User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #2 > Week 13 Predictions by WiSeIVIaN
Page:
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dustin Diamond
No, I am not trolling or using hyperbole. I simply have a somewhat different opinion than you. If there ever is some sort of play recognition, which I am not completely opposed to, it should certainly be tied to certain attributes like vision & maybe confidence. It should also not make up for a lack of AI preparation, which is my main point, the game itself should not make up for human error.


Show me in the AI where I can put in a setting to adjust to some guy running HB smash (or WR screen, or whatever) 20+ times in a game.

The best I can do is put in winning/losing scenarios and guess why it's happening beforehand.

Last edited Jan 29, 2009 08:31:28
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by Dustin Diamond

No, I am not trolling or using hyperbole. I simply have a somewhat different opinion than you. If there ever is some sort of play recognition, which I am not completely opposed to, it should certainly be tied to certain attributes like vision & maybe confidence. It should also not make up for a lack of AI preparation, which is my main point, the game itself should not make up for human error.


Show me in the AI where I can put in a setting to adjust to some guy running HB smash (or WR screen, or whatever) 20+ times in a game.

The best I can do is put in winning/losing scenarios and guess why it's happening beforehand.



I think we're coming to the same conclusion, but taking different routes to get there. Some of these "exploits" are because of plays that are overpowered, & some are because in the process of scouting an OC notices that a team always runs the same D against this look, & if I run this play they will never be able to stop it.

There isn't a lot to do about the overpowered plays, other than just hope to contain them & limit their success. What I am defending is finding a hole in an AI & taking advantage of it.
 
rj414
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dustin Diamond
Originally posted by kurieg

Originally posted by Dustin Diamond


No, I am not trolling or using hyperbole. I simply have a somewhat different opinion than you. If there ever is some sort of play recognition, which I am not completely opposed to, it should certainly be tied to certain attributes like vision & maybe confidence. It should also not make up for a lack of AI preparation, which is my main point, the game itself should not make up for human error.


Show me in the AI where I can put in a setting to adjust to some guy running HB smash (or WR screen, or whatever) 20+ times in a game.

The best I can do is put in winning/losing scenarios and guess why it's happening beforehand.



I think we're coming to the same conclusion, but taking different routes to get there. Some of these "exploits" are because of plays that are overpowered, & some are because in the process of scouting an OC notices that a team always runs the same D against this look, & if I run this play they will never be able to stop it.

There isn't a lot to do about the overpowered plays, other than just hope to contain them & limit their success. What I am defending is finding a hole in an AI & taking advantage of it.


I think both sides of this argument make an excellent point. From a realism standpoint - the simple fact is that no defense facing the same play 60 times in one game wouldn't adjust and read it. However, I also agree that the game should never make up for human error. That said - I don't think you'll find very often a situation where a team runs the same play over and over because they scout and see a weakness. The Bugeaters run the same play over and over because it seems to be the most effective play against all manner of defensive looks. I highly doubt that every defense they've played all season has been equally weak against the weak-I dive play, or now the HB Screen. They just choose to run that play because it's the hardest to stop based on Bort's code, and then after awhile people do come up with a look to stop it so they switch to their next gimmick.

At the end of the day, a team that is thinking strategically enough to identify a weakness will not identify just one play the defense is weak against, but a good set of a few plays and run those over and over again. Therefore I think that making the defense adjust to a play the more it's called, but also with a penalty built in to reading a different play out of the same formation if the previous play is called several times in a row, is actually the best option. This way if a team ran a play 60 times they would get justifiably fucked in the ass, but if they ran it a few times in a row to set the defense up and then went with another play, realism would be served when the defense didn't read it as quickly.
 
Jackhammer1
offline
Link
 
An excellent idea rj...on a side note who wants to do the over under on the odds that Bort will implement this idea if we all suggested it to him and the amount of time it took rj to come up with that eloquent argument
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rj414
Originally posted by Dustin Diamond

Originally posted by kurieg


Originally posted by Dustin Diamond



No, I am not trolling or using hyperbole. I simply have a somewhat different opinion than you. If there ever is some sort of play recognition, which I am not completely opposed to, it should certainly be tied to certain attributes like vision & maybe confidence. It should also not make up for a lack of AI preparation, which is my main point, the game itself should not make up for human error.


Show me in the AI where I can put in a setting to adjust to some guy running HB smash (or WR screen, or whatever) 20+ times in a game.

The best I can do is put in winning/losing scenarios and guess why it's happening beforehand.



I think we're coming to the same conclusion, but taking different routes to get there. Some of these "exploits" are because of plays that are overpowered, & some are because in the process of scouting an OC notices that a team always runs the same D against this look, & if I run this play they will never be able to stop it.

There isn't a lot to do about the overpowered plays, other than just hope to contain them & limit their success. What I am defending is finding a hole in an AI & taking advantage of it.


I think both sides of this argument make an excellent point. From a realism standpoint - the simple fact is that no defense facing the same play 60 times in one game wouldn't adjust and read it. However, I also agree that the game should never make up for human error. That said - I don't think you'll find very often a situation where a team runs the same play over and over because they scout and see a weakness. The Bugeaters run the same play over and over because it seems to be the most effective play against all manner of defensive looks. I highly doubt that every defense they've played all season has been equally weak against the weak-I dive play, or now the HB Screen. They just choose to run that play because it's the hardest to stop based on Bort's code, and then after awhile people do come up with a look to stop it so they switch to their next gimmick.

At the end of the day, a team that is thinking strategically enough to identify a weakness will not identify just one play the defense is weak against, but a good set of a few plays and run those over and over again. Therefore I think that making the defense adjust to a play the more it's called, but also with a penalty built in to reading a different play out of the same formation if the previous play is called several times in a row, is actually the best option. This way if a team ran a play 60 times they would get justifiably fucked in the ass, but if they ran it a few times in a row to set the defense up and then went with another play, realism would be served when the defense didn't read it as quickly.


ITT: Bullseye.
I wish you could have posted this a little earlier today.


 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.