It was not an excuse. It doesn't bother me to lose. Losing happens. What it is about is the predictability of the game. We have been on the flip side too. We have won close games at home in the same manner. It's not about the win or loss. It's about the game. And usually it comes down to the kicker. Let's look at some examples about what I'm talking about. We'll just use our games against the Caps even tho there are more. I don't want to spend all night doing this. So let's just look at these.
Our first game against the Caps last season we played in Pittsburgh. Caps lost that game by 3 points. During that game, the Caps made a 49.5 yard FG yet missed a 31.5 at the end of the game. Ok so let's just go with the whole nerves thing, kicker was nervous blah blah blah. He missed it and we were tied with under 2 minutes left. Yet with 25 seconds left, my kicker is able to come out with nerves of steel and make a 49.5 yarder to win?
Second game against the Caps in the playoffs doesn't count because we just played a bad game there. My offense sucked for that game, we lost by 7. This doesn't fall under the theory I have because like I said, my offense was just really bad. And it was only by a miracle we pulled within 7 during the second half (mostly off of defensive TDs and such). Sim didn't need a hard time to figure out who to have win here.
Now this season we play the Caps in Washington. Washington missed the 2 FG's they tried that game but they were 50.5 and 56 yard attempts. That is ok. That is realistic. Missing 50+ is normal (or at least should be). My kicker in that game made 48.5, 29, 39 and 42.5 yard FG's yet missed a 20.5 yarder. We lost that game by 2. And it shouldn't have even fallen under being tired or nerves because it was only the 2nd FG attempt he made in the game in the 1st quarter.
As a bonus, I'll even throw in the championship game we lost to the Nevada Fire in season 5. They were considered the home team. they tried 1 FG in the regular time of the game. It was 59.5 yards. Again, normal. 60 yard FG's should not be made or at least very very rare. My kicker in the game made FG's of 41 and 48.5 yards yet missed a 27 yarder. Again. Not tired or nerves. It was the very first kick he tried right at the start of the 2nd quarter. We ended up going to OT because of that missed kick. And in OT when nerves and such should be real high, they kick a 47 yarder to win it.
Do you see what I'm saying? Doesn't it seem a little odd? Like I said, it's not about the win or the loss since I showed we won because of the same thing. It's about the game. If the sim is going to give a game to the home during real close games and such, at least make it believable. Caps made a 49.5 but missed a 31.5? We made a 48.5, 29, 39 and 42.5 yet missed a 20.5? We made a 41 and a 48.5 yet missed a 27? I mean c'mon. Make it more believable. If the game is designed to do that at least make it so you miss the a real long FG. Not a chip shot. What the hell is the point in having the Automatic SA built up if you can kick long FG's all day long yet chip shots that are supposed to be "automatic" due to the SA get missed? That's stupid. Like I said, I have a problem with the game and the way it does things like that. Not by the win or loss themselves. If you are gonna add a "12th man" element to the game (not even sure if this is part of the game or reason why these things happen) make it more real with missing these last second real long FG's or just real long FG's in general. Not chip shots that are at the beginning of the game.
I hope I at least showed you guys why I said that. It wasn't to complain about losing to the Caps. It's about the game design. Like I showed in my first example, we won due to the same thing. It wasn't right then either. Granted, it's not an exact science as away teams have won close games (like our win at the Assassins), but it happens more than people may realize.
Our first game against the Caps last season we played in Pittsburgh. Caps lost that game by 3 points. During that game, the Caps made a 49.5 yard FG yet missed a 31.5 at the end of the game. Ok so let's just go with the whole nerves thing, kicker was nervous blah blah blah. He missed it and we were tied with under 2 minutes left. Yet with 25 seconds left, my kicker is able to come out with nerves of steel and make a 49.5 yarder to win?
Second game against the Caps in the playoffs doesn't count because we just played a bad game there. My offense sucked for that game, we lost by 7. This doesn't fall under the theory I have because like I said, my offense was just really bad. And it was only by a miracle we pulled within 7 during the second half (mostly off of defensive TDs and such). Sim didn't need a hard time to figure out who to have win here.
Now this season we play the Caps in Washington. Washington missed the 2 FG's they tried that game but they were 50.5 and 56 yard attempts. That is ok. That is realistic. Missing 50+ is normal (or at least should be). My kicker in that game made 48.5, 29, 39 and 42.5 yard FG's yet missed a 20.5 yarder. We lost that game by 2. And it shouldn't have even fallen under being tired or nerves because it was only the 2nd FG attempt he made in the game in the 1st quarter.
As a bonus, I'll even throw in the championship game we lost to the Nevada Fire in season 5. They were considered the home team. they tried 1 FG in the regular time of the game. It was 59.5 yards. Again, normal. 60 yard FG's should not be made or at least very very rare. My kicker in the game made FG's of 41 and 48.5 yards yet missed a 27 yarder. Again. Not tired or nerves. It was the very first kick he tried right at the start of the 2nd quarter. We ended up going to OT because of that missed kick. And in OT when nerves and such should be real high, they kick a 47 yarder to win it.
Do you see what I'm saying? Doesn't it seem a little odd? Like I said, it's not about the win or the loss since I showed we won because of the same thing. It's about the game. If the sim is going to give a game to the home during real close games and such, at least make it believable. Caps made a 49.5 but missed a 31.5? We made a 48.5, 29, 39 and 42.5 yet missed a 20.5? We made a 41 and a 48.5 yet missed a 27? I mean c'mon. Make it more believable. If the game is designed to do that at least make it so you miss the a real long FG. Not a chip shot. What the hell is the point in having the Automatic SA built up if you can kick long FG's all day long yet chip shots that are supposed to be "automatic" due to the SA get missed? That's stupid. Like I said, I have a problem with the game and the way it does things like that. Not by the win or loss themselves. If you are gonna add a "12th man" element to the game (not even sure if this is part of the game or reason why these things happen) make it more real with missing these last second real long FG's or just real long FG's in general. Not chip shots that are at the beginning of the game.
I hope I at least showed you guys why I said that. It wasn't to complain about losing to the Caps. It's about the game design. Like I showed in my first example, we won due to the same thing. It wasn't right then either. Granted, it's not an exact science as away teams have won close games (like our win at the Assassins), but it happens more than people may realize.
Last edited Jan 25, 2009 23:28:20






























