User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > More Penalties and the suggestion
Luckeroll
offline
Link
 
I think it is a consensus that a more variety of penalties will add to the game or game frustration.

My Idea to do this within what I think is the game engine might be complicated to read but should be simple to code (I think as a non coder)

Since this game is based on the NFL module (or trying to be) first number that needs to be have is the average amount of penalties called per game, detailed to the penalty. Then we will only need to have formulas based on the attributes we have to calculate the actual frequency in which certain penalties.

For Instance
Holding
Run Plays
1. Base Frequency will be "X" penalties called/ Total amount of running plays.
2. Take this percentage/frequency and change it to a roll amount base on the game engine
When the penalty is called
Granted this formula is off the top of my head but here goes.
Strength Difference + or - (this is the difference between you and the person engaged)
Agility Difference + or -
Confidence formula already instated in the game.

(SD + AD) + Con = Your role integer to the dice (haven't played RPG in a while so I forgot the term)

Example Guard A has Str 60 and Agi 30
DT B Has Str 50 and Agi 60
.
10+-30=-20
If the confidence at that time is high then the -20 will be reduced (go more positive).
If the confidence at that time is low then the -20 will increase (go more negative).

Change this to whatever scale Bort has the rolls on. And add it to the average roll

Let's say 10% (i know it is a high number) of running plays have holding. The roll scale is 100. You will need to roll a 11 not to hold.

Lets take the -20 and make it to a -2

Now on that play you need to roll a 13 not to hold.

I think that this is rough but can be used a base for penalties like PI, unnecessary roughness, etc. Also if that individual player is getting drilled, pancaked, burnt, the likelihood of a penalty will increase based on Bort's confidence scale.
 
Link
 
I really like this

edit: what about penalties like clipping(in reference to the constant triple teams of nt's), ineligable man down field(punts/screen plays),
Last edited Jan 8, 2009 08:51:25
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jared

edit: what about penalties like clipping(in reference to the constant triple teams of nt's), ineligable man down field(punts/screen plays),


Has nothing to do with getting triple teamed itself...
 
Link
 
you're right it doesn't but I'm willing to bet that at least 1/10 times one man goes high and one man goes low, which constitutes the clipping penalty
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jared
you're right it doesn't but I'm willing to bet that at least 1/10 times one man goes high and one man goes low, which constitutes the clipping penalty


If they did, the NT would be getting knocked down a lot more often
 
Luckeroll
offline
Link
 
You can add more penalties but it would be easier to start with the base (easier penalties to call). Clipping is would be a bitch when the game is based on numbers. The actual formula would be Vision heavy then agility.
 
Luckeroll
offline
Link
 
Anyways they never call clipping on a NT/DT. The NFL does not care about them. Hell they finally call chop block once every blue moon
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Luckeroll
Anyways they never call clipping on a NT/DT. The NFL does not care about them. Hell they finally call chop block once every blue moon


no they call it one the olineman
 
dmfa41
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I think they were going to have vision/confidence checks not to commit penalties. I think I remember this was supposed to be brand-new for Season 5?
 
Luckeroll
offline
Link
 
Of course there should be a vision confidence check on penalties. but most penalties is because of the physical first, then mental breakdown. That is why I wanted Bort's confidence multiplier included. I have know clue on the actual formula but since it is there might as well use it
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dmfa41
Yeah, I think they were going to have vision/confidence checks not to commit penalties. I think I remember this was supposed to be brand-new for Season 5?


Yep, after he implemented injuries in season 4, penalties were the next big thing.

Wait...
 
Luckeroll
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by dmfa41

Yeah, I think they were going to have vision/confidence checks not to commit penalties. I think I remember this was supposed to be brand-new for Season 5?


Yep, after he implemented injuries in season 4, penalties were the next big thing.

Wait...


LOL


There is another post about how to bring in injuries but nobody post on it really.

Maybe just maybe there should be an update so we do not waste our time talking about this. Otherwise continue to waste.
 
Luckeroll
offline
Link
 
bump
 
Luckeroll
offline
Link
 
b
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
I want all of the penalties added - that way players have a better idea on what attributes/skills they need to compensate.. what good does it do for people to finally think they've got the hang of creating a Players - if we are still adding major components to the Sim in Season 10, 12, or 100?
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.