User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA#1 Pro Bowl? Awards Ceremony?
Page:
 
BigMike1983
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seattlecane
I haven't read it all because I am far too important but here's how it should go down IMO.

A league Commish (West and East) should be established. 1 rep from each team should compile the votes from their team. You can't vote for your players. The designated rep reports the votes back to the Commish. The commish can then compile the list and publish it to the board.


I agree with that.
 
BigMike1983
offline
Link
 
So when are we gonna get this going?
 
Quasta
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by seattlecane
I haven't read it all because I am far too important but here's how it should go down IMO.

A league Commish (West and East) should be established. 1 rep from each team should compile the votes from their team. You can't vote for your players. The designated rep reports the votes back to the Commish. The commish can then compile the list and publish it to the board.


As of yet I dont believe there has been any mention of having the players vote. I believe we have just discussed owners & possibly GM's. I am not opposed to having player vote but it gets alot more complicated. For instance is it a vote for each player or user? Will there me a maximum amout of votes per team?

Also the idea of a league/conference comish is a good one.

Coach Q
Last edited May 16, 2008 19:25:07
 
IronMike
offline
Link
 
Ya using players is too much work I say just owners (sorry GMs) that way 32 possible people and not everyone will vote. Doing it by conf East/West meaning only 16 people would have to do this and since not all 16 like I said would it shouldn't be that difficult.
 
rogers2000
offline
Link
 
it sounds good, the league is great! I would like to involve as many as possible to make more fun & interesting, but should only be Owner of team & maybe 1 GM, but just Owners makes it simple & straight forward!
 
Quint
offline
Link
 
Yup, just Owners seems good.
 
The Rut
offline
Link
 
Since several of us own 5 or more players it would be a little difficult to get a fair player vote from each team. I say keep it owners to start.
 
TheCondor
offline
Link
 
It would be so much easier (and possibly even cooler) if Bort added the ability to create polls. That way you could just send a poll to all of the owners and they can answer accordingly. It's not like it will be difficult otherwise, but it will be way more efficient to do this via a poll.

Plus, it will take care of the "random" votes for player's clearly not on the list to be a pro-bowl candidate. And even then, I think it will make this more fun if there was actually a pro bowl. I can guarantee player's would love the idea of having just one more game to gain some XP. Plus, that makes for some incentive to want to be in the pro bowl or selected to the pro bowl. Maybe even add cash incentives for pro bowler's?

My 2 cents.
 
TheCondor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Rut
Should we require that a player have been with a team at least half of the regular season to be nominated for Pro Bowl?


My vote only goes for player's who have been on the team for the entire season.

There might be limited cases where I'd vote for a player that's been on two teams this season, but my initial votes are for player's sticking with one team. For those who moved teams this year -- if they are on the same team for all of next season, and they perform at pro bowl level, then they can get my vote.
 
rogers2000
offline
Link
 
i bet Bort does add this feature into GLB eventually! I think 3/4 of the teams games should qualify a player b/c u dont want to discourage the whole free agent/ trade market its a good part of the game also.
 
mikerynne
offline
Link
 
I keep coming back to the owners having the only vote in this. If anything I was thinking that as the offensive coordinator of a team that I have a pretty good idea of the defensive players in our league and that have the owners vote for anyone, and the coodinators vote for the players on the other side of the ball that something like that could work.

The one thing I do know is that Porkchop Watkins better get his head screwed on straight if he wants to merit consideration for this.
 
mcnorth
offline
Link
 
I think each team can decide how they want to handle this, whether the owner wants player and coaches input or not, and can submit their votes and/or candidates to the commish type-guy running this for each conference. If an owner wants to roundtable then great - that's why we have team forums.

I also support the notion that teams do not vote for their own players. I think the owners of the teams in our leagues are sharp enough to see behind and not only the individual stats and consider record, team statistics, and player ratings and effectiveness. We all know who we game-planned for and who in the league is getting it done for their squad.

2 cents
 
TheCondor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mcnorth
I think each team can decide how they want to handle this, whether the owner wants player and coaches input or not, and can submit their votes and/or candidates to the commish type-guy running this for each conference. If an owner wants to roundtable then great - that's why we have team forums.

I also support the notion that teams do not vote for their own players. I think the owners of the teams in our leagues are sharp enough to see behind and not only the individual stats and consider record, team statistics, and player ratings and effectiveness. We all know who we game-planned for and who in the league is getting it done for their squad.

2 cents


+1
 
seattlecane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mcnorth
I think each team can decide how they want to handle this, whether the owner wants player and coaches input or not, and can submit their votes and/or candidates to the commish type-guy running this for each conference. If an owner wants to roundtable then great - that's why we have team forums.

I also support the notion that teams do not vote for their own players. I think the owners of the teams in our leagues are sharp enough to see behind and not only the individual stats and consider record, team statistics, and player ratings and effectiveness. We all know who we game-planned for and who in the league is getting it done for their squad.

2 cents


1 looney.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.