User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #2 > Why do I feel like Leon Spinks this season?
Page:
 
vladd148
offline
Link
 
Why do I feel like my HB is gimped this year? His production is so much lower and we were in the same competitive league as last year? I hate these new damn tactics + sim.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vladd148
Why do I feel like my HB is gimped this year? His production is so much lower and we were in the same competitive league as last year? I hate these new damn tactics + sim.


I feel the same way about my MLB. I've spent close to a million in new equipment, rebought a flex item to try and get him ungimped. He was a pretty decent force even with 9 def gen last season. Now? Well in coverage he's good. that's about it.
Last edited Jan 25, 2009 18:01:57
 
Veg
offline
Link
 
0 ints for my cb this season and they were plentiful every other season sooo -=PPPP
 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
Our defense was incredible last season and now we struggle at holding teams under 30 points
 
enoch101
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
[

I feel the same way about my MLB. I've spent close to a million in new equipment, rebought a flex item to try and get him


every De/Dt on the team probably has around 5 million in equipment lol
Last edited Jan 25, 2009 19:05:53
 
Zable
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by enoch101
Originally posted by islander1

[

I feel the same way about my MLB. I've spent close to a million in new equipment, rebought a flex item to try and get him


every De/Dt on the team probably has around 5 million in equipment lol


I think a few of us have had to re-tool equipment a few times just this year. Gets expensive for the owners. I just want a new reset for VA's... now that we have had almost a full season with them.. was hard to tell about some in just 1 game.

Last edited Jan 25, 2009 19:18:18
 
Spirer
offline
Link
 
Offense had a huge boost this season, especially the passing game. Most games have higher scores, because defense is struggling... Bort is fixing it a bit and making CBs "smarter", but WR still have a clear advantage. You see long bombs into double and triple coverage being caught at unreasonable rates...

1 - If you are an offensive player you just need to try and break the system, be it extreme STR or AGI or SPD, etc... if you are a defensive player you have to try and cater for all those possibilities, which makes life much harder

2 - The VAs for offense seem much better than those for defense

3 - Lots of PDs are being caught this season

4 - Ffumbles are on vacation

5 - Interceptions are hibernating

6 - Sacks are rumoured to be extinct

I find it funny that they are trying to make the stats more realistic, but sadly only on defense, offense still has totally bogus numbers.

If Bort wants this to be a simulation then there can be no STR 100 HBs, etc, because there are none in NFL, there can be no STR 8 players, for the same reason. Using unrealistic attributes to run a simulation attempting to represent reality is doomed to failure.

Until Bort codes some "proper" rules into the game, extreme broken builds will always prosper, rather than balanced, realistic ones, but he owns the game, so we can only watch

Apologies for venting some frustration, but since season 4 the game just seems to be going downhill for me... ah well, there is still hope.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
or rebalance them anyway, because right now at least there are a few clear choices - maybe 3-6 per player - that make sense. The rest that would be useful are pretty garbage and that is probably not what Bort wanted to see (all players using the same VAs)

PS: Rock on Spirer
Last edited Jan 25, 2009 19:25:43
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Spirer
Offense had a huge boost this season, especially the passing game. Most games have higher scores, because defense is struggling... Bort is fixing it a bit and making CBs "smarter", but WR still have a clear advantage. You see long bombs into double and triple coverage being caught at unreasonable rates...

1 - If you are an offensive player you just need to try and break the system, be it extreme STR or AGI or SPD, etc... if you are a defensive player you have to try and cater for all those possibilities, which makes life much harder

2 - The VAs for offense seem much better than those for defense

3 - Lots of PDs are being caught this season

4 - Ffumbles are on vacation

5 - Interceptions are hibernating

6 - Sacks are rumoured to be extinct

I find it funny that they are trying to make the stats more realistic, but sadly only on defense, offense still has totally bogus numbers.

If Bort wants this to be a simulation then there can be no STR 100 HBs, etc, because there are none in NFL, there can be no STR 8 players, for the same reason. Using unrealistic attributes to run a simulation attempting to represent reality is doomed to failure.

Until Bort codes some "proper" rules into the game, extreme broken builds will always prosper, rather than balanced, realistic ones, but he owns the game, so we can only watch

Apologies for venting some frustration, but since season 4 the game just seems to be going downhill for me... ah well, there is still hope.


It's my opinion that "extreme, broken builds" should be featured, though. I guess we can all sit around and debate at what point a build is extreme, but my point would be that offenses SHOULD attempt to feature some extreme types of skill players to try to get mismatches on the D. WRs that are stupidly fast, quick, or big are actually fine IMO.

The problem I have is the utter inability to pick matchups. That's the 800 lb gorilla in the room for defenses imo.

As for PDs turning into catches, I have a theory that Bort forgot to make catching a PD harder. I think a PD can redirect the ball in the WR catch radius, which then puts the ball at a different % to catch, but I don't think he put much or any direct penalty due to the ball path rapidly changing (reaction time, which should be mitigated by Vision imo.)

But that's just a theory.

 
whodey08
offline
Link
 
Its the matchups!!! I dont care if a HB has 150 strength and another HB has 150 speed. Let the defense recruit LB's that are strength/tackling focused and LB's that are speed/agility focused and have the option in the AI to say;

If HB#1 is in than LB#1 is in.
If HB#2 is in than LB#2 is in.

On 3rd and short you should be able to sub in your strength DT's for run stuff. If its 3rd and 10 you should be able to sub in your pass rushing DT's. Same for Wr's and so on.

You could have the same options in the offensive Ai as well. If your running you could sub in particular guards and tackles and if its a pass you culd sub in different guards and tackles.

There is no way defenses can stop all the different builds that are out right now. Even if you have the players to stop them....there is no way to assure that they will be in on any particular play
Last edited Jan 25, 2009 22:03:45
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
The custom DAI allows you to match up CB1 against WR1.

That's still worthless.
 
Spirer
offline
Link
 
The matchups is ofc a good idea, but still has serious problems:
1 - Defense will need 2-3 times the number of players offense needs
2 - Defense players will play half the snaps

What do you do with your powerback stopping LBs when you play a team that doesn't even run the ball? It just doesn't work in game mechanics. They need the snaps to get XP, but you are weaker if you field them against an elusive back or a pass team.

For this to be a simulation, players attributes would have to be realistic. One option would be for all players to start with 50 on every attribute and then you could customize it. Raising some attributes would lower others, etc.

Bort just needs to decide if this is a computer game or a simulation. Today we are stuck somewhere in between and it doesn't work very well.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Well, it could be a lot worse. To make this a true simulation, Bort would have to take a lot of options away from the end user. In the end, Bort sees this as a football MMORPG, much like World of Warcraft, Lord of the Rings Online, and Age of Conan.

This vision has never really changed, I dare say, from day 1.

What has changed is how this was implemented - insofar as how the game's grown to become more sim like (at the behest of the majority of players, not just owners). I don't think Bort gave much thought (or perhaps he couldn't have known) the game would develop as it has. Probably the latter. When you open up your game to tens of thousands of people to essentially try and break it, guess what happens.

I would never expect this game to be a true sim. However, I would continue to expect that the game will be modified and developed in that 'general direction'. Which is what the vast majority of people have voted for. For example, I know that Bort wants to implement injuries...however each time he talks of it he can't seem to figure out how to do it fairly - or maybe he's afraid of the reaction. Same with other penalties besides offsides(so to speak).

Although I can't honestly imagine it being sooo difficult to do - maybe it is.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.