User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA > USA AAA Leagues > SilentTom's AAA #1 (West) Power Rankings
SilentTom
offline
Link
 
Before Week 10

My rankings favour wins and to a slightly less extent strength of schedule. Also included in my formula are point differential and win streak/strength of victory in that order of importance.

1. Fresno Ninjas (40) - Solid across the board, and undefeated.

2. Dayton Brute Squad (64) - Another solid team, last week's game decided the top two rankings.

3. TCG Fightin 52s (65) - Right there with the other two teams and holding a five game week streak really helped with that.

4. Dallas Wildcats (74) - Average/above average in most categories, they have had the second toughest schedule which pushed them above a few of the other teams.

5. Gilroy Devils (80) - Almost identical to the Wildcats, a few points in strength of schedule was all that really separated the two.

6. San Francisco Demons (84) - Average/above average across the board, but don't really excel in any categories, keeping them a tad lower than a couple other 5-4 teams.

7. Oakland Rage (86) - The worst strength of schedule in the conference and a low strength of victory relegates the Rage to seventh in the rankings.

8. Buffalo Wills (89) - The highest team with a negative point differential, perhaps a meeting with Long Beach in a couple weeks will help that out.

9. San Jose Spartans (95) - In a situation similar to the Rage with the second worst strength of schedule they do not have the luxury of a seventh win relegating them to ninth behind a few 5-4 teams.

10. California 49ers (107) - At 4-5 this is probably right about where they should expect to be. A solid +93 point differential helps, but it came entirely from a 94-0 pounding of Phoenix last week. Three of their four wins have come against teams with only 1 or 2 wins.

11. Lake Oswego Bulldogs (108) - The final 5-4 team, and you can see its very close. A weaker strength of schedule put them here.

12. Long Beach Bandits (141) - This will no doubt surprise people, but the only 1 or 2 win team to beat someone higher in the standings. A high strength of schedule also helps. You will also notice the next three teams are right there with them.

13. Dallas Zone Defenders (142) - Not really much to say, fifth highest strength of schedule.

14. Phoenix Mambas (146) - They've had the toughest schedule thus far and it shows in their win count and point differential.

15. Parma Burglars (149) - Not really much to say about them either.

16. Oklahoma Hawks (171) - They've fought hard all season as shown by an amazing -14 point differential for a 1-8 team. They are the only team without a single appearance in the top ten of a single category.

Hope you all enjoyed it.
 
seattlecane
offline
Link
 
good work.
 
TheCondor
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SilentTom
Before Week 10

My rankings favour wins and to a slightly less extent strength of schedule. Also included in my formula are point differential and win streak/strength of victory in that order of importance.

1. Fresno Ninjas (40) - Solid across the board, and undefeated.

2. Dayton Brute Squad (64) - Another solid team, last week's game decided the top two rankings.

3. TCG Fightin 52s (65) - Right there with the other two teams and holding a five game week streak really helped with that.

4. Dallas Wildcats (74) - Average/above average in most categories, they have had the second toughest schedule which pushed them above a few of the other teams.

5. Gilroy Devils (80) - Almost identical to the Wildcats, a few points in strength of schedule was all that really separated the two.

6. San Francisco Demons (84) - Average/above average across the board, but don't really excel in any categories, keeping them a tad lower than a couple other 5-4 teams.

7. Oakland Rage (86) - The worst strength of schedule in the conference and a low strength of victory relegates the Rage to seventh in the rankings.

8. Buffalo Wills (89) - The highest team with a negative point differential, perhaps a meeting with Long Beach in a couple weeks will help that out.

9. San Jose Spartans (95) - In a situation similar to the Rage with the second worst strength of schedule they do not have the luxury of a seventh win relegating them to ninth behind a few 5-4 teams.

10. California 49ers (107) - At 4-5 this is probably right about where they should expect to be. A solid +93 point differential helps, but it came entirely from a 94-0 pounding of Phoenix last week. Three of their four wins have come against teams with only 1 or 2 wins.

11. Lake Oswego Bulldogs (108) - The final 5-4 team, and you can see its very close. A weaker strength of schedule put them here.

12. Long Beach Bandits (141) - This will no doubt surprise people, but the only 1 or 2 win team to beat someone higher in the standings. A high strength of schedule also helps. You will also notice the next three teams are right there with them.

13. Dallas Zone Defenders (142) - Not really much to say, fifth highest strength of schedule.

14. Phoenix Mambas (146) - They've had the toughest schedule thus far and it shows in their win count and point differential.

15. Parma Burglars (149) - Not really much to say about them either.

16. Oklahoma Hawks (171) - They've fought hard all season as shown by an amazing -14 point differential for a 1-8 team. They are the only team without a single appearance in the top ten of a single category.

Hope you all enjoyed it.


Take a look at my first game. I played a very different team than everyone else, a team that was gutted the very next game.

With my loss to that team, and the team now being a guaranteed victory and stat-run-up game for every single other team that plays them. I don't see how that translates to my team having a weaker schedule.

Otherwise, good work.
Last edited May 13, 2008 23:14:09
 
SilentTom
offline
Link
 
Your team had the 13th (of 16) highest strength of schedule, where as the team right above you had the fifth highest (their opponents had five more wins than yours). That is all I meant by weaker strength of schedule.
 
The Rut
offline
Link
 
Love being an underdog!!! I hope that people don't take us lightly.
 
The Rut
offline
Link
 
I like the rankings and stuff, but I don't get what Strength of Schedule has to do with this game... we all play the same teams except for the last game (which we drew Wichita.. lucky us!). I know we played a different Phoenix team than most other people played, but all in all after 16 games... we all should pretty much have the same strength of schedule shouldn't we?
 
BigMike1983
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Rut
I like the rankings and stuff, but I don't get what Strength of Schedule has to do with this game... we all play the same teams except for the last game (which we drew Wichita.. lucky us!). I know we played a different Phoenix team than most other people played, but all in all after 16 games... we all should pretty much have the same strength of schedule shouldn't we?


Exactly!
 
SilentTom
offline
Link
 
Yeah, you should ... and I've already thought of that ... as the season winds down I will be putting less emphasis on strength of schedule. But right now some teams have played four of the 1 and 2 win teams and have yet to play a majority of the top teams (Oakland, San Jose). Meanwhile, others (Dallas, probably another team or two) have faced each of the top five teams and still have the two easiest teams left on their schedule.

In short, San Jose and Oakland have proved they're good (can beat the really bad teams, and have beaten a couple 5-4/4-5 teams), but not great (they have not faced any top ranked teams ... both lost to Dayton, and have also lost to 5-4 teams as well).

I may be coming up with a different way of organizing it in the coming days due to this and a couple other issues. Right now I am going by ranking the teams 1-16 in each category, but will like break it down into percentages (ie the number that is first in the category gets 100% for that one, while the rest get percentages based on that number). This will balance out the strength of schedule as time goes on and they become more similar.
Last edited May 14, 2008 08:03:27
 
The Rut
offline
Link
 
I can see that. It would factor into rankings this early for sure. Just keep an eye on those California guys...
 
Quasta
offline
Link
 
Phoenix and Long Beach have VERY different teams than what they started with. Playing them later after they were gutted is a definate advantage that is not reflected in the SOS calculations.


 
BigMike1983
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SilentTom
Yeah, you should ... and I've already thought of that ... as the season winds down I will be putting less emphasis on strength of schedule. But right now some teams have played four of the 1 and 2 win teams and have yet to play a majority of the top teams (Oakland, San Jose). Meanwhile, others (Dallas, probably another team or two) have faced each of the top five teams and still have the two easiest teams left on their schedule.

In short, San Jose and Oakland have proved they're good (can beat the really bad teams, and have beaten a couple 5-4/4-5 teams), but not great (they have not faced any top ranked teams ... both lost to Dayton, and have also lost to 5-4 teams as well).

I may be coming up with a different way of organizing it in the coming days due to this and a couple other issues. Right now I am going by ranking the teams 1-16 in each category, but will like break it down into percentages (ie the number that is first in the category gets 100% for that one, while the rest get percentages based on that number). This will balance out the strength of schedule as time goes on and they become more similar.


I look forward to your updated rankings...
 
SilentTom
offline
Link
 
Here is a question for you guys ... seeing as how they really throw off things (SoS, point differential, strength of victory, etc). Do you want me to take games against Long Beach and South Beach (formerly Phoenix) right out of the equations? (ie games against them don't count at all)

Or would you rather I keep them in the mix?

Perhaps I'll do both this time around and see what you think.
Last edited May 14, 2008 14:02:52
 
seattlecane
offline
Link
 
in the mix.
 
SilentTom
offline
Link
 
Post Week 10 Power Rankings

I've changed it such that it is now a percentage of the top score for each category resulting in either a score of 1 or a decimal. The final totals times by 100 to produce a score out of 100.

1. Fresno Ninjas (93.63)
2. Dayton Brute Squad (81.04)
3. Oakland Rage (73.99)
4. TCG Fightin' 52s (71.03)
5. Buffalo Wills (65.53)
6. Gilroy Devils (65.18)
7. San Francisco Demons (62.86)
8. San Jose Spartans (62.78)
9. Dallas Wildcats (62.72)
10. California 49ers (61.68)
11. Lake Oswego (58.65)
12. Dallas Zone Defenders (43.8)
13. Parma Burglars (41.55)
14. Long Beach Bandits (37.55)
15. South Beach Soldiers (33.84)
16. Oklahoma Hawks (30.46)

Enjoy, I might post comments next time.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.