User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
ratmaze
offline
Link
 
I thank CT for doing this.

In my opinion, I think its the team owners and GMs responsibility to submit their players for consideration. This idea has been floating around for awhile, and I definitely agree some big names are absent - I even asked him to put in a blank so we could add our own opinions (ie. Bone Smash). This season he said that maybe too much. I also feel that, similar to most all star games, all teams should have at least one player represented. Just because someone is on a crappy team and doesn't have all level 15 tackles and guards to open holes, protect and give time, doesn't mean they aren't very good. Same on defense, this is a team game and sometimes individuals are stars but are more involved in a "team concept" and their stats may not show the whole picture.

I agree that exposing your attributes isn't for everyone and shouldn't be required.

I applaud CT for doing this and trying to make the game even more enjoyable. It will only be interesting to all of us though, if all of our conference teams have some representation. A Yukon/Bracatus all star team would be great, but there are other players and owners that are developing teams as well.
 
CTGuyton
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ratmaze
I thank CT for doing this.

In my opinion, I think its the team owners and GMs responsibility to submit their players for consideration. This idea has been floating around for awhile, and I definitely agree some big names are absent - I even asked him to put in a blank so we could add our own opinions (ie. Bone Smash). This season he said that maybe too much. I also feel that, similar to most all star games, all teams should have at least one player represented. Just because someone is on a crappy team and doesn't have all level 15 tackles and guards to open holes, protect and give time, doesn't mean they aren't very good. Same on defense, this is a team game and sometimes individuals are stars but are more involved in a "team concept" and their stats may not show the whole picture.

I agree that exposing your attributes isn't for everyone and shouldn't be required.

I applaud CT for doing this and trying to make the game even more enjoyable. It will only be interesting to all of us though, if all of our conference teams have some representation. A Yukon/Bracatus all star team would be great, but there are other players and owners that are developing teams as well.


I hope tht next season we will be able to ensure all teams are represented. I had an idea last night to have each team nominate 10 players which would have 320 players nominated. I want to narrow this down to 200(4 per spot on the final roster) on the ballot and eventually 50 on the final team. now that many more players/owners/gms know whats going on and I have had a few people volunteer to help out next season I really think this is something that can only grow and get better.

as for the equal represetation I am all for it on the ballot but the final team doesn't necisarrily need to include everey team. I agree that I may not be as interested if one of my teammates aren't in the game but being honored with a nomination and watching you league claim dominance I think will be enough for most players. The only real way to make sure every team is represented is to ignore some votes and uninclude someone who has rightfully earned his spot on the team through a fair nomination and voting process.

The attributes ar not required to be revealed. It makes it easier on me and allows your madden counterpart to be more accurate but I have ways around it that i think will work out well for those who want to keep thier attributes private.
 
foobles
offline
Link
 
Really bad list, why isn't Spangler up there for LB voting?
 
Lecithin
offline
Link
 
Where's Speedy Hernandez on the WR list? Where's Egon Spangler on the LB list? Where's Pher Hobbits on the CB list? There are a bunch of players who SHOULD be on these lists that aren't.

I agree with the idea where each owner submits a player or two from each position for each league. That way it'll be fairer.
 
Lecithin
offline
Link
 
Is kick everything the only player from our team on the list?
 
CTGuyton
offline
Link
 
I get so irritated by people who reply w/o reading the thread. Almo. Your team's owner didn't submit nominations to be put on the ballot. I(notice the singular) did not have time nor feel the need to go through 128(notice the massive difference in the team:organizer ratio) and find the best players. I did how ever take the time to ensure that there was at least 1 player from each team on the ballot. you kicker just happened to be the best kicker of the teams that didn't submit any nominations. next year if your team owner/gm decide to participate then the ballot will include more and better players from your team.
 
mactruck27
offline
Link
 
That's true, but how hard is it to look on the league leaders and see Speedy and Egon near the top of the lists?
 
CTGuyton
offline
Link
 
how hard is it to say I want speedy and egon to represent my team on the ballot. I think alot easier than me looking at a buch of lists. if I did it for WRs and RBs and QBs who have alot of stats it wuldn't be fair to the TEs and FBs and SSs who have very few stats. its a much better system to have the owners who know the players the best to nominate, as long as they do nominate.
 
CTGuyton
offline
Link
 
The results are in.. #4 is Gold

the rosters will be done tommorrow
 
DickovDK
offline
Link
 
Anywhere one can see who are picked ?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.