User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > ITT: Necessary and indisputable fixes to GLB
Page:
 
Black Peter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by morbo
Originally posted by DavidD458

As I said, ~13% was the NFL average.


Your google search was wrong. Wiki said that 2004 the average was 23%, but the source link (was to nfl.com) was broken due to a restructure. I went to nfl.com myself and counted the 2007 season onsides, they had a 25% success rate.


Heck, if onside kicks in GLB had a 25% chance of success they'd be tried every kick-off. I mean with the way kicker's distance on kick-offs has been "nerfed" teams already start most drives with great field position, usually 35+ yard line now. So, I'd have to agree with the chance of an onside kick succeeding being under 5%, around 3% would be ok. Just IMO.
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
15% or so would seem fine.

I also liked the idea of 2 pt conversions but only when the difference in scores made it make a difference. Really only need to do it in 4 situations: (scores before the TD)

Down by 8 (2 pt conv to tie)
Down by 11 (2 pt conv to make it just a FG to tie)
Down by 1 (after the 6 you're up 5, so go for 2 to make it an even 7pt td lead)
Up by 2 (after the 6 you're up 8, so go for 2 to make it an even 10 pt lead)
 
RandomBeast
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
15% or so would seem fine.

I also liked the idea of 2 pt conversions but only when the difference in scores made it make a difference. Really only need to do it in 4 situations: (scores before the TD)

Down by 8 (2 pt conv to tie)
Down by 11 (2 pt conv to make it just a FG to tie)
Down by 1 (after the 6 you're up 5, so go for 2 to make it an even 7pt td lead)
Up by 2 (after the 6 you're up 8, so go for 2 to make it an even 10 pt lead)


If you are up 8 wouldn't you rather kick the 1 to go up 9 (two scores) than possibly only be up 8 and can be tied with the 2pt conversion in scenario 1?
 
Marion Who
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
This should be moved to suggestions, and then locked because all this stuff is epic, so Bort can get back to not even looking at that forum.


 
allstarpdc
offline
Link
 
Great list here. I really think the coverage issues & fumble SAs to take priority. Even the worst of a conference's QBs completing better than 60% of their passes is crazy. And FFs are MIA this season. The best teams in the NFL recover about 1 fumble/game...the worst still cause around .5/ game (google search) . My team is 10-0 & we've only forced 2 fumbles this season...even after playing 3 CPU teams. I've asked my D players to beef up Big Hit & Monster Hit for no reason now?
 
Zoblefu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by RandomBeast
Originally posted by Zoblefu

15% or so would seem fine.

I also liked the idea of 2 pt conversions but only when the difference in scores made it make a difference. Really only need to do it in 4 situations: (scores before the TD)

Down by 8 (2 pt conv to tie)
Down by 11 (2 pt conv to make it just a FG to tie)
Down by 1 (after the 6 you're up 5, so go for 2 to make it an even 7pt td lead)
Up by 2 (after the 6 you're up 8, so go for 2 to make it an even 10 pt lead)


If you are up 8 wouldn't you rather kick the 1 to go up 9 (two scores) than possibly only be up 8 and can be tied with the 2pt conversion in scenario 1?


Probably right. In any case, whether I can think of them in a couple minutes or not, there would only need to be 3-4 scenarios where you'd go for 2
 
Link
 
I think 10% is a good number to use for onside success rate. Just low enough so owners don't try it when there's no "real" reason to...just high enough so if you are losing late you actually have a shot at getting the ball back.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.