Originally posted by morbo
Originally posted by DavidD458
As I said, ~13% was the NFL average.
Your google search was wrong. Wiki said that 2004 the average was 23%, but the source link (was to nfl.com) was broken due to a restructure. I went to nfl.com myself and counted the 2007 season onsides, they had a 25% success rate.
Heck, if onside kicks in GLB had a 25% chance of success they'd be tried every kick-off. I mean with the way kicker's distance on kick-offs has been "nerfed" teams already start most drives with great field position, usually 35+ yard line now. So, I'd have to agree with the chance of an onside kick succeeding being under 5%, around 3% would be ok. Just IMO.
Originally posted by DavidD458
As I said, ~13% was the NFL average.
Your google search was wrong. Wiki said that 2004 the average was 23%, but the source link (was to nfl.com) was broken due to a restructure. I went to nfl.com myself and counted the 2007 season onsides, they had a 25% success rate.
Heck, if onside kicks in GLB had a 25% chance of success they'd be tried every kick-off. I mean with the way kicker's distance on kick-offs has been "nerfed" teams already start most drives with great field position, usually 35+ yard line now. So, I'd have to agree with the chance of an onside kick succeeding being under 5%, around 3% would be ok. Just IMO.





























