User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Mrstickball
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by djfivenine
Originally posted by fastmover

Originally posted by wolfe


Just wanted to try my 2 cents.
Computerized rankings based on Win%, Opponent Win % and Score differential.

The Power32: http://wolfeplanet.net/atoms/sched.php

I'm not sure how this formula will hold up by the end of the year. Every team will have 15 games in common so Opponent Win% will be less relevant.



Good stuff right there, no bias involved, thanks!



Semper fi



The problem with that ranking is, its only numbers.
The GSPs defeated the Grizzlies by over 20 pts, and they are still behind them in the rankings.
Also, for our score differentials, we like to play our backups when we get ahead..so teams score some scrap TDs in the 4th qtr against us.


Too bad there isnt a metric on that ranking for quality wins..
 
fastmover
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by djfivenine
Originally posted by fastmover

Originally posted by wolfe


Just wanted to try my 2 cents.
Computerized rankings based on Win%, Opponent Win % and Score differential.

The Power32: http://wolfeplanet.net/atoms/sched.php

I'm not sure how this formula will hold up by the end of the year. Every team will have 15 games in common so Opponent Win% will be less relevant.[/QUOTE


Good stuff right there, no bias involved, thanks!



Semper fi



The problem with that ranking is, its only numbers.
The GSPs defeated the Grizzlies by over 20 pts, and they are still behind them in the rankings.
Also, for our score differentials, we like to play our backups when we get ahead..so teams score some scrap TDs in the 4th qtr against us.


We also play our back ups alot on both sides of the ball, and we still do pretty well on offense and defense. We have scoreed a total of 292 points, and allowed a measly 41 points, (2 td's total and the rest was fg's) thats pretty stout IMO. That includes back up's with 40-50% playing time in the game. So I think the computerized stats are pretty good. Also it doesnt matter if the gsp's beat the grizzlies by 20, consistency that teams have is what matters in order to effect those numbers.

Semper fi

Last edited May 11, 2008 20:13:00
 
Brick Wall
offline
Link
 
nice work stick
 
wolfe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by djfivenine

The problem with that ranking is, its only numbers.
The GSPs defeated the Grizzlies by over 20 pts, and they are still behind them in the rankings.
Also, for our score differentials, we like to play our backups when we get ahead..so teams score some scrap TDs in the 4th qtr against us.


Yeah, it's all just number crunching. No system will ever be perfect.
 
agitator
offline
Link
 
Springfield Upset Scotstown! wonder how that will play into the power rankings!!!!

Go Atoms!!!!
 
agitator
offline
Link
 
Updated Power Rankings by Jeff Wolfe:

http://wolfeplanet.net/atoms/sched.php
 
blevstone
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mrstickball
Blev - The issue is there is no perfect formula to how good/bad a team is. Opponent win/loss %, point differential, and other factors play a good part, but there are 1,000,000 things to determine the "best" team outside of the obvious teams.

I mean, what is a great team today, in 16 days could be a dud and vice versa...We'll see how these projections turn out on both my end, and Wolf's computer rankings (which are very good too).


Well, the big thing here is that a HUGE part of who wins in GLB in general is the overall ability of the players themselves which is largely ignored using this formula...that's really the biggest problem that I would have with it. It's a game realistically built upon statistical differences alot of which have to do with the teams themselves, so ignoring that part seems like a system doomed to fail.
 
agitator
offline
Link
 
anyone have an updated power ranking for the EAST?
 
Mrstickball
offline
Link
 
Not yet. Why not update those computer power rankings?
 
djfivenine
offline
Link
 
zzzz
 
nfratami
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mrstickball

Western Conference - #5. (tie) Red Deer Longhorns (#13 Ovr.)
Rather lackluster with their wins, they've won what they've had to this year, with a quality win over Pitt. However, although 5-win, they have a horrible rest of the year schedule with North Delta, Fort St. Johns, Montreal, Kensington and Thunder Bay in the East. My pick to be the "2007 Detroit Lions" of the West.



I look forward to proving you wrong.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.