User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Oceania > Oceania AAA Leagues > Oceania AAA what is the best conference Alpha or Zeta
Page:
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HaplosDog
Originally posted by lukin83

Originally posted by HaplosDog


There's an even better way to settle this. A Championship game. Someone tell Bort.

Oh, wait...nvm.


I don't think that settles anything outside of the best team from Alpha is better/worse than the best team from Zeta.


I agree. I was only posting that because I don't think that a Pro-bowl game would be a good way to settle this either. Who would pick which players are part of each squad? Most importantly, who would be the coaching team for each?


I agree on that, as well. Coaching plays a huge role, as does the players said coach has to work with. There is no realistic way to get a 100% definite answer to this question. I honestly think they are pretty even, as a whole. There may be a slight advantage to one conference, but it is very small in my eyes.
 
HaplosDog
offline
Link
 
I agree that it's all very subjective. My very subjective opinion, having followed this league very closely since last season, is that the Alpha Conference has a slight overall edge.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HaplosDog
I agree that it's all very subjective. My very subjective opinion, having followed this league very closely since last season, is that the Alpha Conference has a slight overall edge.


Except for that awesome Caninites team in the Zeta, right?
 
Tevin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by HaplosDog

Originally posted by lukin83


Originally posted by HaplosDog



There's an even better way to settle this. A Championship game. Someone tell Bort.

Oh, wait...nvm.


I don't think that settles anything outside of the best team from Alpha is better/worse than the best team from Zeta.


I agree. I was only posting that because I don't think that a Pro-bowl game would be a good way to settle this either. Who would pick which players are part of each squad? Most importantly, who would be the coaching team for each?


I agree on that, as well. Coaching plays a huge role, as does the players said coach has to work with. There is no realistic way to get a 100% definite answer to this question. I honestly think they are pretty even, as a whole. There may be a slight advantage to one conference, but it is very small in my eyes.



We could be able to play 4 randomized teams in the other conferences.........
 
hdawesome
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by lukin83
Originally posted by HaplosDog

Originally posted by lukin83


Originally posted by HaplosDog



There's an even better way to settle this. A Championship game. Someone tell Bort.

Oh, wait...nvm.


I don't think that settles anything outside of the best team from Alpha is better/worse than the best team from Zeta.


I agree. I was only posting that because I don't think that a Pro-bowl game would be a good way to settle this either. Who would pick which players are part of each squad? Most importantly, who would be the coaching team for each?


I agree on that, as well. Coaching plays a huge role, as does the players said coach has to work with. There is no realistic way to get a 100% definite answer to this question. I honestly think they are pretty even, as a whole. There may be a slight advantage to one conference, but it is very small in my eyes.


I like the idea of a Pro-Bowl. It would be like the NFL the coach who made the superbowl (or Confrence champions in our case Alpha and Zeta) would coach the Alpha and Zeta teams ... do you guys watch football?

 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by hdawesome
Originally posted by lukin83

Originally posted by HaplosDog


Originally posted by lukin83



Originally posted by HaplosDog




There's an even better way to settle this. A Championship game. Someone tell Bort.

Oh, wait...nvm.


I don't think that settles anything outside of the best team from Alpha is better/worse than the best team from Zeta.


I agree. I was only posting that because I don't think that a Pro-bowl game would be a good way to settle this either. Who would pick which players are part of each squad? Most importantly, who would be the coaching team for each?


I agree on that, as well. Coaching plays a huge role, as does the players said coach has to work with. There is no realistic way to get a 100% definite answer to this question. I honestly think they are pretty even, as a whole. There may be a slight advantage to one conference, but it is very small in my eyes.


I like the idea of a Pro-Bowl. It would be like the NFL the coach who made the superbowl (or Confrence champions in our case Alpha and Zeta) would coach the Alpha and Zeta teams ... do you guys watch football?



I actually think that would be an awesome idea. I'm not sure it would be a high priority for the devs though.
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by
The Top 10:

1 . ( 1 . ) 1.10 [ 1 , 1 , 1.50 ] Brantford Mustangs (9-0-0)
2 . ( 2 . ) 2.20 [ 2 , 2 , 3.00 ] Tonga Ikale Tahi (8-1-0)
3 . ( 3 . ) 3.40 [ 3 , 4 , 4.00 ] Sth Queensland Crushers (8-0-1)
4 . ( 5 . ) 3.70 [ 5 , 2 , 1.50 ] FFLW Caninites (8-1-0)
5 . ( 4 . ) 5.30 [ 4 , 7 , 7.50 ] Cajun Crushers (7-2-0)
6 . ( 6 . ) 6.40 [ 7 , 5 , 6.00 ] Melbourne SWG (7-2-0)
7 . ( 10 . ) 7.90 [ 7 , 5 , 13.50 ] Sydney Sharks (7-2-0)
8 . ( 9 . ) 8.00 [ 6 , 13 , 9.00 ] Arctic Panthers (8-1-0)
9 . ( 8 . ) 9.50 [ 9 , 9 , 11.50 ] Gold Coast Crocs (6-2-1)
10 . ( 12 . ) 9.90 [ 11 , 9 , 7.50 ] Dunedin Beavers (7-2-0)

The Middle 10:

11 . ( 13 . ) 10.40 [ 12 , 8 , 8.00 ] PUMPED UP PISTONS (7-2-0)
12 . ( 6 . ) 10.90 [ 10 , 11 , 13.50 ] Utopia Kangaroos (6-3-0)
13t . ( 14 . ) 13.80 [ 15 , 13 , 11.00 ] So Cal BDC (5-4-0)
13t . ( 11 . ) 13.80 [ 13 , 15 , 15.00 ] The Bomb Squad (5-4-0)
15 . ( 17 . ) 14.00 [ 13 , 20 , 11.00 ] Springfield Sewer Rats (5-4-0)
16 . ( 15 . ) 15.40 [ 17 , 12 , 14.00 ] Toowoomba (OTF) Centurions (5-4-0)
17 . ( 16 . ) 16.70 [ 16 , 16 , 19.50 ] Los Cabolo Sharks (4-5-0)
18 . ( 18 . ) 17.50 [ 18 , 18 , 15.50 ] Avondells Raiders (4-5-0)
19 . ( 19 . ) 19.70 [ 19 , 22 , 19.50 ] Port Moresby Demons (3-6-0)
20 . ( 20 . ) 21.80 [ 23 , 21 , 19.00 ] Barossa Grapestompers (3-6-0)

The bottom 12:

21 . ( 23 . ) 22.10 [ 22 , 22 , 22.50 ] Samoa Flying Foxes (2-7-0)
22 . ( 25 . ) 22.70 [ 21 , 26 , 24.50 ] Oregon Flat Backers (2-7-0)
23 . ( 26 . ) 23.10 [ 20 , 28 , 27.50 ] Newcastle Surfers (2-7-0)
24 . ( 21 . ) 23.70 [ 26 , 19 , 21.50 ] Sydney Thunder (3-6-0)
25 . ( 22 . ) 24.70 [ 23 , 29 , 25.50 ] Tonga Strikers (3-6-0)
26 . ( 24 . ) 24.90 [ 29 , 16 , 21.50 ] Le Thor Bulls (3-6-0)
27 . ( 27 . ) 25.30 [ 25 , 24 , 27.50 ] Canberra Stingers (2-7-0)
28 . ( 28 . ) 26.90 [ 28 , 25 , 25.50 ] (N.M.I) Pagan Fire Eaters (2-7-0)
29 . ( 29 . ) 27.00 [ 26 , 27 , 30.00 ] Sunshine Coast Wallabies (1-8-0)
30t . ( 30 . ) 30.30 [ 31 , 30 , 28.50 ] District 5 Ducks (0-9-0)
30t . ( 31 . ) 30.30 [ 30 , 31 , 30.50 ] The Practice Squad (1-8-0)
32 . ( 32 . ) 31.40 [ 31 , 32 , 32.00 ] Fiji Storm (0-9-0)


Based on these rankings, it is pretty tight between which is the better conference. Adding up the ranks of each team should give a good perspective on how good overall each conference is.

The Alpha Conference totals 260 to the Zeta Conference's total of 266, so slight edge to Alpha heading into Week 10.
 
HaplosDog
offline
Link
 
I think that Alpha is top heavy and Zeta has less bad teams. Alpha has the best teams, but Zeta has more good teams.
 
McGruffHawk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by HaplosDog
I think that Alpha is top heavy and Zeta has less bad teams. Alpha has the best teams, but Zeta has more good teams.


I think that's a fair assessment. Alpha is fairly polarized. There's only 3 teams in that middlin' 4-6 wins group, and half the team (8) have just flat out struggled to win games. Zeta has more balance, more even tiers with a top five, a middle five, and a bottom 6. However, I should point out that the teams only two winless teams are in Zeta.
 
DaSaintFan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tevin
We could be able to play 4 randomized teams in the other conferences.........


I don't agree with the randomized teams... I do prefer the idea of playing the teams that are ranked at or near you for 3 out of conference games... although the scheduling would be kind of rough (considering they drop/promote 4 teams each season..)

13 in conference, 3 out of conference...

Last edited May 13, 2008 07:55:11
 
HaplosDog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by McGruffHawk
Originally posted by HaplosDog

I think that Alpha is top heavy and Zeta has less bad teams. Alpha has the best teams, but Zeta has more good teams.


I think that's a fair assessment. Alpha is fairly polarized. There's only 3 teams in that middlin' 4-6 wins group, and half the team (8) have just flat out struggled to win games. Zeta has more balance, more even tiers with a top five, a middle five, and a bottom 6. However, I should point out that the league's only two winless teams are in Zeta.


Don't I know!

And they will be playing each other tomorrow.
 
Carpy
offline
Link
 
How does the promotion/relegation work? Is it the 2 teams that make the championship game that go up, or the two conference leaders at the end of the regular season?
 
Mickgolden
offline
Link
 
2 Championship game teams.
 
HaplosDog
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PACharger
2 Championship game teams.


Yes, and the last place team from each conference gets relegated.
 
Link
 
sometimes getting relegated puts you in a better league, with more participation and better all around conversation...

just saying!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.