Agents have to weigh their hate for me against their desire for championships.
refguru
offline
offline
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
The reason recruiting is broken has absolutely nothing to do with money or the number of teams added. Rather it has to do with the fact that all teams go uncapped at a certain point then all go after the same highest level players.
Its not that FA's only care about money or don't care about record, but rather you need to agree on those things while separating yourself from the pack in other ways to even get a free agent interested in your team.
So many owners out there send out 1000 offers with a 10 word PM, and then they get pissed off and blame player greed when it reality each highest level player gets 150+ offers some of which from people who do a pretty good job of relating to and convincing players to join their squad.
So again, the problem is that 90% of teams can go after the same level 42 WR. Cash or player demands have nothing to do with it. At any rate once your at these high levels player salary demands really don't mater as you just end up complimenting his salary with a shitload of equipment money anyhow. Bigger daily salary means less equipment bonus but the same amount of money lost overall...
If your team is extremely good you need to write a fantastic PM to have a chance at a player whos agent you don't already know. If your team is bad, you better be blowing said players' minds with your vision for the team, why you'll get players together, tactics, drive, favorite kind of ice cream, ect... I'm not saying you do this, but so many agents just send out 100's of contract offers with no PM. Why would an agent sign with a team who gives out blind offers when other teams are actually contacting them and sharing info about their team?
All IMO of course.
With all due respect, you're wrong.
Most PMs don't even get read and those that do don't get replied to. I do agree about level caps for every level. There is a BBB league I just saw that outlevels Indy. TO me, that is not BBB. In fact, I'd go as far as to make it a rule that even your own players can only be so high over the level cap before contract terminated and they go FA. So if an A league's level cap is say 28 and it gets raised to 32 at mid-season and you don't move up--it goes back to 28. Existing players may not be higher than say five levels higher than cap or they get cut. Sure there would be some bitching, but they'd work with it. That's what you get for signing your lvel 37 in a BBB league. Also should be salary caps for players at every level and every league.
The reason recruiting is broken has absolutely nothing to do with money or the number of teams added. Rather it has to do with the fact that all teams go uncapped at a certain point then all go after the same highest level players.
Its not that FA's only care about money or don't care about record, but rather you need to agree on those things while separating yourself from the pack in other ways to even get a free agent interested in your team.
So many owners out there send out 1000 offers with a 10 word PM, and then they get pissed off and blame player greed when it reality each highest level player gets 150+ offers some of which from people who do a pretty good job of relating to and convincing players to join their squad.
So again, the problem is that 90% of teams can go after the same level 42 WR. Cash or player demands have nothing to do with it. At any rate once your at these high levels player salary demands really don't mater as you just end up complimenting his salary with a shitload of equipment money anyhow. Bigger daily salary means less equipment bonus but the same amount of money lost overall...
If your team is extremely good you need to write a fantastic PM to have a chance at a player whos agent you don't already know. If your team is bad, you better be blowing said players' minds with your vision for the team, why you'll get players together, tactics, drive, favorite kind of ice cream, ect... I'm not saying you do this, but so many agents just send out 100's of contract offers with no PM. Why would an agent sign with a team who gives out blind offers when other teams are actually contacting them and sharing info about their team?
All IMO of course.

With all due respect, you're wrong.
Most PMs don't even get read and those that do don't get replied to. I do agree about level caps for every level. There is a BBB league I just saw that outlevels Indy. TO me, that is not BBB. In fact, I'd go as far as to make it a rule that even your own players can only be so high over the level cap before contract terminated and they go FA. So if an A league's level cap is say 28 and it gets raised to 32 at mid-season and you don't move up--it goes back to 28. Existing players may not be higher than say five levels higher than cap or they get cut. Sure there would be some bitching, but they'd work with it. That's what you get for signing your lvel 37 in a BBB league. Also should be salary caps for players at every level and every league.
thunderdoozer
offline
offline
I agree that a salary cap for lower leagues could help. But it would have to be a pretty liberal cap, like $5000/day. This is high, but it would keep BBB and A teams from offering SUPER outrageous contracts, without screwing them over entirely.
I don't like a hard cap idea, but I think soft caps like we have are good, they just need to be permanent (and ever-changing based upon the actual player levels in GLB). Hard caps could cause too many problems for the player market, and to make the caps right so that every player could find a home would be nearly impossible.
I've suggested several times that there should be a parallel farm system for the first 3 seasons of a player's career. After 3 seasons (when the player is about level 28), their growth has slowed, and they are ready for the "real" leagues. This kind of system would keep the current leagues at consistently high levels while making room for noobs to gain XP. This would indirectly help recruiting because newly uncapped leagues would not continuously flood the market with offers. The new teams would be in the farm league.
I actually think a lot of people would be interested in running these "college" leagues, because at that level recruiting can be fun, and Bort would be able to experiment with an NCAA championship format.
I don't like a hard cap idea, but I think soft caps like we have are good, they just need to be permanent (and ever-changing based upon the actual player levels in GLB). Hard caps could cause too many problems for the player market, and to make the caps right so that every player could find a home would be nearly impossible.
I've suggested several times that there should be a parallel farm system for the first 3 seasons of a player's career. After 3 seasons (when the player is about level 28), their growth has slowed, and they are ready for the "real" leagues. This kind of system would keep the current leagues at consistently high levels while making room for noobs to gain XP. This would indirectly help recruiting because newly uncapped leagues would not continuously flood the market with offers. The new teams would be in the farm league.
I actually think a lot of people would be interested in running these "college" leagues, because at that level recruiting can be fun, and Bort would be able to experiment with an NCAA championship format.
Last edited Nov 26, 2008 13:37:25
islander1
offline
offline
Originally posted by pat2007
Predictions:
Washington Wolfpack vs Footstar Heroes NYC (30-18) Spread: 12
I hope the Heores make it that close, but it will more look like the OFG game for Footstar.
Team: Good Margin: Close, but Not Good
We covered the spread! Wooooooo!
Predictions:
Washington Wolfpack vs Footstar Heroes NYC (30-18) Spread: 12
I hope the Heores make it that close, but it will more look like the OFG game for Footstar.
Team: Good Margin: Close, but Not Good
We covered the spread! Wooooooo!

WiSeIVIaN
offline
offline
---Free Agents---
Well ref, I would like to thank you for all the due respect, but I am absolutely not wrong.
The reason a lot of PMs don't get read is two fold and are the result of too many leagues being uncapped and going after the same players.
1. Said player in the offseason is getting 100+ PMs and alot of them are getting bumped out of his inbox.
2. When you get that many messages, rather than reading through all of them (an almost impossible task with more constantly coming in) a lot of agents will read PMs until a team hits home with then, after which they will simply accept an offer rather than reading the other million PMs.
I can 110% guarantee PMs aren't going unread/unreplied to because agents become free agents then pick the biggest contract offered. Try offering free agents the max contract as I'm positive that it won't get you anywhere at all.
Furthermore, if you got 150 PMs for your free agent player and was scrambling for a team would you really take the time to reply to the teams that didn't interest you? I know in theory one would say "I'd say thanks for the offer but I'm not interested" or whatever that bullshit is, but in reality it'd take way too much time. Not to mention that if you reply to someone even to say your not interested, its a given that they will reply to you back with a comment or try to change your mind. This'll lead to even more PMs for free agents and a bigger cluster-fuck when they have too many teams to choose from to begin with. Because there are too many uncapped teams. If a player reads your PM and doesn't reply, its safe to say that he was not impressed.
Both of these are the result of too many teams going after the same players. If you go after a player who's 10 levels below the highest level people I am positive that your PM will be read. I had a complete monster of a level 25 DE (productive as can be, fantastic build) who was a free agent this off-season. But since every freshly uncapped team goes out and trys to get those level 38 free agents, I got a total of 6 PMs from owners and 2 that showed some sort of intelligent thought. Barely anyone goes hard after the mid-level guys and all rather want their new level 40 DE who's gonna upgrade their roster.
So since your someone who's never had a high level free agent to have any idea the pressure/interest one gets, I can safely say that you do not have any idea what your talking about. With all due respect of course my friend.
---Level Caps---
In order to go with level caps (hard or soft) there need to be more than 5 "levels" (pro-aaa-aa-a-bbb) since eventually players are gonna top out around level 60. So we're talking about even with perfect parity (which is unachievable) there is still a given 10 level difference in given league which is way too much before maybe the level 45-55 gap to have any sort of real parity...
---Salary Cap---
The idea of a salary cap is worthless unless you get rid of the equipment fund, and if you got rid of the equipment fund player salaries would have to be MUCH higher than they are right now. As it stands any player making less than $10,000 (which I beleive is every player) doesn't even make enough contract cash in an entire season for 1 level 40 equipment upgrade.
So as it stands you end up giving players a crapload of extra money anyhow for equipment, it really doesn't make one once of difference if players make $4500/day ($180,000/year) or $9000/day ($360,000/year) because they are going to need 800k for level 32 upgrades and 1.6m for level 40 upgrades. Even the max contract size is so small in relation to the amount of money the player will be needing total that any max stadium team who crys about contract size is completely off base.
Not to mention that of all the players I've ever signed not one has cared one bit about their daily salary. Money wise players just want to be assured that all equipment and training will be paid for and then the money aspect is taken care of. But if they want the max daily salary who really cares...
/rant
And yes, I know I have a ranting problem, but don't worry I'm getting help...
Well ref, I would like to thank you for all the due respect, but I am absolutely not wrong.
The reason a lot of PMs don't get read is two fold and are the result of too many leagues being uncapped and going after the same players.
1. Said player in the offseason is getting 100+ PMs and alot of them are getting bumped out of his inbox.
2. When you get that many messages, rather than reading through all of them (an almost impossible task with more constantly coming in) a lot of agents will read PMs until a team hits home with then, after which they will simply accept an offer rather than reading the other million PMs.
I can 110% guarantee PMs aren't going unread/unreplied to because agents become free agents then pick the biggest contract offered. Try offering free agents the max contract as I'm positive that it won't get you anywhere at all.
Furthermore, if you got 150 PMs for your free agent player and was scrambling for a team would you really take the time to reply to the teams that didn't interest you? I know in theory one would say "I'd say thanks for the offer but I'm not interested" or whatever that bullshit is, but in reality it'd take way too much time. Not to mention that if you reply to someone even to say your not interested, its a given that they will reply to you back with a comment or try to change your mind. This'll lead to even more PMs for free agents and a bigger cluster-fuck when they have too many teams to choose from to begin with. Because there are too many uncapped teams. If a player reads your PM and doesn't reply, its safe to say that he was not impressed.
Both of these are the result of too many teams going after the same players. If you go after a player who's 10 levels below the highest level people I am positive that your PM will be read. I had a complete monster of a level 25 DE (productive as can be, fantastic build) who was a free agent this off-season. But since every freshly uncapped team goes out and trys to get those level 38 free agents, I got a total of 6 PMs from owners and 2 that showed some sort of intelligent thought. Barely anyone goes hard after the mid-level guys and all rather want their new level 40 DE who's gonna upgrade their roster.
So since your someone who's never had a high level free agent to have any idea the pressure/interest one gets, I can safely say that you do not have any idea what your talking about. With all due respect of course my friend.
---Level Caps---
In order to go with level caps (hard or soft) there need to be more than 5 "levels" (pro-aaa-aa-a-bbb) since eventually players are gonna top out around level 60. So we're talking about even with perfect parity (which is unachievable) there is still a given 10 level difference in given league which is way too much before maybe the level 45-55 gap to have any sort of real parity...
---Salary Cap---
The idea of a salary cap is worthless unless you get rid of the equipment fund, and if you got rid of the equipment fund player salaries would have to be MUCH higher than they are right now. As it stands any player making less than $10,000 (which I beleive is every player) doesn't even make enough contract cash in an entire season for 1 level 40 equipment upgrade.
So as it stands you end up giving players a crapload of extra money anyhow for equipment, it really doesn't make one once of difference if players make $4500/day ($180,000/year) or $9000/day ($360,000/year) because they are going to need 800k for level 32 upgrades and 1.6m for level 40 upgrades. Even the max contract size is so small in relation to the amount of money the player will be needing total that any max stadium team who crys about contract size is completely off base.
Not to mention that of all the players I've ever signed not one has cared one bit about their daily salary. Money wise players just want to be assured that all equipment and training will be paid for and then the money aspect is taken care of. But if they want the max daily salary who really cares...
/rant
And yes, I know I have a ranting problem, but don't worry I'm getting help...
baumusc
offline
offline
Originally posted by refguru
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
The reason recruiting is broken has absolutely nothing to do with money or the number of teams added. Rather it has to do with the fact that all teams go uncapped at a certain point then all go after the same highest level players.
Its not that FA's only care about money or don't care about record, but rather you need to agree on those things while separating yourself from the pack in other ways to even get a free agent interested in your team.
So many owners out there send out 1000 offers with a 10 word PM, and then they get pissed off and blame player greed when it reality each highest level player gets 150+ offers some of which from people who do a pretty good job of relating to and convincing players to join their squad.
So again, the problem is that 90% of teams can go after the same level 42 WR. Cash or player demands have nothing to do with it. At any rate once your at these high levels player salary demands really don't mater as you just end up complimenting his salary with a shitload of equipment money anyhow. Bigger daily salary means less equipment bonus but the same amount of money lost overall...
If your team is extremely good you need to write a fantastic PM to have a chance at a player whos agent you don't already know. If your team is bad, you better be blowing said players' minds with your vision for the team, why you'll get players together, tactics, drive, favorite kind of ice cream, ect... I'm not saying you do this, but so many agents just send out 100's of contract offers with no PM. Why would an agent sign with a team who gives out blind offers when other teams are actually contacting them and sharing info about their team?
All IMO of course.
With all due respect, you're wrong.
Most PMs don't even get read and those that do don't get replied to. I do agree about level caps for every level. There is a BBB league I just saw that outlevels Indy. TO me, that is not BBB. In fact, I'd go as far as to make it a rule that even your own players can only be so high over the level cap before contract terminated and they go FA. So if an A league's level cap is say 28 and it gets raised to 32 at mid-season and you don't move up--it goes back to 28. Existing players may not be higher than say five levels higher than cap or they get cut. Sure there would be some bitching, but they'd work with it. That's what you get for signing your lvel 37 in a BBB league. Also should be salary caps for players at every level and every league.
Having tried to recruit in USA AAA, WE AAA and EE AA I have to say that us in the USA leagues have it easy when recruiting compared to other leagues. For whatever reason the majority of players want to be in a USA league and being in a USA AAA or Pro league really helps make recruiting that much easier.
I totally agree with you about the salary caps, Pro league players should be able to make a lot more than BBB players.
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
The reason recruiting is broken has absolutely nothing to do with money or the number of teams added. Rather it has to do with the fact that all teams go uncapped at a certain point then all go after the same highest level players.
Its not that FA's only care about money or don't care about record, but rather you need to agree on those things while separating yourself from the pack in other ways to even get a free agent interested in your team.
So many owners out there send out 1000 offers with a 10 word PM, and then they get pissed off and blame player greed when it reality each highest level player gets 150+ offers some of which from people who do a pretty good job of relating to and convincing players to join their squad.
So again, the problem is that 90% of teams can go after the same level 42 WR. Cash or player demands have nothing to do with it. At any rate once your at these high levels player salary demands really don't mater as you just end up complimenting his salary with a shitload of equipment money anyhow. Bigger daily salary means less equipment bonus but the same amount of money lost overall...
If your team is extremely good you need to write a fantastic PM to have a chance at a player whos agent you don't already know. If your team is bad, you better be blowing said players' minds with your vision for the team, why you'll get players together, tactics, drive, favorite kind of ice cream, ect... I'm not saying you do this, but so many agents just send out 100's of contract offers with no PM. Why would an agent sign with a team who gives out blind offers when other teams are actually contacting them and sharing info about their team?
All IMO of course.

With all due respect, you're wrong.
Most PMs don't even get read and those that do don't get replied to. I do agree about level caps for every level. There is a BBB league I just saw that outlevels Indy. TO me, that is not BBB. In fact, I'd go as far as to make it a rule that even your own players can only be so high over the level cap before contract terminated and they go FA. So if an A league's level cap is say 28 and it gets raised to 32 at mid-season and you don't move up--it goes back to 28. Existing players may not be higher than say five levels higher than cap or they get cut. Sure there would be some bitching, but they'd work with it. That's what you get for signing your lvel 37 in a BBB league. Also should be salary caps for players at every level and every league.
Having tried to recruit in USA AAA, WE AAA and EE AA I have to say that us in the USA leagues have it easy when recruiting compared to other leagues. For whatever reason the majority of players want to be in a USA league and being in a USA AAA or Pro league really helps make recruiting that much easier.
I totally agree with you about the salary caps, Pro league players should be able to make a lot more than BBB players.
thunderdoozer
offline
offline
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
-
---Salary Cap---
The idea of a salary cap is worthless unless you get rid of the equipment fund, and if you got rid of the equipment fund player salaries would have to be MUCH higher than they are right now. As it stands any player making less than $10,000 (which I beleive is every player) doesn't even make enough contract cash in an entire season for 1 level 40 equipment upgrade.
So as it stands you end up giving players a crapload of extra money anyhow for equipment, it really doesn't make one once of difference if players make $4500/day ($180,000/year) or $9000/day ($360,000/year) because they are going to need 800k for level 32 upgrades and 1.6m for level 40 upgrades. Even the max contract size is so small in relation to the amount of money the player will be needing total that any max stadium team who crys about contract size is completely off base.
That's why the ticket prices et al should be MUCH more steeply graded by level. It shouldn't be easy to get equipment upgrades in lower leagues.
... or there should be extra bonuses available to players in higher leagues.
-
---Salary Cap---
The idea of a salary cap is worthless unless you get rid of the equipment fund, and if you got rid of the equipment fund player salaries would have to be MUCH higher than they are right now. As it stands any player making less than $10,000 (which I beleive is every player) doesn't even make enough contract cash in an entire season for 1 level 40 equipment upgrade.
So as it stands you end up giving players a crapload of extra money anyhow for equipment, it really doesn't make one once of difference if players make $4500/day ($180,000/year) or $9000/day ($360,000/year) because they are going to need 800k for level 32 upgrades and 1.6m for level 40 upgrades. Even the max contract size is so small in relation to the amount of money the player will be needing total that any max stadium team who crys about contract size is completely off base.
That's why the ticket prices et al should be MUCH more steeply graded by level. It shouldn't be easy to get equipment upgrades in lower leagues.
... or there should be extra bonuses available to players in higher leagues.
Last edited Nov 26, 2008 15:01:48
WiSeIVIaN
offline
offline
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
-
---Salary Cap---
The idea of a salary cap is worthless unless you get rid of the equipment fund, and if you got rid of the equipment fund player salaries would have to be MUCH higher than they are right now. As it stands any player making less than $10,000 (which I beleive is every player) doesn't even make enough contract cash in an entire season for 1 level 40 equipment upgrade.
So as it stands you end up giving players a crapload of extra money anyhow for equipment, it really doesn't make one once of difference if players make $4500/day ($180,000/year) or $9000/day ($360,000/year) because they are going to need 800k for level 32 upgrades and 1.6m for level 40 upgrades. Even the max contract size is so small in relation to the amount of money the player will be needing total that any max stadium team who crys about contract size is completely off base.
That's why the ticket prices et al should be MUCH more steeply graded by level. It shouldn't be easy to get equipment upgrades in lower leagues.
... or there should be extra bonuses available to players in higher leagues.
Agreed.
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
-
---Salary Cap---
The idea of a salary cap is worthless unless you get rid of the equipment fund, and if you got rid of the equipment fund player salaries would have to be MUCH higher than they are right now. As it stands any player making less than $10,000 (which I beleive is every player) doesn't even make enough contract cash in an entire season for 1 level 40 equipment upgrade.
So as it stands you end up giving players a crapload of extra money anyhow for equipment, it really doesn't make one once of difference if players make $4500/day ($180,000/year) or $9000/day ($360,000/year) because they are going to need 800k for level 32 upgrades and 1.6m for level 40 upgrades. Even the max contract size is so small in relation to the amount of money the player will be needing total that any max stadium team who crys about contract size is completely off base.
That's why the ticket prices et al should be MUCH more steeply graded by level. It shouldn't be easy to get equipment upgrades in lower leagues.
... or there should be extra bonuses available to players in higher leagues.
Agreed.
refguru
offline
offline
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
---Free Agents---
So since your someone who's never had a high level free agent to have any idea the pressure/interest one gets, I can safely say that you do not have any idea what your talking about. With all due respect of course my friend.
What a crock of shit.
You can't reason with an irrational person.
You have no idea how many high level players I've had. Don't feel too safe.
---Free Agents---
So since your someone who's never had a high level free agent to have any idea the pressure/interest one gets, I can safely say that you do not have any idea what your talking about. With all due respect of course my friend.
What a crock of shit.
You can't reason with an irrational person.
You have no idea how many high level players I've had. Don't feel too safe.
Last edited Nov 26, 2008 22:38:32
Track6Track7
offline
offline
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Agents have to weigh their hate for me against their desire for championships.
I hate to encourage this type of behavior/let down the curtain, but there's definitely something to be said for maintaining a forum presence that FAs might recognize.
Agents have to weigh their hate for me against their desire for championships.
I hate to encourage this type of behavior/let down the curtain, but there's definitely something to be said for maintaining a forum presence that FAs might recognize.
grooveskipinc
offline
offline
Originally posted by Track6Track7
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Agents have to weigh their hate for me against their desire for championships.
I hate to encourage this type of behavior/let down the curtain, but there's definitely something to be said for maintaining a forum presence that FAs might recognize.
/humphumphump
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Agents have to weigh their hate for me against their desire for championships.
I hate to encourage this type of behavior/let down the curtain, but there's definitely something to be said for maintaining a forum presence that FAs might recognize.
/humphumphump
WiSeIVIaN
offline
offline
Originally posted by refguru
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
---Free Agents---
So since your someone who's never had a high level free agent to have any idea the pressure/interest one gets, I can safely say that you do not have any idea what your talking about. With all due respect of course my friend.
What a crock of shit.
You can't reason with an irrational person.
You have no idea how many high level players I've had. Don't feel too safe.
No disrespect meant here buddy, we're just having a friendly convo.
My perhaps faulty assumption was that you haven't retired any players. If that's true, your only high level player has been on the same team throughout his career...
GL with the rest of your season.
Originally posted by WiSeIVIaN
---Free Agents---
So since your someone who's never had a high level free agent to have any idea the pressure/interest one gets, I can safely say that you do not have any idea what your talking about. With all due respect of course my friend.
What a crock of shit.
You can't reason with an irrational person.
You have no idea how many high level players I've had. Don't feel too safe.
No disrespect meant here buddy, we're just having a friendly convo.

My perhaps faulty assumption was that you haven't retired any players. If that's true, your only high level player has been on the same team throughout his career...
GL with the rest of your season.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 01:08:53
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.



























