User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Southeast Asia AAA Leagues > Southeast Asia AAA #1 > Let's do the MVP/Pro Bowl/All Pro thing like the Pro leagues
Page:
 
creeker22
offline
Link
 
I say Topdog and Shut Downs are 2 of the top CBs in Alpha. They have shut down almost every team this season and they both rack up the PDs and INTs which is the key stats for a CB. And tackles aren't always a bad thing for a CB when they are playing 80 plays a game IMHO.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by shadow46x2
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

I'm sorry guy, but I don't let that much through, no one does

Really though, where is shadow getting his info from? The other top CB's might have a little fewer tackles than me but look at all their missed tackles, I only have 2 missed tackles.


hmmm...not to take anything away from willis, because he is a solid CB, as are a lot of p-funk players....but, i can name a CB, off the top of my head, that has just as few missed tackles(2, to match your 2), and a shitton fewer tackles as well....i remember doing the match about mid-season, and most of this CB's tackles were from picking up tackles on other teammate's marks as well...the only thing that willis has over him is more picks...

sadly, in all fairness, the CB position is hard to evaluate in general...low tackles is a key number, imo, but it's a double edged sword...it either means they're covering their player well enough that the QB can't pass to them....or it means they're not in position to make the tackle after a catch...

interceptions is hard to read as well, because it's either, the guy was open enough to have a ball thrown to him, or the CB is quick enough to move to where the pass is...

honestly, CB evaluation is probably one of the hardest spots to properly judge....

--j



And I agree with this whole post. I don't even know how many of my tackles were from running plays or someone elses cover. I've been trying to get a new stat, suggested a few times on the suggestions forums, "targeted" so this way you can have a slight more advatage to telling this things but due to zone coverage and other coding issues, it would probably never come to light.
 
SportsFrk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by creeker22
I say Topdog and Shut Downs are 2 of the top CBs in Alpha. They have shut down almost every team this season and they both rack up the PDs and INTs which is the key stats for a CB. And tackles aren't always a bad thing for a CB when they are playing 80 plays a game IMHO.


I second this.

Not only because I'm a Pa Dong Dragon, but because my FS couldn't get any FUCKING stats because of those asshole CBs

Only 2 PDs, and no INTs.

I did get a DefTD, but that was off a FF.
Last edited Oct 22, 2008 00:00:42
 
HeresTo14
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by creeker22
I like the idea, but I kind of feel that it may be too late to get everything set up, but if anyone wants to put in the effort and create a voting ballot and such for owners/GMs to vote on, I would be down.


Not too late... the offseason always drags on a little while.

How are we going to do this? A couple of possible ideas:

1. Electoral College. Nomination threads for every position. Rules (1) each agent can nominate one player per position thread (2) No team can nominate more than 2/position from their own team, except only 1 for QB, HB, FB, TE, SS, FS, KR. NT and DT would be combined. (3) No agent can nominate their own player. Afterward, each team would have a voting representative that would meet in a private forum for a 1 day vote. After voting, we would arrange an All Pro and 2nd team and post it here.
(example nomination)
- G Willis (CB)
- Tackles = w, ints = x, PDs = y, forced fumbles = z
- Insert highlights here
- Pitch as to why that player is worthy of Pro Bowl

2. Two pollsters. Have two agents - one from Alpha and Zeta make a 4 player/position ballot. Each conference chooses an agent to do this. The alpha and zeta ballots are combined making it an 8 deep/position ballot. Take your ballot to your team forum where you can vote for two players/position. Return your ballot to me and I'll tally the votes and release a 1st and 2nd team All Pro Team.

3. All out voting. Nomination threads again, but this time they are voting threads. No agent can nominate/vote for their own player. Each team is limited to 5 votes per position thread - only 3 can be for their own teamates. Each team is limited to voting for 2 players/position on their own team, except only 1 for QB, HB, FB, TE, SS, FS, KR. Votes are tallied and a 1st and 2nd Pro Bowl Team is announced.

4. One Pollster. One agent makes a ballot 4 deep/position. All out voting limited to 5 votes/team. Votes are tallied and a 1st and 2nd Pro Bowl Team is announced.

Just trying to get the ball rolling on this one as I think it's a good idea. The number of votes & the rules above are completely abitrary and I'm open to suggestion.
Last edited Oct 22, 2008 06:21:03
 
Kirby~Cult~
offline
Link
 
Fats Mchenry G of the Pirates.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by HeresTo13
Originally posted by creeker22

I like the idea, but I kind of feel that it may be too late to get everything set up, but if anyone wants to put in the effort and create a voting ballot and such for owners/GMs to vote on, I would be down.


Not too late... the offseason always drags on a little while.

How are we going to do this? A couple of possible ideas:

1. Electoral College. Nomination threads for every position. Rules (1) each agent can nominate one player per position thread (2) No team can nominate more than 2/position from their own team, except only 1 for QB, HB, FB, TE, SS, FS, KR. NT and DT would be combined. (3) No agent can nominate their own player. Afterward, each team would have a voting representative that would meet in a private forum for a 1 day vote. After voting, we would arrange an All Pro and 2nd team and post it here.
(example nomination)
- G Willis (CB)
- Tackles = w, ints = x, PDs = y, forced fumbles = z
- Insert highlights here
- Pitch as to why that player is worthy of Pro Bowl

2. Two pollsters. Have two agents - one from Alpha and Zeta make a 4 player/position ballot. Each conference chooses an agent to do this. The alpha and zeta ballots are combined making it an 8 deep/position ballot. Take your ballot to your team forum where you can vote for two players/position. Return your ballot to me and I'll tally the votes and release a 1st and 2nd team All Pro Team.

3. All out voting. Nomination threads again, but this time they are voting threads. No agent can nominate/vote for their own player. Each team is limited to 5 votes per position thread - only 3 can be for their own teamates. Each team is limited to voting for 2 players/position on their own team, except only 1 for QB, HB, FB, TE, SS, FS, KR. Votes are tallied and a 1st and 2nd Pro Bowl Team is announced.

4. One Pollster. One agent makes a ballot 4 deep/position. All out voting limited to 5 votes/team. Votes are tallied and a 1st and 2nd Pro Bowl Team is announced.

Just trying to get the ball rolling on this one as I think it's a good idea. The number of votes & the rules above are completely abitrary and I'm open to suggestion.


I say either all out voting or pollsters. W/ the electoral college approach, you'd only get a handful of votes, since some teams aren't active here.
 
SlayerB
offline
Link
 
All I know is my teams WR BigC should definitely make it... He is in his second season leading the league in both TD's and Yards for WR's...
 
shadow46x2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by creeker22
I say Topdog and Shut Downs are 2 of the top CBs in Alpha. They have shut down almost every team this season and they both rack up the PDs and INTs which is the key stats for a CB. And tackles aren't always a bad thing for a CB when they are playing 80 plays a game IMHO.


topdog?...

....seriously?

104 tackles in one season?....not to mention 7 missed tackles?

that's basically every QB in the league nailing their passes to his mark on demand....

imo, that's not a good CB...that's a liability.....

--j

ps....and while, yes, your point about 80 plays a game does have *some* merit....not much, but some....the point is invalid when the guy isn't playing 80 plays per game....
Last edited Oct 22, 2008 21:07:03
 
HeresTo14
offline
Link
 
From the responses, I think "All Out Voting" would be interesting... First thread will be QBs. I'm going to start it in a second.

Rules:
1. Can't nominate your own player
2. 5 Votes per Team
3. 1 Vote per agent
4. Only 3 Votes for your own teamates
5. Arguing is encouraged

Two agents from each conference will attempt to make sure voting is fair. Please use the example nomination below. After a player is already nominated, a +1 or a simple quote of the nomination will act as a vote. Adding to the reason why a player should win is encouraged.

(example nomination/vote)
- Player A (QB)
- TDs = v, Yards = w, Ints = x, Completion % = y, QB Rating = z.
- Insert highlights here
- Pitch as to why that player is worthy of Pro Bowl

I'd suggest that you get together on your team forum to make sure your five votes are well used. If you want to retract a vote, either delete your post or have a GM or owner pm me.

Last edited Oct 23, 2008 06:44:44
 
shadow46x2
offline
Link
 
so um....creeker...

how'd those "2 of the top CBs in Alpha" do?

--j
 
SLZmonster
offline
Link
 
C Crosby, doesn't have the pancakes stacekd up like some...but nobody gets by him!
 
SportsFrk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by shadow46x2
so um....creeker...

how'd those "2 of the top CBs in Alpha" do?

--j


Their QB had no passing TDs, and the 2 CBs had 5 combined PDs and 8 tackles.

Pretty decent, I'd say.
 
shadow46x2
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sportsfrk51790
Originally posted by shadow46x2

so um....creeker...

how'd those "2 of the top CBs in Alpha" do?

--j


Their QB had no passing TDs, and the 2 CBs had 5 combined PDs and 8 tackles.

Pretty decent, I'd say.


don't forget the 2 missed tackles

--j
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SLZmonster
C Crosby, doesn't have the pancakes stacekd up like some...but nobody gets by him!


Truthfully, pancakes are a worthless stat to judge a OL by. You need to be on a dominant running team to rack those up.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.