User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
vin521
offline
Link
 
First off, I hope everyone is having a good Memorial Day. I will take just about every one of your lines and analyze them...

"again...this wasn't supposed to be debate it was more of joke, but some don't understand that."
-Well the debate was started by plum13sec with his "lol he sucks" comment...I just gave my point of view

"and again....my qb of course is not the best...however you are again since you wanna compare forget to compare the fact that he is LLLLLEEEEVVVVVVEEEEEEELLLLLLL 10 compared to the lvl 20-30's in the leauge."
-Levels mean a whole lot less then builds in GLB (my next one responds more in depth)

(This one I am lost on) "to me that makes him better then a qb that is lvl 25 putting up less numbers.....so you can make the argument he don't play the best teams....that is bullshit....it doesn't matter what team he plays....he's 10-15 levels lower. lmao."
-so your saying he is a better QB, but he is not the best? (So who is the best QB in your opinion) Anyway, ALL I AM SAYING IS IF HE PLAYED IN THE EAST HIS NUMBERS WOULD BE WORSE (I are really tired of debating this point) and yet again levels mean a whole lot less then builds in GLB....

The whole thing about EQ
-Yes I understand that if he was a higher level he would have more SP and could get better EQ and that would benefit his game

"much of a difference. either way it can be argued left and right. but point is, my qb has put up the better numbers....regardless of the situation....so yes i throw way more, but scoring doesn't take that into consideration." and "like i said does the nfl take away drew brees's passing title this season because he threw more then the other qbs? no."
-I am 99.99999% sure that was not directed at me so I will not respond....

I really do not know what else I can say to you except for good luck with your QB in the future. If he continues to have the success he currently has you can definitely expect big things from him. BTW if you make a reply bout the east vs. west issue I will simply copy and paste ALL I AM SAYING IS IF HE PLAYED IN THE EAST HIS NUMBERS WOULD BE WORSE
 
Devin00
offline
Link
 
yes they prob would if i played in the other division. frankly i'm suprised his numbers were as good considering the level difference.

i'm not here to debate what division is better. i could care less

but point is that my qb led the league in yards and tds....is it because he passes so much...of course it is. would i try to say otherwise....no

but he does. and my argument was that no matter how you look at it...he led the league. is it a shitty rap for those qbs that don't pass as much. yes it is. but that's football.

and again best of luck to your players as well. and everyone else's.
 
dss02
offline
Link
 
Stats really mean jack.....

W/L determines if your player is good

If you want to say he is great based off his stats my question to you is.....

Does this make My peewee QB the 19th best in the game?
#1 in peewee and 19th Globally because of stats so is he in fact the 19th best in the game?

Besides anyone can complete a ton of passes for a pathetic avg if they manipulate their sliders....
Edited by dss02 on May 25, 2009 16:11:52
 
Devin00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dss02
Stats really mean jack.....

W/L determines if your player is good

If you want to say he is great based off his stats my question to you is.....

Does this make My peewee QB the 19th best in the game?
#1 in peewee and 19th Globally because of stats so is he in fact the 19th best in the game?

Besides anyone can complete a ton of passes for a pathetic avg if they manipulate their sliders....


well then yes i would say your qb is 19th. yes stats mean everything when your going for individual awards. lol. this isn't who's qb is the best team oriented and win/loss qb contest.

it's best qb overall based on performance.

and besides anyone can complete passes....agreed. however when you have a 10 year old completing passes against 20 year olds....well that's impressive. you can be a hater too

nice qb btw.
 
Devin00
offline
Link
 
and btw...rushing qbs for peewee is a flaw in the game. it's glitch so comparing a running qb to a passing qb in a different type of league is not gonna work.

however your qb did best it in that league and was the best qb in that league. no question.

and if you think it's not a glitch in the game go look at the bugs section before the season started and check it out....then ask yourself why everyone made rushing qbs all a sudden lvl 1 qbs against lvl 1 defenders or by that means had no way to stop them. you can use the same bootleg and get touchdown every time.....that's old
 
dss02
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Devin00
and btw...rushing qbs for peewee is a flaw in the game. it's glitch so comparing a running qb to a passing qb in a different type of league is not gonna work.

however your qb did best it in that league and was the best qb in that league. no question.

and if you think it's not a glitch in the game go look at the bugs section before the season started and check it out....then ask yourself why everyone made rushing qbs all a sudden lvl 1 qbs against lvl 1 defenders or by that means had no way to stop them. you can use the same bootleg and get touchdown every time.....that's old


Not a glitch....Defender's complain about not instantly responding to the boot leg but their is another side....If they are allowed to respond to a boot leg instantly then a qb should have the option of 1 dumping the pass off or 2 throwing it away. As this is not the case allowing the defense a near perfect reaction time is out of the question. BTW it takes a pathetic DC to fail to shutdown a rushing qb....it is easily done and you have 2 ways to go about it, it just leaves you open to other attacks.

Now i could care less why everyone else made a rushing qb....I decided before the season started that i was gonna try to put up some insane stats and essentially shit on some records.....goal completed...(btw finished 16th globally)
 
Devin00
offline
Link
 
already said good for u...and your qb is beast.

if it works, then do it.

but then what point where you trying to make to me? that my qb is bad because W/L....lmao. that's bogus. have you looked at our team? lot of spots filled by cpu. win or loss has nothing to do with how well a qb does.

again....same situation. does drew brees suck because new orleans didn't win? next time make valid point and make it good.

as far as your rushing qb...i can care less, i was just telling you the reason everyone made them. i am not saying that is why you did....and i was just simply stating you can't compare rusher to passer.
 
vin521
offline
Link
 
"but then what point where you trying to make to me? that my qb is bad because W/L....lmao. that's bogus. have you looked at our team? lot of spots filled by cpu. win or loss has nothing to do with how well a qb does."


I really have tried to not reply in this post anymore, but this quote forced me to....
Regarding the cpus the last time we had A CPU play somewhat significant time (14 plays) was when we faced the GSST the first time around (sorry if a more recent one happened that I missed)....

Now regarding W.V. passing (or lack of) we made it to 15-1 by rushing (and the best part of was everyone knew we were going to rush on them) , your team made it to 4-12 by passing . That is not my point though like I said in my 1st round Eastern Conference Playoff Predictions post, "Most of the times when a huge upset occurs is when a one dimensional team (a team that only pass throughout the regular season decides to run during the playoffs or visa versa) *coughs**coughs*"

I also disagree with you about NFL QBs not be judged by w/l. In drew brees' case one bad season would not effect his legacy. This more applies to a players legacy. Dan Marino NEVER WON A TITLE, yes he is remembered because of his amazing stats, but I am pretty sure he would have rather had Trent Dilferish (created a new word...definition- be a pretty bad QB but win a title because of the players behind him) way of winning.




Edited by vin521 on May 28, 2009 09:50:20
 
Devin00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vin521
"but then what point where you trying to make to me? that my qb is bad because W/L....lmao. that's bogus. have you looked at our team? lot of spots filled by cpu. win or loss has nothing to do with how well a qb does."


I really have tried to not reply in this post anymore, but this quote forced me to....
Regarding the cpus the last time we had A CPU play somewhat significant time (14 plays) was when we faced the GSST the first time around (sorry if a more recent one happened that I missed)....

Now regarding W.V. passing (or lack of) we made it to 15-1 by rushing (and the best part of was everyone knew we were going to rush on them) , your team made it to 4-12 by passing . That is not my point though like I said in my 1st round Eastern Conference Playoff Predictions post, "Most of the times when a huge upset occurs is when a one dimensional team (a team that only pass throughout the regular season decides to run during the playoffs or visa versa) *coughs**coughs*"

I also disagree with you about NFL QBs not be judged by w/l. In drew brees' case one bad season would not effect his legacy. This more applies to a players legacy. Dan Marino NEVER WON A TITLE, yes he is remembered because of his amazing stats, but I am pretty sure he would have rather had Trent Dilferish (created a new word...definition- be a pretty bad QB but win a title because of the players behind him) way of winning.






i don't think you understand my post. we have half a team full of cpus....we ain't gonna win like that....is my point. not you...us. so valuing my win loss record is irrelevant. we had no intentions of winning this season. hence casual league

and yes your absolutely right. any qb in their right mind would trade away a record for a championship if they didn't have one. and drew brees is perfect example? great qb...one of the best in the game...what has he done? nothing with his team...although individually dominant at times. does that make him bad qb because his team can't win when it means most? of course not.

like you said your only as good as the players around you...and i don't take full credit for leading the league in all the above in passing....sarcastically.....i had few great receivers here that made that happen...not all me....but can't a guy get credit where credit is due....to make a statement that my qb is no good because he led league but didn't make playoffs is a knock that shouldn't be under the circumstances.

and yes it's better to be multi-dimensional team no question...gotta keep the other team guessing...but if i was so bad of a qb, then don't you think i would have played horrible because the defense was keyed against the pass? no that didn't happen i still put up great numbers for my level facing higher levels.
 
vin521
offline
Link
 
"i don't think you understand my post. we have half a team full of cpus....we ain't gonna win like that....is my point. not you...us"
Oh I just reread the original and your right sorry about that one...

BTW-This was hands down the best reply you had in this entire post (and I personally believe that it would be a wonderful way to end this post)


 
Devin00
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vin521
"i don't think you understand my post. we have half a team full of cpus....we ain't gonna win like that....is my point. not you...us"
Oh I just reread the original and your right sorry about that one...

BTW-This was hands down the best reply you had in this entire post (and I personally believe that it would be a wonderful way to end this post)




thanks and every reply i had was good and justified. maybe you should have reread them all and this is where the thread will die i hope lol...should have died after my 1st post...wasn't supposed to be debate thread...supposed to be bustin balls thread cuz everyone else was doing it.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.