw -- if I were Dan Snyder, I would have killed myself by now.

I second Sahoj's good game, and I have enjoyed our spirited discussion. NOW I feel like I'm carrying the forums if I can inspire positive chat like this. Let's keep it up.

The Bali game is a good question. I think we matched up well against running teams. Ever since the Mekong/Bacolod debacles I've been very actively trying to roll back our run defense and focus more on stopping the pass. I feel pretty confident I don't have the balance right yet



I agree, nothing wrong with spirited debate.. Most the time when i've voiced my opinion or dislike in a league forum i get a few girls who always seem to take it the wrong way.. This was fun and an active forum is great.. I do enjoy your reads Fishdan, and i hope to see many more! I DO understand as Sahoj said that your not always goin to be spot-on with your predictions, and as i said, it was more a build up from two times of being a severe underdog when the games were very close.. Both times weren't from your predictions either, once was Flounder.. I'm sure you also understand that being the guy who makes the predictions is goin to put you under fire from agents here and there and i'm sure your perfectly ok with that, or else i doubt you'd still be doin it.. I want to echo again, great game, i look forward to more in the future and keep up the great reads!!

 
43Hitman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Flintmode
Originally posted by fishdan

Originally posted by Sahoj


[... predictions are not always accurate or fishdan would be a very
rich man and I would surely take him to Vegas.

Good game fellas!

Cheers,
Sahoj


Dude, I live in vegas and am a billionaire off of football wagering. I am actually Dan Snyder

That's a joke btw -- if I were Dan Snyder, I would have killed myself by now.

I second Sahoj's good game, and I have enjoyed our spirited discussion. NOW I feel like I'm carrying the forums if I can inspire positive chat like this. Let's keep it up.

The Bali game is a good question. I think we matched up well against running teams. Ever since the Mekong/Bacolod debacles I've been very actively trying to roll back our run defense and focus more on stopping the pass. I feel pretty confident I don't have the balance right yet



I agree, nothing wrong with spirited debate.. Most the time when i've voiced my opinion or dislike in a league forum i get a few girls who always seem to take it the wrong way.. This was fun and an active forum is great.. I do enjoy your reads Fishdan, and i hope to see many more! I DO understand as Sahoj said that your not always goin to be spot-on with your predictions, and as i said, it was more a build up from two times of being a severe underdog when the games were very close.. Both times weren't from your predictions either, once was Flounder.. I'm sure you also understand that being the guy who makes the predictions is goin to put you under fire from agents here and there and i'm sure your perfectly ok with that, or else i doubt you'd still be doin it.. I want to echo again, great game, i look forward to more in the future and keep up the great reads!!



I think you just pissed in his boots..
 
skinzfan08
offline
Link
 
I'll piss in peoples' boots! lol
 
mosesp33
offline
Link
 
Now c'mon Dan, the Bali remark was meant to be sarcastic. You guys won that game because of a great gameplan tactics and builds.
 
ScullyDawg
offline
Link
 
Um....can everyone stop talking about Bali losing dammit?
 
Flintmode
offline
Link
 
If this doesn't put a smile on your face i don't know what will!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tm2Jy64b0dI
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.