Originally posted by notgoing2argue
Originally posted by ytwins
Originally posted by austin8214
LOL the USA has a full team of D-1 commits playing a bunch of foreign countries that hardly know what American football is.
No, that not the case only country that is fairly young to playing football is New Zealand, and it shows; they still pitch the ball like they are playing rugby, and overall are not that big. Japan has been playing football since the 1930's. IMO Japan has the best QB there. Also several players playing football at US colleges/universities.
I lived in Japan for 3 years. As a country they know less about football than we do soccer. I'd be surprised if there is even 100,000 people in that whole country who have ever even touched a football, let alone thrown one. My elementary school had one at the bottom of its ball basket, but nobody ever touched it, haha. I don't doubt the QB on their team looks good though. He probably lived near a US base, or did study abroad here and got into it. There was a teacher at my JHS who played some football in college, and I think he was on some adult league team in Nagasaki. He had a helmet in his car and everything. The funny thing is he never even asked to play catch with me once, even when I broke out a nerf ball to teach a few JHS kids how to throw. He was a 5 foot 4 lineman. So that should tell you all you need to know about the quality of play in Japan.
One of the reasons Japan might produce a good QB is because if there is one thing Japanese people will do, it is robotically practice the fuck out of something 3X longer than we ever will. That alone would probably produce a good low-level thrower. However, if that QB has never lived abroad and learned the game in Japan, I would feel safe saying he won't amount to much playing in a US program.
I'd also wager taht one of the reasons he probably looks so good to you is they practiced those routes 3 hours a day, 6 to 7 days a week since they joined the team. They don't mess around during their club activities like we do. In fact, there is very little play in anything they do. It is an exercise they practice, but they don't explore and try out something new like we do. It's pretty horrible to witness (more than a few times), and even worse to participate in one of their practices regularly. It is so monotonous and bloodless you just don't even feel like you are playing a sport. Basically, athletes in Japan are not very dynamic due to the way their culture is. Their school system beats all the originality and spontanaeity from them by the time they are 3rd graders. I taought 1st grade elementary through 12th grade HS, so I've seen it first hand.
He's young. You don't learn the game here when you are young. It's 90-95% athletic ability in high school football. The coaches do the thinking, the players just play. That's why the same schools are so good year after year. As long as you have a pool of athletes, a good coach can win with them in high school. But D-1 college ball is more than just speed and strength.
So that said, if anything, if this kid's tools are as good as ytwins said, I think it gives him an advantage. Throwing mechanics, game breakdown, reading defenses, etc. can be taught. And his limited experience playing here helps him because he doesn't develop bad habits. It sounds like he has work ethic too. Something you cannot teach, but is an invaluable tool for a player willing to put the work in and learn.