Originally posted by GMathiasf
Originally posted by oakland360
Originally posted by GMathiasf
Based completely on "stats" would be easier to just use the pbr Pro-bowl scout, though these are pretty close. Coincidently, McDragon scores a 473 while MTP scores a 513 since we're looking at things solely from a statistical perspective.
The point you're failing to mention is that they're in two separate conferences. Meaning that they should both be in the pro-bowl. It'd be a different scenario if we were talking about an All-Pro list. Which is what Mgoods format is, even though he calls it a Pro Bowl. Pro Bowl that is not. Sorry just isn't.
And I'll admit I might be a little bit biased in my assesments. Though I tried to be as unbiased as possible. Some of the players listed made it because of factors not listed in stats. Which I'll explain when I do the write up tonight. Love having a job where I get to tell people what to do, and play on the cpu doing nothing myself. God I love running my uncles restaurant.
I know. Did I say he shouldn't be on there? I was just pointing out that there was a statistical analysis script already written and easily accessible and that Tails scores significantly higher on it...no bias, just "facts"
Never seen or heard of this script your talking about. And to be honest, I trust my analysis more than some generic script. But that's neither here nor there. But why are you even bringing that subject up here. Different thread. And I already left that subject alone. You should try to do the same. Agree to disagree ya know. Either that or stop wasting my time. I'm not even trying to compare the two any longer. It's a waste of my energy. I'm going to believe what I believe and the same can be said of everyone else and their own opinions. So please don't bring that up again. I'm over and done with that subject.
Originally posted by oakland360
Originally posted by GMathiasf
Based completely on "stats" would be easier to just use the pbr Pro-bowl scout, though these are pretty close. Coincidently, McDragon scores a 473 while MTP scores a 513 since we're looking at things solely from a statistical perspective.
The point you're failing to mention is that they're in two separate conferences. Meaning that they should both be in the pro-bowl. It'd be a different scenario if we were talking about an All-Pro list. Which is what Mgoods format is, even though he calls it a Pro Bowl. Pro Bowl that is not. Sorry just isn't.
And I'll admit I might be a little bit biased in my assesments. Though I tried to be as unbiased as possible. Some of the players listed made it because of factors not listed in stats. Which I'll explain when I do the write up tonight. Love having a job where I get to tell people what to do, and play on the cpu doing nothing myself. God I love running my uncles restaurant.
I know. Did I say he shouldn't be on there? I was just pointing out that there was a statistical analysis script already written and easily accessible and that Tails scores significantly higher on it...no bias, just "facts"
Never seen or heard of this script your talking about. And to be honest, I trust my analysis more than some generic script. But that's neither here nor there. But why are you even bringing that subject up here. Different thread. And I already left that subject alone. You should try to do the same. Agree to disagree ya know. Either that or stop wasting my time. I'm not even trying to compare the two any longer. It's a waste of my energy. I'm going to believe what I believe and the same can be said of everyone else and their own opinions. So please don't bring that up again. I'm over and done with that subject.
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 23:10:59






























