User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AA Leagues > USA AA #2 > USA AA #2 - OFFICIAL Pro Bowl Roster
Page:
 
snowmonkey
offline
Link
 
congrats to everyone
 
Link
 
Thanks to everyone who sent in a vote for Jug. I appreciate it guys.
 
Fred Dean
offline
Link
 
Congrats to everyone...and thanks to the folks for putting this together.......
 
avwjase
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Craelath
Originally posted by powerwingman

Originally posted by Craelath


Some of these absolutely scare me. Like the corner with 118 tackles. That, imo, should be an automatic disqualification. You're telling me those aren't completions against him? That's not exactly "the best".


Well, the votes came from eight owners who more than likely watched at least one game of these players. If they scout as heavily as we do, they they probably watched 4-5 games of each player's team. I'm pretty sure the people with the most informed opinion on the matter picked the teams. Are they perfect? Probably not. LB's for instance were all over the map and no LB really got a "majority" of the votes. There was really no clear cut #1 guy. So, I can see some people having issue with the LB's because there were wildly different opinions on those. Same with the 2nd team WR's and RB's. Some of the OLine positions were pretty tight races as well. The D-Line and CB's though were clear cut. When it comes to CB I think every ballot had Hennessey N RedBull on there. So, the people have spoken on that front.


This might be the case, but here's food for thought. Assuming, and I haven't charted a single game of his so this isn't 100% accurate, he wasn't thrown at any more than the 174 plays listed here, he comes out with a score of -462.33 in the coverage sheet I use. That's absolutely atrocious, and while some of the tackles will be from someone else, I also figured in him giving up 116 catches for zero yards. Add those figures in, along with incomplete passes against, and it gets even worse. Just to put it in perspective, running the same thing with Ray Long comes out with a score of -61.52, which looks awful still on a scale to 100, but when you throw a season's worth of stats in, it makes people look worse than they really are. The gap, though, is definitely clear.


I based most of my votes on a combination of stats and how they did vs my team. In the end, it's hard to pick out the best LB, OL & DB's because their stats are so misleading. An OL could be a pancake machine but can't pass block to save his life. I know our leading OL in pancakes is, at best, our third best OL IMO. But I watch all of our games and I know who's giving up sacks and who can roll out and pick up the LB to get us a big gain on outside runs. It's not our pancake machine.

Likewise, our leading CB in INT's was hardly our best CB. In fact, he gave up the first 13 completions against Columbus and it was a recurring theme all season long. But I don't expect other people to know this stuff because they don't watch our games. Just like I don't watch all of their's. So, you're really fighting a losing battle here. People have to vote on this stuff based on stats becauyse watching a 1,000 games to scout each individual player isn't going to happen.

I do think a "thrown at" stat for CB's with a completion rate would be nice. Maybe even total yards given up on passing plays. All would be good indicators.
 
konan83
offline
Link
 
thanks for voting my player in the pro bowl


thanks


kk
 
DaRealest
offline
Link
 
Good job!

Stained Leggler is actually one of the best, if not THE BEST, punter in the league, though.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.