Originally posted by Jakemall
For future probowl selections, I suggest you allow popular vote for nomination and 2 GM votes for selection.
This will eliminate active team agents dominating the voting process.
The entire Discussion thread was open for the 'popular vote', anyone and everyone was able to vote players onto the wall...all it takes is three votes to get on the ballot, and your 'nomination' is counted as 1...I do believe that's fair. Nobody wanted to join the committee to voice their opinion, so I was forced to work almost a complete 24hrs (no sleep) in filling the gaps after the rest of the committee had voiced their votes. I kept extending the discussion thread, leaving the window open for more and more people to join...but nobody wanted in. How much more public could I get on a 'popular vote'? Only taking the top selected players? That's basically the case...as there were VERY FEW arguments vs. the 'Base Ballot'. Everyone seemed to agree....
For future probowl selections, I suggest you allow popular vote for nomination and 2 GM votes for selection.
This will eliminate active team agents dominating the voting process.
The entire Discussion thread was open for the 'popular vote', anyone and everyone was able to vote players onto the wall...all it takes is three votes to get on the ballot, and your 'nomination' is counted as 1...I do believe that's fair. Nobody wanted to join the committee to voice their opinion, so I was forced to work almost a complete 24hrs (no sleep) in filling the gaps after the rest of the committee had voiced their votes. I kept extending the discussion thread, leaving the window open for more and more people to join...but nobody wanted in. How much more public could I get on a 'popular vote'? Only taking the top selected players? That's basically the case...as there were VERY FEW arguments vs. the 'Base Ballot'. Everyone seemed to agree....