User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
ColaCock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MadcatWillie

Anyway, I'm no expert, but training all the way to 48 seems counter-productive in the long term. Remember, all that is guess work, I'm not going to run the numbers on training percentages because I'm lazy and I don't like math.


That kind of confused me haha

Again, I don't claim to be an expert either...but think about this:

- if your team was under the impression that they didn't feel they would seriously be competitive for 3-4 seasons, why not stockpile Skill Points THE WHOLE WAY and just gain on Attributes from training?

- for example, a OT at LVL 4 could have Blocking around 25 (30 with EQ) and Strength around 22...but have 30 Skill Points built up. the training % value is still around 32-35% for Strength or Blocking....so every 6 training points or so, you add another whole point to the attribute.

however, if you hit LVL 4 with the same scenario (Strength 22 and Blocking 25) you could use those 30 points to take either to the softcap of 48 and have around 6-8 Skill Points left. BUT, you will only be getting 12% each time you normal train for that attribute...taking about 8 training days to gain one point instead of 3. it seems like you could end up taking advantage of this for a LONG time by stockpiling Skill Points and just training...you are cutting your training % gain in more than half (from 30-35% to 10-12%) by hitting that softcap so fast.

so...it seems like if you did NOTHING but train and save SP until around LVL 15 or so, you would have one attribute damn near soft cap and like 85 SP to use...on capping TWO attributes...maybe THREE if you only needed 25-30 per extra attribute.

what am I missing here- seems like i am missing something along the way? am I wrong in this thinking?

Edited by ColaCock on Jun 29, 2009 17:17:58
 
Loonzilla
WAR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ColaCock
Originally posted by MadcatWillie


Anyway, I'm no expert, but training all the way to 48 seems counter-productive in the long term. Remember, all that is guess work, I'm not going to run the numbers on training percentages because I'm lazy and I don't like math.


That kind of confused me haha

Again, I don't claim to be an expert either...but think about this:

- if your team was under the impression that they didn't feel they would seriously be competitive for 3-4 seasons, why not stockpile Skill Points THE WHOLE WAY and just gain on Attributes from training?

- for example, a OT at LVL 4 could have Blocking around 25 (30 with EQ) and Strength around 22...but have 30 Skill Points built up. the training % value is still around 32-35% for Strength or Blocking....so every 6 training points or so, you add another whole point to the attribute.

however, if you hit LVL 4 with the same scenario (Strength 22 and Blocking 25) you could use those 30 points to take either to the softcap of 48 and have around 6-8 Skill Points left. BUT, you will only be getting 12% each time you normal train for that attribute...taking about 8 training days to gain one point instead of 3. it seems like you could end up taking advantage of this for a LONG time by stockpiling Skill Points and just training...you are cutting your training % gain in more than half (from 30-35% to 10-12%) by hitting that softcap so fast.

so...it seems like if you did NOTHING but train and save SP until around LVL 15 or so, you would have one attribute damn near soft cap and like 85 SP to use...on capping TWO attributes...maybe THREE if you only needed 25-30 per extra attribute.

what am I missing here- seems like i am missing something along the way? am I wrong in this thinking?



The natural progression that is just awarded to your player is a multiplier of your current attributes, if you do not assign SP the multiplier hits at a lower rate. So you lose a percentage of your natural progression..

Thats what the people say on the GLB main forum anyway.
 
ColaCock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Loonzilla
Originally posted by ColaCock

Originally posted by MadcatWillie



Anyway, I'm no expert, but training all the way to 48 seems counter-productive in the long term. Remember, all that is guess work, I'm not going to run the numbers on training percentages because I'm lazy and I don't like math.


That kind of confused me haha

Again, I don't claim to be an expert either...but think about this:

- if your team was under the impression that they didn't feel they would seriously be competitive for 3-4 seasons, why not stockpile Skill Points THE WHOLE WAY and just gain on Attributes from training?

- for example, a OT at LVL 4 could have Blocking around 25 (30 with EQ) and Strength around 22...but have 30 Skill Points built up. the training % value is still around 32-35% for Strength or Blocking....so every 6 training points or so, you add another whole point to the attribute.

however, if you hit LVL 4 with the same scenario (Strength 22 and Blocking 25) you could use those 30 points to take either to the softcap of 48 and have around 6-8 Skill Points left. BUT, you will only be getting 12% each time you normal train for that attribute...taking about 8 training days to gain one point instead of 3. it seems like you could end up taking advantage of this for a LONG time by stockpiling Skill Points and just training...you are cutting your training % gain in more than half (from 30-35% to 10-12%) by hitting that softcap so fast.

so...it seems like if you did NOTHING but train and save SP until around LVL 15 or so, you would have one attribute damn near soft cap and like 85 SP to use...on capping TWO attributes...maybe THREE if you only needed 25-30 per extra attribute.

what am I missing here- seems like i am missing something along the way? am I wrong in this thinking?



The natural progression that is just awarded to your player is a multiplier of your current attributes, if you do not assign SP the multiplier hits at a lower rate. So you lose a percentage of your natural progression..

Thats what the people say on the GLB main forum anyway.


ahh that is right...but is that a fact of the game or just heresay? is there a chart that show the multiplier?
 
Loonzilla
WAR
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ColaCock
Originally posted by Loonzilla

Originally posted by ColaCock


Originally posted by MadcatWillie




Anyway, I'm no expert, but training all the way to 48 seems counter-productive in the long term. Remember, all that is guess work, I'm not going to run the numbers on training percentages because I'm lazy and I don't like math.


That kind of confused me haha

Again, I don't claim to be an expert either...but think about this:

- if your team was under the impression that they didn't feel they would seriously be competitive for 3-4 seasons, why not stockpile Skill Points THE WHOLE WAY and just gain on Attributes from training?

- for example, a OT at LVL 4 could have Blocking around 25 (30 with EQ) and Strength around 22...but have 30 Skill Points built up. the training % value is still around 32-35% for Strength or Blocking....so every 6 training points or so, you add another whole point to the attribute.

however, if you hit LVL 4 with the same scenario (Strength 22 and Blocking 25) you could use those 30 points to take either to the softcap of 48 and have around 6-8 Skill Points left. BUT, you will only be getting 12% each time you normal train for that attribute...taking about 8 training days to gain one point instead of 3. it seems like you could end up taking advantage of this for a LONG time by stockpiling Skill Points and just training...you are cutting your training % gain in more than half (from 30-35% to 10-12%) by hitting that softcap so fast.

so...it seems like if you did NOTHING but train and save SP until around LVL 15 or so, you would have one attribute damn near soft cap and like 85 SP to use...on capping TWO attributes...maybe THREE if you only needed 25-30 per extra attribute.

what am I missing here- seems like i am missing something along the way? am I wrong in this thinking?



The natural progression that is just awarded to your player is a multiplier of your current attributes, if you do not assign SP the multiplier hits at a lower rate. So you lose a percentage of your natural progression..

Thats what the people say on the GLB main forum anyway.


ahh that is right...but is that a fact of the game or just heresay? is there a chart that show the multiplier?




http://www.glbwiki.com/index.php?title=Leveling#Automatic_Attribute_Gains
 
Sec
offline
Link
 
If you don't get a skill to the first cap as soon as possible, then you lose extra skill points in level ups along the way. For a Center or Punter or Kicker (since it is much easier for math purposes). Your major skills get 1pt per level. So, if you wait until level 15 to put skill points into an attribute, then you have 14 points of level ups that are at 1pt for 1pt. If you hit the first cap as soon as possible (with those positions possibly level 3) then you get 12 more attribute points to level 15. In effect 24 skill points worth of gains since your major attributes have already hit the first cap. Then, as you dump more skill points to the next cap, you start getting 3 and 4 and 5 skill points worth of attribute points just for leveling up.

I think the key to slow-building is maximizing automatic level-ups, not maximizing training. Though a combination of both is more than likely the best overall option.
 
Dloth35
offline
Link
 
Chuck is Super Slow build, no assigning of points until we can hit the 3rd or 4th soft cap for each major attribute. Level 48 idea is good, but it's stil 2 to 1. Much better value when it's 3 to 1 or 4 to 1.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.